News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by arcticbull on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:49AM (#42885819)
Corporate tax is quite misunderstood in my opinion.

Tesla makes revenue, and they have costs. Their revenues are offset by their costs.

Any profit Tesla makes is eventually taxed -- either when Tesla shareholders sell appreciated stock, when the company makes distributions or when they liquidate.

Corporate tax only applies to un-distributed profits carried forward from year to year instead of invested into the business or distributed to shareholders.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by dxuh on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:01AM (#42885901)
I have income and I have costs. Why is my income not completely offset by my costs? I'd love to spend more money to pay fewer taxes. My labor is turned into profits for my employer and similarly their profit is eventually taxed. In that sense my labor doesn't have to be taxed directly either. Why is it? I think it's absurd that one the hand they are reporting revenue to shareholders and on the other hand they are reporting no profits to tax authorities. Am I misunderstanding something here? I think it's an arbitrary choice that people are supposed to pay for the expenses of the state and corporations are not. I don't think that's a good choice, but that's partially subjective.
Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:06AM (#42885938)
> it's absurd that one the hand they are reporting revenue to shareholders and on the other hand they are reporting no profits to tax authorities. Am I misunderstanding something here?

Yes and no. It's clearly an abuse of the tax code. But the idea that a company would have different books for the IRS and itself is no different than you probably having a different set of "books" for your household budget and tax filings. They're held to different standards of precision and serve different purposes.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by ksec on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:40AM (#42886137)
Because part of their cost is to pay for your income. You also get Tax deduction on certain "cost" as well. Just not everything.

> My labor is turned into profits for my employer and similarly their profit is eventually taxed.

Your labour is tuned into revenue first. There are plenty of companies burning through cash for 10 years before making a single cent of profits.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by BlackFly on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:04AM (#42885920)
It's not misunderstood.

People also have costs some of which are tax deductible, yet their income is seen to be completely taxed before costs are deducted. In both personal and corporate taxes, some costs are deductible and others not. People understand this.

The point is that people find it a violation of norms how a company can arrange its taxes in a way that a salaried individual basically never can: to basically not pay any taxes while enriching some specific people more than others.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by nicce on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:56AM (#42885862)
> either when Tesla shareholders sell appreciated stock, when the company makes distributions or when they liquidate.

Feels like a fatal flaw in the law if you can bypass paying the corporate taxes in that way.

That is individual tax - not the tax payed by the corporation. Normally the tax is payed twice. Tax from the corporation profits and then the individual employee/shareholder tax based on their income.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:58AM (#42885880)
> Normally the tax is payed twice. Tax from the corporation profits and then the individual employee tax based on their income.

Payroll tax is the second check you're looking for. Tesla is almost certainly fucking around. But the concept of taxing corporate profits--versus earnings--is solid. You massively favour high-margin (tech) over low-margin (manufacturing, service, anything with physical assets) and incumbents over new entrants if you tax the top line.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by Ekaros on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:18AM (#42886007)
It really comes to simple process lot of companies operate. They buy some materials, they spend some labour to refine it, sell it, ship it. And what is above all these costs is profit. Taxing them on what they sold for, is not really sensible say with fuel, a low margin product.

Now what can be called cost is very reasonable question. Clearly dividends or stock buybacks should not be costs. And thus such spending should only come from post tax money...

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:25AM (#42886048)
> Clearly dividends or stock buybacks should not be costs. And thus such spending should only come from post tax money

It does. Dividends and stock buybacks are not tax deductiable [1][2].

[1] https://www.thetaxadviser.com/issues/2022/sep/paying-dividen...

[2] https://www.grantthornton.com/insights/alerts/tax/2024/flash...

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by arcticbull on Friday January 31, 2025 @06:06AM (#42886582)
> Taxing them on what they sold for, is not really sensible say with fuel, a low margin product.

That's what SF instituted with Prop C -- only to see an exodus of low margin tech companies.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by arcticbull on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:57AM (#42885875)
At least today the corporate tax rate is 21%. Individual tax rates in California are as high as like 52%. In almost every scenario you'll see a higher rate on the distributions and buybacks than you would carrying it forward to the following year.

I guess you could make a case for double-taxation but... why?

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by throwaway2037 on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:00AM (#42885891)

    > Individual tax rates in California are as high as like 52%.
Is that a marginal tax rate (not very useful for comparison) or an effective tax rate? Also, can you explain why income level is required to achieve 52% "individual tax rate"?
Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by arcticbull on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:02AM (#42885909)
Yes, the top marginal rate is 37% federal + 13.3% state + 0.9% surtax -- and note the state tax is generally double-taxed at this income level thanks to the SLPT cap.

Can it also be an effective rate, yes, pretty close anyways.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by throwaway2037 on Friday January 31, 2025 @09:44AM (#42888161)
At what personal income level does this top marginal rate apply? 250K? 500K? 1M?
Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by s1artibartfast on Friday January 31, 2025 @11:19AM (#42888991)
Income from a corporate entity is taxed twice by the time it gets to an individual. If I own a corporation and live in California, first I pay 21% on the profits and then 52% on what is left before it gets to my bank account.

At these rates, This means the government takes 72 cents out of every dollar of profit.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by notTooFarGone on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:52AM (#42885838)
Oh yea share buybacks are very nice costs for a lot of companies.

Then you can also take loans based off of that to make sure you never have to pay taxes again.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by arcticbull on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:53AM (#42885840)
Those are taxable events for the people who sell the shares Tesla is buying back.

> Then you can also take loans based off of that to make sure you never have to pay taxes again.

You can borrow against the after tax amount yes, you'll pay interest on it and when you die, you will pay the capital gains. On your final tax return, you are required to pay taxes on all of the capital gains you up to your departure. This resets the tax basis for your heirs.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by flipbrad on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:00AM (#42885894)
"Those are taxable events for the people who sell the shares Tesla is buying back."

But in which jurisdictions is that tax payable, and at what rates?

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by arcticbull on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:01AM (#42885899)
There's no general answer to that question. It depends on how long you held it for, where you're resident, and your specific circumstances.
Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by croes on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:59AM (#42885888)
So in politics companies are people but in taxes they are not?

Or why do I have to pay taxes instead of nothing because I invest in my company aka me?

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by jpc0 on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:06AM (#42885939)
To be fair you are welcome to incorporate and follow all the rules regarding what is actually business expenses vs private and most of your expenses can also be tax free.

But I doubt your employer will be too happily to now pay your salary as an invoice to a subcontractor...

You may find it's easier to just pay tax... Also look up effective tax rate vs actual tax rate...

I know many people who despite having a significant portion of their salary being taxes, when you look at their Revenue and Expenses for a given 12 month period they in fact paid no tax.

Your specific situation may be different, but you aren't a corporation.

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by throwaway2037 on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:58AM (#42885879)
My sense about Tesla: They have nearly all of their R&D in the United States, but they have large global footprint with very large factories in Germany and China. I think a lot of the US-based R&D costs can by used to offset US-based income. Also, does "income" mean "profits" in this context? It is unclear to me. They did not clearly define the term.
Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by JumpCrisscross on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:01AM (#42885905)
> does "income" mean "profits" in this context?

Net income. The article's $2.3bn 2024 "U.S. income" lines up with Tesla's (global) $2.32bn net income (on $1.6bn operating income) [1].

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2025/01/29/tesla-tsla-2024-q4-earnings....

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by aqme28 on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:57AM (#42885876)
Yes, but that’s not the whole picture. If the value of the company goes up, shareholders capture value as capital gains which has a very low tax rate.
Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by arcticbull on Friday January 31, 2025 @03:59AM (#42885885)
Low... ish... depending on where you are. Short term gains are taxed as ordinary income, long-term gains are taxed up to 20% (already the corporate rate) and states like California treat it as ordinary income exposing you to another up to 13.3%
Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by aqme28 on Friday January 31, 2025 @10:18AM (#42888511)
It's still never higher than income tax, which is what the parent comment was comparing to.
Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by ahiknsr on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:01AM (#42885902)
> Tesla makes revenue, and they have costs. Their revenues are offset by their costs.

FTA

> Tesla saved half a billion in taxes last year using accelerated depreciation. Tax breaks for executive stock options shaved a quarter billion off the company’s tax bill. Unspecified “U.S. tax credits” were good for $300 billion of tax savings.

what about the tax breaks and tax credits?

> Corporate tax is quite misunderstood in my opinion.

No. You are missing the point. Why does one of the most valuable companies in the world need a quarter billion tax break? This is a rhetorical question by the way, cause I'm confident the answer is going to be 'corporate tax is complicated, Tesla is following the same rules as everyone'

Re:Tesla Reported Zero Federal Income Tax on $2B of U.S. Inc... by Terr_ on Friday January 31, 2025 @04:02AM (#42885907)
> Corporate tax is quite misunderstood in my opinion.

Yeah, it's mechanically different from individual income taxes, but in general Americans don't know how taxes work.

I mean, I've had coworkers in the past who still believed that if you made juuust enough money to enter a new income tax bracket, you'd actually have less take-home than before.