The recent Internet Defense League makes me wonder if something similar couldn't be launched for small software companies who make it CLEARLY part of their ethos about the direction of the company. This would not necessarily be a membership kind of animal but more of a "we agree with the ideas of Small Software Developers' Principles."
Well, in many cases "free" is strongly suggestive of the "not trying to build a company, just building a portfolio in order to attract job offers" scenario. Beyond that, it's hard to say.
The recent Internet Defense League makes me wonder if something similar couldn't be launched [...]
I'm not sure what "something similar" would be here. Your favourite website is being shut down because its developers got acquihired by Google, so you should write a letter to your member of congress?
"Something similar" being companies that subscribe to an idea of "not heading towards acquihire." Substitute idea with ethos/loose organization/alliance/whatever other non-hostile word might suffice here. I'm not suggessting that by participating you elect to be lynched by a mob at the slightest whim of misunderstanding or error. It is more of a self-certify that a company has an intention of providing a service and not a portfolio to be hired in 180 days.
Your idea of self-certification is why I wrote that blog post. It's an open invitation to lynch me if Tarsnap gets acquired and shut down a few months later.
But I think it's far more likely that I'd hire out of the open source community than out of the startup community.