News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by stellar678 on Monday July 23, 2012 @11:49AM (#4281541)
Am I the only person who really enjoys YouTube comments? It's obviously not the place to go for high-brow discussion.

But the fact that it's a no-holds-barred space means that occasionally some genuinely hilarious and unexpected stuff pops up. I really wouldn't want that to change...

Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by Wilya on Monday July 23, 2012 @11:59AM (#4281594)
I like their blunt feel. If people don't like something, they will say so. Loudly. I find that a good thing. Plus, in my experience, they are not so bad. The number of rational and moderate people is quite higher than, for example, in newspaper websites comments.

On even moderately successful videos, they accumulate really too fast, though. They quickly become impossible to follow.

Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by eli on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:20PM (#4281718)
That's only because they added rudimentary voting a few years back. Do you remember what it was like before that?
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by TazeTSchnitzel on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:22PM (#4281730)
Personally I think YouTube should have HN/Reddit-style threaded comments, but I wonder how well that works for videos seen and commented on every day.
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by mitchty on Monday July 23, 2012 @04:01PM (#4282790)
They sorta do now with the in reply to link now. Its pretty bad though.
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by nwhitehead on Monday July 23, 2012 @01:56PM (#4282183)
Actually some subjects on YouTube do have high-brow discussion, they're just not the millions-of-views kinds of subjects. I did a bunch of videos on quantitative finance, the discussions on those often involve talking about calculus, questions about assumptions in financial models, etc. The comments actually add a lot of value to the videos.

One nice thing is that the anonymity means that real finance people can comment without worrying about their employer finding their comments. All the best financial discussion areas have to have good anonymity for participants to get people from industry involved.

Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by ImprovedSilence on Monday July 23, 2012 @04:10PM (#4282836)
Any chance you could provide a link to those videos? I'd be interested in checking them out.
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by roryokane on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @01:06AM (#4284419)
I found his YouTube channel with a little Googling. He's NathanWhitehead: http://www.youtube.com/user/NathanWhitehead.
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by modarts on Monday July 23, 2012 @07:45PM (#4283592)
I'd be interested in checking out your videos if you have a link lying around.
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by roryokane on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @01:07AM (#4284423)
See my reply to ImprovedSilence: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4284419.
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by WiseWeasel on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:02PM (#4281616)
What kills YouTube comments is the same thing that kills Ars comments, along with pretty much every blog ever; there's no threading and no peer moderation or ranking. No one wants to sort through a river of random comments.
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by CamperBob2 on Monday July 23, 2012 @07:46PM (#4283601)
Yet for some reason this model works well on Fark (and, I agree, nowhere else.)
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by groby_b on Monday July 23, 2012 @08:32PM (#4283733)
The entire point of Fark is to make off-topic, off-color remarks. So yes, for that, it works well :)
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by mey on Monday July 23, 2012 @08:41PM (#4283761)
This also explains how Reddit works so well
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by ramblerman on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @06:42AM (#4285100)
reddit has peer moderation and ranking. Which is why it works well, it's nothing like flat fark or youtube comments
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by twelvechairs on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:42PM (#4283895)
I came here to say exactly the same thing...
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by chimeracoder on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:44PM (#4281855)
If you ask me, the legendary reputation of trolling on Youtube comments is largely a relic of the past - you still have trolls, to some extent, but nowadays most videos' comments are closer to the trolls' comments on more mainstream subreddits, whereas before they seemed more like the fringes of 4chan.

I don't like this change. If you look at the top two comments on most videos (the two highest-rated comments), they tend to be funny at best, and lame-but-harmless jokes at worst. Not the crown jewel of the Internet by any means, but they've developed a culture of their own, and I dislike the idea of disrupting that with seemingly no reason (other than to create a "unified" identity).

Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by dinkumthinkum on Monday July 23, 2012 @11:11PM (#4284193)
I think it is a good reminder how awful and diseased humans really are. Nothing makes for a better case for the concept of letting humanity go as YouTube comments. I think if we lost YouTube comments as they are, we would lose that reality check and begin deluding ourselves. :)
Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by ericdykstra on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:56PM (#4281901)
YouTube comments on videos where there's a new page of comments every time you refresh are awful, and not worth paying attention to. On a lot of types of videos, comments add absolutely nothing.

The one exception I've found is for music, where the plays on the video are between 10,000 and 500,000 or so. The discussion is pertinent and sometimes interesting, and I've had a couple of good back-and-forths on those kinds of videos.

I'm not sure if adding real names will help expand the number of videos where discussion is decent, but I don't think it will hurt.

Re:Google Begins Practically Begging You to Use Your Real Na... by vipervpn on Monday July 23, 2012 @04:50PM (#4283007)
There's a Jerry Springer quality to the comments, which isn't all bad. Sometimes I'll go to read them for a laugh.