News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by tocomment on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:07AM (#4280724)
What always goes through my mind when I imagine buying one of these is, "my laptop battery died after two years". How do I know the same thing won't happen with this car? If not two years, what happens to this car in 5 years, 10 years?

Is there any guarantee this car will be drivable in 10 years? Is there even a process for replacing the battery? What would it cost?

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by Peroni on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:21AM (#4280793)
The tesla battery costs approximately $40k to purchase and replace. There was widespread coverage of Tesla Roadsters being 'bricked'. Essentially more than a few Roadster owners reported that if the car was left sitting idle for more than a month or so it was rendered useless as the battery requires a constant trickle feed of electricity if parked up over a long period of time.

It was discussed at length here on HN too:

http://theunderstatement.com/post/18030062041/its-a-brick-te...

http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3618946

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by rjsamson on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:54AM (#4280947)
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by Peroni on Monday July 23, 2012 @10:36AM (#4281173)
You may wish to have another read of some of your sources which clearly indicate that Tesla's can be bricked.

The argument is not about how easy they are to brick, it's about the fact that the entire car is rendered useless if bricked unless you're willing to pay $40k to get your vehicle back on the road again.

If the cars were easy to brick there would be a significantly larger number of documented cases than what currently exist.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by pbreit on Monday July 23, 2012 @07:50PM (#4283615)
While it's safe to assume the Model S could be bricked, we actually don't know. And if it is suitably difficult to brick, it is no different from a regular car being rendered inoperable due to mis-maintenance. Finally, 10 years of decent use would outdo many Audis (certainly my own).
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by Peroni on Tuesday July 24, 2012 @10:11AM (#4285738)
Correct. My statements are with the Roadster.

Claims that bricking is caused by mis-maintenance are false. leaving a car idle for a few months in secure storage isn't mis-maintenance. The requirement to leave the Tesla on a trickle charge is almost completely obfuscated in the guidelines and Tesla purposely downplay the information.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by jsvaughan on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:38AM (#4280868)
This is just FUD. This is nothing to do with Tesla, and just the case with most battery chemistries. Even if the article is true, it has only happened to 0.2% of Tesla cars and it would be solved by a £15 solar charger.

More relevant comments on slashdot

http://hardware.slashdot.org/story/12/02/23/0310255/why-tesl...

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by Peroni on Monday July 23, 2012 @10:31AM (#4281142)
...it has only happened to 0.2% of Tesla cars

In the automotive industry, 0.2% is a huge figure for concern.

The comment you linked is in itself factually incorrect. Firstly, when a Tesla battery dies, towing isn't even an option. The vehicle has to be completely lifted from it's spot and placed on a truck as the wheels can't be released on a dead Tesla.

Secondly, it misses the semantics of the claim. It's not about battery failure, it's about how the battery itself discharges over a prolonged period of time as Teslas, even whilst switched off and completely stationary, require a minor amount of power which progressively drains the cells.

After a period of time, the cells are entirely depleted and the structure of the Tesla battery means they can't be recharged and require replacing entirely. It's been acknowledged that it's a fundamental flaw in the Tesla powerpack that has not yet been resolved.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by majorlazer on Monday July 23, 2012 @01:35PM (#4282081)
In response to your "towing isn't an option" comment, it most definitely is. Any decent tow truck driver will get that thing towed. Jack up the front end of the car, put a roller underneath, jack up the rear end, and winch it up the tow truck. My father used to tow cars and we would do this pretty often.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by pbreit on Monday July 23, 2012 @07:52PM (#4283616)
It should be stated that all of Peroni's claims apply to the Roadster and not necessarily the Model S.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by ghostfish on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:19AM (#4280781)
There is an 8 year warranty on the battery in a Model S, with mileage depending on which capacity version you own.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by tocomment on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:31AM (#4280833)
Oh that's a start. It's still hard to swallow that a 50K+ car will be worthless in 8 years.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by base698 on Monday July 23, 2012 @10:47AM (#4281222)
I talked to a sales rep in one of their stores and they said the Roadster with the most mileage has 160K miles and the battery is still at 70% capacity. Not worthless but definitely less range.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by freehunter on Monday July 23, 2012 @02:24PM (#4282313)
160k miles isn't too much to sneeze at, and it's not unheard of for ICE cars to have 30% loss of power over that mileage. It still does hurt a bit thinking that you're buying a car with an expiration date built in, though.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by jguimont on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:57AM (#4280960)
People don't seem to remember that Tesla's car won't be consuming any gas for that 8 year period and that the only (almost) maintenance cost is changing the tires/breaks once in a while. Also the average ownership length [1] is less than 5 years.

Take all into consideration and a base Model S at 50k is closer to a 25-30k car.

Combine all the "not spent" gas and maintenance cost and you can very well afford a new battery 8 years down the road.

[1] http://www.kbb.com/car-news/all-the-latest/average-length-of...

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by bdfh42 on Monday July 23, 2012 @10:40AM (#4281188)
A lot of the "gas" you wont be spending money on would be because the range is pretty small.

Next weekend I will be hopping into a car that has sat outside the house doing nothing for a month or so and drive it 1,000 km to the South West of France. I will stop briefly on the way to fill up with fuel (10 minutes?). It will be dark for quite a lot of the time and the car will have the headlights on. Oh - it might even rain so the wipers might be needed. The journey should take about 12 hours including the section where we cross the English channel.

A couple of weeks later I will do the reverse journey. No fuss at all. How many days would it take to do the same journey in an electric car?

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by bryanlarsen on Monday July 23, 2012 @11:13AM (#4281352)
Answer: you rent a car.

If you go a month at a time without using your car, then the financially optimal number of cars to own is zero. Since you own more than zero cars, then your ownership is based on reasons other than financial ones.

Which overlaps nicely with Tesla owners: anybody who buys a $100,000 car is doing it for reasons other than financial ones. They just have different reasons than you do.

P.S. Not judging here. My wife owns a BMW, which is also more than just a way to get from point a to point b.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by moheeb on Monday July 23, 2012 @03:22PM (#4282615)
WRONG! "you rent a car" is not a unit of time!
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by danielweber on Monday July 23, 2012 @11:19AM (#4281371)
An electric car is completely inappropriate for that use.

Just the same as a Miata is inappropriate for a family of 6, or a smart car is inappropriate for guy who has to haul lumber, or a minivan is inappropriate for a single guy in his 20's.

Yet all of those cars sell enough to carve out markets for themselves.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by bdfh42 on Thursday July 26, 2012 @07:34AM (#4295460)
But all of those cars would make the same journey without any problems - you are confusing carrying capacity with the fundamental utility of the things we call cars.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by jguimont on Monday July 23, 2012 @10:53AM (#4281245)
That's a whole different discussion/argument by itself.

For most transportation 400km is plenty. That's a week of transport for my family and me.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by oh_sigh on Monday July 23, 2012 @08:45PM (#4283770)
Next weekend I will be digging an in-ground pool. I will use my backhoe and complete the digging in about 6 hours. No fuss at all.

How many days would it take to do the same digging with a spoon?

(unstated, but strongly implied point: Therefore, spoons are worthless)

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by rprasad on Monday July 23, 2012 @01:22PM (#4282027)
If someone can afford an electric car, especially a Tesla, they will probably just fly first-class to their destination, where they will undoubtedly have a second electric car waiting for them.

So my estimate would be about 1-2 hours.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by danielweber on Monday July 23, 2012 @11:21AM (#4281380)
Gas is about $1,000 a year, very roughly. (10000 miles @ 30 mpg @ $3 a gallon. You can of course change those numbers in either direction.)

8 years may not quite pay for a new battery. It depends if you can extract any value from the used one.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by rprasad on Monday July 23, 2012 @01:20PM (#4282018)
In California, where most fuel-efficient/electric cars are sold, gas ranges between $3.50-$4.00/gallon (or above $4.00 during periods of "high demand"). Gas in the areas targeted by Tesla (i.e., Beverly Hills) starts at $4.25 and goes up from there.

Also, very few cars on the road anywhere in the U.S. get close to 30mpg, excepting hybrids and 2012 or 2011 versions of some (but not all, or even most) smaller sedans. The most popular models of the most popular sedans of the last decade, i.e., the Camry, Accord, and Civic, do not get 30mpg--they tend average around 22-25mpg in real-world conditions. MPG is even worse among the luxury cars that compete with Tesla.

Consequently, the gas cost savings experienced by Tesla owners would be significantly greater than $1,000/year.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by danielweber on Monday July 23, 2012 @05:58PM (#4283268)
Where gas is more expensive, people will tend to have cars with higher MPGs.

MPG is even worse among the luxury cars that compete with Tesla

That's the key question. If someone is getting a Tesla because they care about mileage, they probably were not driving a 20 MPG car beforehand. If they were getting it to show off that they can afford a $100,000 car, then maybe they were.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by irq on Monday July 23, 2012 @08:13PM (#4283683)
Electricity isn't free. It is usually cheaper than gas, but it's still a significant cost to charge cars like this.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by c2 on Monday July 23, 2012 @10:04AM (#4280996)
Tesla Roadster's have been on the roads now for 6 years, and I think you'll find it is pretty hard to find one at any significant discount off it's MSRP.

Tesla also offered a $12000 replacement plan for the Tesla Roadsters, so you could get a fresh set of batteries if there was a failure.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by lsc on Monday July 23, 2012 @06:48PM (#4283442)
really? What kind of person spends that much on a car, then keeps it for 8 years?

I mean, Tesla, I think, did the right thing by going for the luxury market; people there are accustomed to considering a ten year old car essentially worthless. (Yeah, a ten year old BMW still runs, but for what you pay to keep it running, unless you have the auto repair hobby, well, you probably want to get a new one.)

Battery longevity is going to be a huge problem when these cars move to the economy market. But for the luxury market? I think that the technology is just fine. Using an 8 year old car, to them, would be like me using a cellphone from the '90s. (Personally, I think Tesla needs to be careful to provide luxury service; Charge a little more and roll that 8 year 'no questions' battery warranty into the purchase price. I mean, if I'm going to spend $100,000+ for a car? clearly I'm not trying to save money... but also clearly I expect a 'premium' experience. I mean, the nature of ridiculous high end cars is that they are less reliable than a Toyota, but the service had better be goddamn good.)

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by bdfh42 on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:10AM (#4280731)
I don't know the specifics of this model but most electric cars on the market come with a lease agreement for the batteries - you don't get to own them.

I also understand that the batteries need swapping in a lot less than 10 years.

Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by smackfu on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:10AM (#4280732)
Most cars only have a 5-year powertrain warranty anyways.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by Peroni on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:23AM (#4280800)
Your powertrain won't cost $40k to replace unlike Tesla batteries.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by smackfu on Monday July 23, 2012 @10:38AM (#4281179)
OTOH, replacing an engine does usually cost a good 70% of the value of the car, with labor and all.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by Peroni on Monday July 23, 2012 @10:43AM (#4281201)
Agreed however it's significantly more difficult to render a complete engine a write-off and most of the component parts can be individually replaced. Not so with Tesla.
Re:Tesla Model S review: A good first impression by bdfh42 on Monday July 23, 2012 @09:14AM (#4280752)
But there is a huge difference between the length of a warranty and one's reasonable expectation of a functional lifetime.

My last car only came with a 4 year warranty (now expired) but I bet it is still driving just fine in another 10 years.