News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy by rayiner on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:03AM (#4279483)
> The percentage of power generated from wind globally, currently, rounded to the nearest decimal place is zero.

This is just not true. I'm not sure what it is globally, but in the US it's several percent (which is not zero percent under any rounding I'm aware of). More to the point, it produces more than 10% of the electricity in five U.S. states. It's also the fastest-growing energy source in the world, even faster than natural gas.

> Trillions of dollars have been spent on windfarms and solar panels around the world, and, as the article notes, it has made zero difference to the overall energy mix.

Nowhere near "trillions of dollars" have been spent on wind farms. You're just making things up.

> Yet it has affected national economies in real ways - the bankruptcies in Germany, Spain and elsewhere have real costs, as does taking the most basic economic input - energy - and making it more expensive for zero environmental gain at the global level.

The bankruptcies in Germany, Spain, etc, are the fault of alternative energy?

> Despite the countless examples of failures to point to, the boosters insist that it's the right course, when any plain analysis shows the exact opposite.

The analysis of the "skeptics" almost always leaves out the vast externalized costs of traditional energy sources. E.g. if hundreds of billions of dollars of externalized costs from coal were factored into the price of coal, coal power would be more expensive than wind power: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dave-cooper/harvard-study-coal....

> But you have to be a starry-eyed believer who trusts in state-coerced solutions

There is nothing starry-eyed about the economists who point out that the free market naturally underproduces fundamental R&D. Pick up an Economics 101 book sometime.

Re:A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy by brc on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:28AM (#4279531)
- Globally wind power produced < 0.5% of energy last year. Most people forget, or don't realise, that the current obsession with alternative energy is limited to parts of Western Europe and parts of the USA. It has virtually no traction elsewhere in the world.

- You're right, I should have written billions instead of trillions, though I'd be surprised if it hasn't reached a trillion by now. It's still an insane amount of money.

- Bankruptcies in Germany and Spain by solar companies are very much the cause of bad policies - by pumping up a sector with unsustainable subsidies, then being forced to remove subsidies precisely because they are unsustainable. This creates a bubble into which resources rush, which then bursts and creates a lot of problems.

This is the fundamental problem, of trying to coerce a particular set of technologies into place when they aren't suitable for it. The correct response is to admit there is no current technical solution to affordable energy without burning stuff. There is a noisy subset of people who don't agree with this position, and that's fair enough. History has always proven that major advances come from unexpected areas, and tend to render prior technologies obselete almost overnight.

Re:A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy by rayiner on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:52AM (#4279587)
> Globally wind power produced < 0.5% of energy last year. Most people forget, or don't realise, that the current obsession with alternative energy is limited to parts of Western Europe and parts of the USA. It has virtually no traction elsewhere in the world.

Who cares about places that aren't Western Europe or the USA? Those places are technology followers. 15 years ago, the internet was only a statistically significant phenomenon in Western Europe and the USA. Yet other countries are now reaping the benefits of that technology. So to will be the case with energy technology.

> - Bankruptcies in Germany and Spain by solar companies are very much the cause of bad policies

This argument is non-sensical. STD's and babies are both caused by sex, that doesn't mean that STD's are the fault of babies.

> The correct response is to admit there is no current technical solution to affordable energy without burning stuff.

"Affordable" is a very relative term, especially when you look at true costs, including externalities, rather than just observed costs. Where I live (Illinois) wind power is approaching a factor of two of our average electricity price. Is that affordable? Almost certainly.

Re:A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy by Someone on Monday July 23, 2012 @05:09AM (#4280178)
"the current obsession with alternative energy is limited to parts of Western Europe and parts of the USA. It has virtually no traction elsewhere in the world"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wind_power_in_the_People%27s_Re...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_power_in_India

"The correct response is to admit there is no current technical solution to affordable energy without burning stuff"

And, from there, the correct conclusion must be that we should continue burning stuff at ever faster rates?

IMO, we should start using renewable sources ASAP, start using less energy, and work on energy-efficient ways to decrease the amount of greenhouse gases released (IMO, building factories to pump CO2 into the ground is not the best solution here)

Re:A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy by ghouse on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:44AM (#4279574)
These comments are not necessary exclusive. Parent said electricity while brc indicates globally wind power produced < 0.% of <energy>.

Of course, no thermal plant has been built in the US in the past 50 years without some subsidies -- both direct and indirect. So, it's a bit of a red-herring argument.

Re:A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy by rayiner on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:55AM (#4279600)
The "no subsidies" bit is really a massive red-herring.

Even without taxes, fossil fuels are hugely subsidized. The lack of effective legal frameworks to prevent e.g. coal plants from shifting the inherent costs of coal power onto people in surrounding neighborhoods is an implicit subsidy. Letting them shift $100 of environmental damage onto the residents of West Virginia is exactly the same as giving them a $100 check.

Re:A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy by ktizo on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:42AM (#4279571)
There are many available technical solutions, is just that the majority aren't as cheap as burning oil or gas yet, at least for most situations.
Re:A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy by rayiner on Monday July 23, 2012 @12:47AM (#4279582)
It's not just that. It's also that the majority aren't as heavily subsidized, both directly and indirectly, as burning coal or oil.

In the U.S. more than half our electricity comes from coal. When the enormous external costs of coal mining and burning are factored in (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dave-cooper/harvard-study-coal...) the per-kilowatt hour cost of coal should be more than double the artificially low cost we see today. And in certain parts of the country (particularly the midwest), wind power is already within a factor of two in price.

Re:A Skeptic Looks at Alternative Energy by vannevar on Monday July 23, 2012 @04:25AM (#4280084)
The analysis of the "skeptics" almost always leaves out the vast externalized costs of traditional energy sources.

Yes, this is the chief fallacy in the article and it deserves to be highlighted. Fossil fuels are even more heavily subsidized than alternative energy sources, but the subsidies are hidden in other expenses such as medical costs and drought-driven food prices. There is after all a reason that we're looking for alternative energy, and it's because we're finding the true cost of fossil fuels is much too high, regardless what the subsidized price may be.