Its like trying to argue that money are not property, just representation of property.
Same thing with contracts: a contract is a relationship. The signed piece of paper is not the contract, but proof that a contract exists.
It's just a case of Procrustean bedding to act like all property (or rights bundles isomorphic thereto) must be physical.
Except the ones that do. You're right; most don't by default, but if you DO have valid paper certificate, it is a bearer instrument. Who owns it, owns it.
The preferred example would be futures, and oddly enough, something I also think is a scam.
Somebody who owns their own company can be thought of as equivalently having 100% of its stock.
Don't see what's "a scam" about it, but I'd love to hear your thorough analysis on the matter.
[1] The stock certificate doesn't count; that's a representation of the property, not the property itself.