News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Even experts get it wrong by jere on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @08:20AM (#4285329)
>And yet, the technology in question is a system that stops people from pirating their software and helps them make money. Well if you think it's so unfair, don't use the tech. Do something else. No one is forcing you to use the technology.

Bullshit. Mojang isn't using Uniloc's tech. They're writing their own tech using a bloody obvious idea.

Re:Even experts get it wrong by jcromartie on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @09:03AM (#4285467)
Not to mention Uniloc doesn't even have technology. They do not create or sell software.
Re:Even experts get it wrong by jere on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @09:18AM (#4285511)
I was going to respond by playing devil's advocate and defending Ric and Uniloc. But a quick glance at their site proves you absolutely right. Here are some gems:

Uniloc's surprising honesty:

>And it fits our straightforward development model. Look at many ideas. Pick an outstanding one. Patent it. Commercialize it. Reap the rewards.

Uniloc's vast knowledge of technology:

>After all, Bell Labs did develop some fairly transformative technology like radio astronomy, the transistor, the laser and the UNIX programming language.

Re:Even experts get it wrong by Vivtek on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @11:31AM (#4286087)
These are the same people whose patent claim addresses Mojang's well-known product Mindcraft, so a little illiteracy obviously isn't costing them much on the bottom line.
Re:Even experts get it wrong by jcromartie on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @12:23PM (#4286337)
Hah. Someone who thinks UNIX is a programming language is obviously not intimately involved with building real technology.
Re:Even experts get it wrong by mitchty on Friday July 27, 2012 @11:38AM (#4301924)
I find it odd that lawyers, who use language to such an exacting degree they have effectively created their own dialect of English, have so much factually wrong information written on their own site.
Re:Even experts get it wrong by eli on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @12:31PM (#4286387)
Devil's Advocate mode

They create a market for patents which benefits everyone who invents something and patents it. If your startup has a useful patent then (even if you never use the patent) your company is made more valuable because trolls like this exist. Investors will consider how much that patent is worth on the market when valuing your company.

And how would you implement a system that prohibits patent troll behavior? Only the original inventor gets to own the patent? Only people using the technology are allowed to own the patent? Define "using." What if I invent something truly novel and would rather license it to established players instead of bringing it to market myself?

Re:Even experts get it wrong by wtracy on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @07:54PM (#4288709)
I've certainly seen the proposal raised that you should lose a patent if you don't bring it to market.
Re:Even experts get it wrong by repsilat on Wednesday July 25, 2012 @07:54AM (#4290423)
The usual counter-argument is meant to go that companies full of smart people should be able to think up clever inventions all day and sell them to people who know how to build and market them. I'm not sure it really pans out in reality, though.
Re:Even experts get it wrong by talmand on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @10:51AM (#4285905)
Exactly, my stance on software patents is that they do not necessarily cover the coder's method, it creates an entitlement to the result. Almost every software patent I've seen doesn't mention specific code, it just covers the result. Meaning no one can ever come up with a similar system without the threat of being sued for patent infringement. So, even if someone had a better way to make a similar system, they more than likely will get sued. "I have a patent that covers software that checks licenses over a network; therefore you can never make software that checks licenses over a network without paying me money." How does that allow for someone to do "something else"?
Re:Even experts get it wrong by usea on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @01:10PM (#4286650)
This isn't actually true. The summary of a patent is usually very broad, but if you read the full text it is very specific as to the method being patented. Media outlets portray patents as covering an entire concept, but really they only cover a narrow implementation of a concept.
Re:Even experts get it wrong by emmett on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @02:00PM (#4287018)
Actually, this is often quite true for software patents. For a famous example, the Amazon one-click patent.

It shouldn't be true, but it is, because patent examiners have done a very poor job screening software patents historically.