News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Authors Seek Meta's Torrent Client Logs and Seeding Data ... by WhatsName on Monday January 20, 2025 @04:53PM (#42773502)
You mean OpenAIs infamous "you shall not train on the output of our model" clause?
Re:Authors Seek Meta's Torrent Client Logs and Seeding Data ... by Terr_ on Monday January 20, 2025 @06:02PM (#42774179)
If that's contractually-enforceable in their terms-of-service... then I have my own terms-of-service proposal that I've been kicking around here for several weeks, a kind of GPL-inspired poison-pill:

> If the Visitor uses copyrighted material from this site (Hereafter: Site-Content) to train a Generative AI System, in consideration the Visitor grants the Site Owner an irrevocable, royalty-free, worldwide license to use and re-license any output or derivative works created from that trained Generative AI System. (Hereafter: Generated Content.)

> If the Visitor re-trains their Generative AI System to remove use of the Site-Content, the Visitor is responsible for notifying the Site Owner of which Generated Content is no longer subject to the above consideration. The Visitor shall indemnify the Site-Owner for any usage or re-licensing of Generated Content that occurs prior to the Site-Owner receiving adequate notice.

_________

IANAL, but in short: "If you exploit my work to generate stuff, then I get to use or give-away what you made too. If you later stop exploiting my work and forget to tell me, then that's your problem."

Yes, we haven't managed to eradicate a two-tiered justice system where the wealthy and powerful get to break the rules... But still, it would be cool to develop some IP-lawyer-vetted approach like this for anyone to use, some boilerplate ToS and agree-button implementation guidelines.

Re:Authors Seek Meta's Torrent Client Logs and Seeding Data ... by protocolture on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @12:14AM (#42776876)
I still dont think this has legs, precisely because of this case.

They accessed the material through piracy. They never accepted a TOS. They will probably get away with acquiring the material however they liked because of fair use.

The technicality is that they redistributed the material because of seeding, which is a no no.

That said, you might find inspiration in Midjourneys TOS. Anyone paying less than a Business plan agrees that anyone else on the platform can sample your output and your prompt.

Re:Authors Seek Meta's Torrent Client Logs and Seeding Data ... by Terr_ on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @02:51PM (#42784481)
While this won't work too well when the access is indirect via a piracy or a "rogue contractor", it can be applicable to the web-crawlers the companies are directly running.
Re:Authors Seek Meta's Torrent Client Logs and Seeding Data ... by oakpond on Tuesday January 21, 2025 @03:53AM (#42777860)
It's incredibly hypocritical too. They have become rich by training on valuable data produced by others. Yet others are not allowed to train on valuable data produced by them.