Re:Even experts get it wrong
by michaelcampbell on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @02:19PM
(#4292243)
> Most exchanges and corporations don't even go by a paper certificate,
Except the ones that do. You're right; most don't by default, but if you DO have valid paper certificate, it is a bearer instrument. Who owns it, owns it.
Which is to say, that the physical piece of paper is not a defining characteristic of property in stocks (even one case would mean that paper is not inherently part of stock ownership), just as physical stuff is not necessary in many other kinds of property.
Same thing with contracts: a contract is a relationship. The signed piece of paper is not the contract, but proof that a contract exists.
It's just a case of Procrustean bedding to act like all property (or rights bundles isomorphic thereto) must be physical.