News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by SecretDreams on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:30PM (#42775739)
I can't tell if your implication is what meta did is fine or just that your brain is as good as an AI?

Could you clearly speak your point?

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by whynotminot on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:36PM (#42775773)
This viewpoint is one widely shared inside the AI community — that AI systems should be able to learn from material just as humans do.

Extrapolated out into some new future a hundred years from now when we have embodied AI humanoids walking alongside us, would it be weird if those humanoids were barred from buying a new book or charged a different rate than the humans they coexist with?

I’m still deciding how I feel about some of this too.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by plasticchris on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:46PM (#42775868)
If we are going to afford models like this treatment equivalent to sentient beings in this regard, why not others? In your extrapolation these ai walking among us are property of giant tech companies…
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by whynotminot on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:47PM (#42775889)
Valid point. And to some extent a lot of existing licensing models cover this for humans too (are you using this thing for yourself, or are you using this thing on behalf of your company).

There will be a lot to figure out over the coming years.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by SecretDreams on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:41PM (#42775815)
> This viewpoint is one widely shared inside the AI community — that AI systems should be able to learn from material just as humans do.

I'm not even against this to a point. The issue is what comes after. The monetization. The enshitification. The derivatives in place of real creativity.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by hedora on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:47PM (#42775887)
Hardware and algorithms keep getting 10x better in this space with a regular cadence.

The only way to prevent the things you are worried about is to let anyone train a model, and then compete to make the best product.

The enshittifying monopolies and big copyright holders are the only ones that would benefit from locking down training data or regulating AI compute.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by SecretDreams on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:51PM (#42775922)
Even if we could all train evenly, those with money will always win out on the execution. You can't possibly believe just "letting things play out" as they have been so far, but with less copyright guardrails, is the solution here?
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by tinco on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:44PM (#42775843)
It's a straw man though, whether or not AI should be allowed to learn from books is irrelevant to the point that Meta stole tens of thousands of books to accomplish this. A fact that they've admitted to and even had they not would be trivially proven.

They're not being charged, that would be a vast improvement over reality.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by DennisP on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:56PM (#42775949)
At ten dollars per book, that'd just be a few hundred thousand dollars. They spent way more than that training the model, and probably will spend more on legal fees in this case.

But if they had done that, I bet they would have been sued anyway.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by whynotminot on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:59PM (#42775983)
I think that part is maybe missed here — “why didn’t you pay for it?”

“Because you wouldn’t have sold it to me. Or even if you would have, you would have put such onerous terms on it that I’d rather take this path.”

(Not saying this makes it right)

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by plasticchris on Monday January 20, 2025 @10:03PM (#42776008)
Buying a single copy of a work does not grant you a license to duplicate or distribute that work.

So just buying copies wouldn’t have helped them.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by DennisP on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @06:18AM (#42778882)
But they are not duplicating or distributing it. The whole point is that the AI is just reading and learning from it, just like a human would do.
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by plasticchris on Saturday January 25, 2025 @10:42AM (#42822262)
Even accepting that, the law should be encouraging creative output by individuals and there is justifiable fear that this will be used to bypass protections designed to reward such behavior.

For a more direct counterexample, I can memorize something and type it back out, but if it is copyrighted the law doesn’t make an exception just because it passed through my head.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by DennisP on Sunday January 26, 2025 @09:22AM (#42830256)
If the AI is able to type back out a duplicate of the training data, then I agree that's copyright infringement. If it just learns from the data like a human with normal memory reading a large amount of material, then I don't see it. That's normally the case. There have been experiments where someone managed to make an AI spit out near-copies, but it's not the default situation and seems preventable.

I do agree that we should encourage human creativity. But if AI isn't making copies, and the output of AI isn't awarded copyright (as is currently the case) then I think humans still have sufficient reward.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by hedora on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:43PM (#42775840)
The courts have already ruled that training on data is similar to reading it (sufficiently transformative) to be considered fair use, in the same way that I cannot claim a copyright on your brain because you read this comment.

On the other hand, they torrented books and then open sourced LLM weights. No punishment is too severe for that!

If you still don’t understand, I strongly suggest watching Max Headroom, “Lessons”, which you can get here:

https://archive.org/download/max-headroom-complete

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by wang_li on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:37PM (#42775784)
I think he’s saying he works for meta and when the company employees committed mass copyright violation that’s ok because once someone read Winnie the Pooh to him at story hour at the library.
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by 23B1 on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:35PM (#42775772)
OP is making the spurious argument that technology should have the same ethical entitlements as humans. It's on par with "information wants to be free".
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by derektank on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:46PM (#42775870)
I don't read it as an ethical argument, it's an argument about the purpose of copyright. Copyright is intended to restrict reproduction of a work for the purpose of incentivizing the creation of new works. Copyright is not intended to restrict the transmission of knowledge.
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by 23B1 on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @01:49AM (#42777273)
OP's argument is a common one amongst the IP entitlements crowd.
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by SecretDreams on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:39PM (#42775799)
My thoughts as well. I just prefer to remove the nuance on these types of things. If OP wants to draw a line and clearly state "I'm with the corpo robots" that's fine. Just state it plainly so I can proceed accordingly.
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by nicce on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:44PM (#42775851)
Maybe I need to use this argument when I go to the movies next time.
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by Guthur on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:35PM (#42775767)
Honestly, if people continue to conflate human development with a mega corps trawling copyright material to build a mathematical model and then wrap it up and charge a subscription for it, then there's really not much you, I or anyone else can do to avoid the inevitable fallout and we really deserve everything we get for it.
Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by SecretDreams on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:38PM (#42775789)
> and we really deserve everything we get for it.

I agree with you until this part. There comes a time where I don't think I deserve to get my eyes poked out just because other people find that fashionable.

Re:It sure looks like Meta stole a lot of books to build its AI by maeil on Monday January 20, 2025 @09:37PM (#42775782)
> and we really deserve everything we get for it.

Those people who conflate them deserve it. You and me don't.

> there's really not much you, I or anyone else can do

We can make our own community. And Bluesky is very much not it.