My in-laws buy a lot of stupid stuff (IMHO) that saps their spending money. Do you think they're going to stop buying stupid little knick-knacks when they're retired? Probably not. Should they? Probably. But humans have a hard time changing their behavior.
So what this woman is proposing is to work with and solve the problems we have, not try to magically wish them away or pretend that we can easily change the behavior of the 400mil Americans overnight, and I tend to agree with her that it's a good idea.
It actually does take much more investment expertise than the average American has to know what a Vanguard Fund is, to know that it's a safe bet etc.
Why aren't basic finance classes taught in grade schools anymore? How hard is it for parents to teach their kids to save 10% of their income, and to put it into an IRA?
Edit: Before anyone points it out, I know the IRA is a relatively young investment vehicle (the 70's). Swap IRA for any sane long-term savings and retirement plan.
Nothing is without risk. This is, perhaps, the first financial investment lesson we should teach our children.
30 year US Treasurys are currently ~2.7%. Assuming someone saves 10% of their pre-tax income each month between the ages of 25 and 55, at that interest rate, they can look forward to 5 times their average annual income to sustain them through their last 20+ years of life. That's a 75% cut in income. Stocks are theoretically higher yield, but as others have argued, normal people shouldn't have to worry about stocks, and more importantly, there's a justified fear of market crash, which could be... appreciably lower return than Treasurys.
It should be possible to buy CDs at a few points above inflation. This was the historical norm. People shouldn't have to "invest" at all to preserve and modestly grow the value of their earnings. The vast majority of people have no business owning stocks or bonds. The only reason you can't get a decent interest rate is the crazy monetary policy of the last 40 years.
It's funny how most (all?) government policies result in a wealth transfer. If it's not directly buying goods and services from a corporation on behalf of the people, it's a policy to encourage the people to spend on one thing instead of another. There's nothing inherently wrong with that, but it's good to notice who stands to gain.
Name a historical period of longer than 15 years in which the market as a whole has lost money relative to inflation. That didn't even happen across the Great Depression.
http://www.angelfire.com/or/truthfinder/index14.html
http://www.dogsofthedow.com/dow1925cpilog.htm
Furthermore, market history did not begin in 1910 in the United States. Stock markets go back hundreds of years in many countries. A global long-view perspective is worth a lot more than 90 years of US data. And from that perspective "stocks for the long haul" have very often been a bad idea.
The figure I was remembering was actually about a 60/40 balanced stock+bonds fund like VBINX, which is what I'd recommend to anyone anyway.
That is valid even in the case of extreme inflation - like 1923 Germany. People suffered, but stocks didn't.
Only exception from that rule was the 70s oil shock, but that wasn't a real crisis (economy itself was doing just fine, only the oil became expensive for purely external political reasons).
If the internet became unavailable for a long time, it would be a very interesting situation regardless...during a calamity like that, you might be better off having all your money in real estate or other physical goods.
Ahistorical nonsense. "People USED to save! That's why people used to generally end up desperately poor when they were elderly, and also is why the US implemented Social Security."
>My advice to everyone: spend less. You're chucking great gobs of money at things that don't make you happy; just STOP DOING THAT and you will have enough to retire on by the time you're 50.
I'm glad to see a comment on Hacker News in which the author describes how amazingly thrifty he is and how irresponsible and shortsighted and stupid everyone else in the world is. It's been ages since anyone has posted anything along those lines and really helps our discussion of large-scale social issues.
I'm hardly a model of thrift.
Nah, sum up the premiums on what your insurance would cost at retirement age.
Meh, until the last few decades, people just invested in a bunch of kids they hoped would take care of them in their old age.
It has failed because it relies on people to make rational choices and to save money. To be fair, those were considered reasonable expectations until the last few decades.
You don't need 'investment expertise'. You put your money in a Vanguard index fund, and you don't pull it out until you're done working. With a savings rate of even 10%, you're golden by traditional retirement age.
The main problem I have with .. pretty much every article on retirement ever is this line:
>To maintain living standards into old age we need roughly 20 times our annual income in financial wealth.
Really? Your living standard is entirely dictated by how much money you spend?
I had a conversation with my mother recently about their retirement plans - she's "done the math", and they won't be able to retire until a few years after they planned to. I was somewhat surprised, and asked for details - she apparently can't picture living comfortably on less than $130,000 per year. My wife and I have a comparable lifestyle, and are living on $31,000 without even working hard at it.
My advice to everyone: spend less.
You're chucking great gobs of money at things that don't make you happy; just STOP DOING THAT and you will have enough to retire on by the time you're 50.