News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by belorn on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:11PM (#42938762)
A lot of people like to focus very exclusive on the aspect if its top-down, with the implied message being that censorship is acceptable as long its done by companies or community leaders rather than government. Yes, it is worse when it is done by governments. But no, it doesn't make censorship acceptable. So much debate happens because some people view all censorship as bad, that is rules intended to inhibit speech and shutdown wrong-thinking, while others want to distinguish between government censorship and "good" censorship. As someone who stand in the "all censorship as bad" category, there is no good censorship! Only grades of wrong.

Different wrongness do get compare. That doesn't make very very very wrong to be equivalent to just very wrong. Both are however wrong. The kind of censorship and self-censorship we have seen in science, popular media and even humor in the last few decades has been insane compared to the decades previous. To throw in a random example, someone who criticized religion was murdered a few days ago in Sweden, and as a society we kind just expected it and waiting for it to happen. Something like Monty Python could not exist today as they would had either been censored or murdered, and so they would have been forced to self-censor long before their skills as comedians would have grown.

Censorship is not something we can pick and choose from.

Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by philipov on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @04:13PM (#42938800)
Then you agree that what's going on now is wrong, and there's no need to bring up lesser wrongs to distract us from that.
Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by belorn on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:59PM (#42940376)
> Then you agree that what's going on now is wrong

Obviously yes. Censorship is not something we can pick and choose from.

> and there's no need to bring up lesser wrongs to distract us from that.

There would not be a need for that if people agreed that censorship is wrong. As long people see some censorship as good, rather than a lesser wrongs, the trend of ever more censorship will just continue and this kind of events will continue to occur and at larger scope. Censorship is a kind of political violence that once accepted only expands until the social rules totally breaks apart. It can't exit as just a rule for the government, it must be something that people inherently support as a concept.

Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by burkaman on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @05:08PM (#42939648)
Voluntarily choosing not to say something is preference, not self-censorship. For example, some people choose not to swear because they don't like swears. That is just a preference, self-censorship is when you want to swear but don't because of external pressure.

Nobody was forced to stop using master/slave, some companies just chose not to because that was their preference. They didn't want to use the word slave anymore. It's reasonable to call it pointless or performative, but I don't think any of the decision-makers at these companies were forced into it. Most companies did not change anything, and they faced absolutely no consequences.

I'm sure there were some (for example) GitHub employees who didn't agree with the decision and maybe felt censored, but basically every company on the planet has standards for language in the workplace, so in that sense every company is guilty of censorship. GitHub did not force any of its users to do anything, you could still use whatever language you want, and you can search "slave" right now to see how common it still is.

Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday February 04, 2025 @11:23PM (#42943761)
> GitHub

Let's not mix up issues though.

Removing 'master' in git has much less justification than removing master/slave terminology.

Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by orf on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @03:56AM (#42945849)
Nobody removed “master” from git though
Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @04:00AM (#42945893)
https://github.com/github/renaming

https://www.theserverside.com/feature/Why-GitHub-renamed-its...

They did stuff. Plenty qualifies as "removing". (And I didn't say they reached out and changed the entire world.)

And unlike master/slave, it's fake inclusivity.

Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by orf on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @04:11AM (#42945970)
Nobody removed “master” from git though
Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @05:18AM (#42946475)
They did (and encouraged) a lot of "removing".

Which is different from saying they "removed", because "removed" sounds like 100% removal. They didn't 100% remove, but that's not my argument, only a strawman of it.

So will you meet me at what I actually meant, or are you going to insist on your own wording that doesn't actually rebut me?

Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by orf on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @05:38AM (#42946633)
Git isn’t GitHub. GitHub changed the default for GitHub, didn’t touch existing projects and made it optional for projects to switch.
Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @05:49AM (#42946726)
I didn't say they did anything to mainline git's source code.

Hell, I didn't even say they accomplished their goal. I just criticized the goal, not just for github but for everyone else doing the same thing. And the goal is about git repos. Lots of those are on github, and lots of those are influenced by the things github did.

TL;DR: Lots of people removed "master" from git repos.

Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by philipov on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @09:30AM (#42948933)
> Lots of people removed "master" from git repos.

So because a lot of people chose to no longer use "master" in their git repos, it justifies an authoritarian rollback of science and health? No one cares what their git branches are called. Get that stupid chip off your shoulder and smell the fire. The country is burning.

Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by Dylan16807 on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @03:06PM (#42954350)
What the hell are you talking about? I never made any comparison between those.

(I sure hope you're not just complaining that I'm wasting words on it while more important things are happening in the world, because that's pure hypocrisy and applies to 99-100% of comments on this site. "Never do anything unimportant" is a terrible motto. So is "never complain about anything minor".)

Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by zzo38computer on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @05:24PM (#42956169)
Yes, I think that it is good that they did not touch existing projects. (Much of the complaints (including my own complaints) when it was announced were due to ignorance of the working of git and of GitHub; once I learned how it is working then I do not have complaints about it.)

Even for new projects, if you create a empty repository on GitHub and then send a repository from your own computer, it will work with whatever branch name you give it, at least in my experience (I had sent repositories with the only branch named "trunk" and it seems to cause no problems at all as far as I can tell).

Neither git nor GitHub software cares what the branches are called as far as I know; I think they just changed the default settings if you are creating a repository using GitHub, but you are not required to use them.

And, actually, I read the documentation and you can even make per-user settings on GitHub, and you can change the default branch name for git itself too (and, like in GitHub, this setting can also be changed in git).

They also added the function to rename branches (you can rename any branch, not only the default branch), and they provide documentation about how this is working, so this is a side benefit of their work on this, in case it is sometimes useful to rename branches (although I think probably it is usually better not to rename existing branches, maybe sometimes it might be useful).

Furthermore, "main" is shorter than "master", and starts with the same two letters; but in my opinion, these are minor benefits (although they are still beneficial anyways).

However, even though I think this is good, this does not imply that all software that used "master" and changed it, were doing good. In many cases they weren't good, but git (and GitHub) isn't one of them that isn't good. The reasons why it is good or not good have to do with the existing working of the software and of working of names, and how the changes are being handled, and is not because of racism and stuff like that.

Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by burkaman on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @10:29AM (#42949859)
The justification is irrelevant. You can think it's as dumb as you want to, it still isn't censorship if nobody is being forced to do anything.
Re:Words Now Forbidden in the Free Speech United States of A... by SV_BubbleTime on Wednesday February 05, 2025 @03:23PM (#42954596)
Are you pretending that the previous administrations did not lean on tech companies to directly censor speech - or do you really not know?