Remember that 2000 years ago is 24AD, the middle of the Roman empire and Han dynasty which covered half of the world population. Nobles would be literate and well educated, artisans and soldiers would be skilled, and I bet there were lots of smart peasants that got ignored.
They wouldn't do well on intelligence tests because not used to it, but that is more about tests than their intelligence. I'm sure that the average intelligence is lower than now from lack of education and malnutrition. Smart ones would still be smart. Also, I bet people from now would do poorly in their environment.
Such that my question mostly still stands? Again, I'm largely inline with the view that this will be difficult to test. However, I'm also comfortable in saying that you can tell intelligence levels between people. Again, with a caveat that I don't think it is reducible to a single number. (Such that I think I also think it is fair to say most views of intelligence, in the colloquial sense, are not transitive.)
As an example, as much as I loved my grandparents, I have zero difficulty saying that a few of them would never be able to score as well on some problem solving tests as a few of the kids in the current generation. At the same time I know some people in their 80s that I will never be able to compare with. Again, I don't expect it is a straight line, along the time axis. I also don't know that I agree that every person 2000 years ago just didn't do calculus because they weren't taught it.
To my awareness, there is nothing in the fossil record to suggest that an anatomically modern human (Homo sapiens), which may have first emerged as much as 500,000 years ago, would be distinguishable from currently living humans. Here's a thought experiment: We have a time machine. We travel back 500k years and abduct a pair of Homo sapiens (male and female). We transport them forward in time to our present. We cause them to breed and produce offspring. During gestation, they live in a modern environment (nutrition, shelter, etc.). At birth we take the newborn infant and give it to a modern, contemporaneous couple to raise. Is there is reason to believe it (the infant) would not emerge as a normal, modern adult?
If there is no reason, what does that imply about intelligence? Is knowledge separable from it? Or is knowledge a necessary component of it? Or is knowledge itself "intelligence"? For my part, I think it is a distinct attribute, but I assign a low probability to that belief.
Again, I am largely agreed with the idea. But, evidence is not as clear cut. We had entire civilizations that never utilized wheels. Writing was not universal across all humanity.
Would I prefer that it is only access to technology that confers advantages that we see in developing thought? Absolutely. I'm not able to categorically assume it, though.
Because we have intellectual artefacts from that time that show us. Artefacts that underlay much of modern society, and that in many respects still hold up, even though we've built upon them for 20 generations.
I don't think I've come across any evidence suggesting that the human brain has changed the last 2000 years. After all, the Great Pyramid of Giza was built 4600 years ago. That construction required fairly advanced engineering. That's sort of beside the point though.
To go back to my original comment, there is some distinction to be made between knowledge and intelligence. Even those should probably be decomposed into further salient attributes. And modern LLMs seem to capture some of those attributes, but do not yet strike me as "intelligent" in the way the average human is intelligent, but the average dog is not.
I don't know, maybe I am conflating sentience or consciousness or embodiment or something else with intelligence.
And, I get it, most kids that are "gifted" at super young age all somewhat converge with where others were going to get in a few years time. But I don't think we fully appreciate just how early we are able to get our kids reading across the board. Do we have evidence that you could get a mediocre teacher to prehistoric classrooms and have them get kids reading as well as we do on the regular today?
And, quickly, as I say in sibling posts, I was taking "2000" to be a shorthand for absurdly old. My general question, there, is do you not think we are getting smarter?
I realize this is a hazard of discussions, as most people seem to think this somehow logically leads to every terrible take it could. I don't agree with those. I do fully think that my children will net be smarter and stronger than me in most every way. I'd expect that my grandchildren will continue that trend. It seems to me that thinking otherwise is to either think that evolution has stopped with us, or that we have stagnated for other reasons?
Aristotle was like 2,400 years ago, for context lol
I get that evolution takes generations. But, it actually moves rather fast for some things, no?
Rather fast is like millions of years in evolutionary terms so 2,000 years is nothing. I don’t even think there’s significant evidence to show that Neanderthals were less intelligent than Homo sapiens and they were around from 400,000 years ago to 40,000 years ago or so. Human brains and also brain-body mass ratio wouldn’t have changed enough to make much of a noticeable difference if you teleport a human baby from thousands of years ago to today and put them through our education system.
It’s just easier to dismiss them as stupid because very little of their life has survived til today.
To the point, I mentioned that Aristotle was 2,400 years ago and you still landed on “largely compatible” lol. The pyramids were built over 4,000 years ago and they’re still a marvel of engineering. You just have a bias against people from thousands of years ago again mostly because a lot of their work didn’t survive to modern day.
My general question is largely the same, though. Do you think we haven't evolved with more intelligence since proto-human periods? Because that seems to be the claim, that we somehow evolved intelligence, and it has been solely knowledge acquisition since then. I suspect that is defensible, but feels off to me.
And my nitpicks would be that evolution isn't measured in years, but generations. And moves more rapidly when pressure on a population is stronger. Seeing how autistic so many "smart" people act, I confess I would expect more negative pressure on those behaviors in the past.
And no, I don’t think there’s a noticeable difference in terms of intelligence between us and someone from 30,000 years ago or even something more extreme like 300,000 years ago. We’re still the same species after all.
I do think you’d be more open to that idea if we had records of their thoughts and ideas. The early humans who came up with epic tales and the explorers who went on grand expeditions to unexplored territories. The people who used an early scientific method to come up with ways to preserve food or figure out what plants were safe to eat. The people who figured out better ways to build clothing for extreme weather. These weren’t dumb people.
To that general idea, I similarly have zero issue with claiming some dogs are dumber than other dogs. They obviously all fail at what we would call language skills, in they can form a rudimentary problem solving ability just fine.
And, I can't remember what thread I said it in, but I do stress this isn't a transitive property. It is a lot like someone can be better at sports than someone else, but worse specifically at a specific sport.
I largely empathize with your point. But, as I can recognize there are some out there far better at problem solving than I am, I am growing ok with the idea that intelligence can be measured. Not to a single number, most likely, but to a variety of different aspects.
Similarly, I'd imagine that a human from 2000 years ago is probably more hardy than one from the modern age. If only because of selection effects at play.
Obviously, you can't extrapolate a straight line between either measurement and expect it to continue in either direction. But I don't know why you couldn't build up a measurement for it?
(And it should go without saying that you shouldn't be judging worth using this sort of measurement.)