Re:Quick Nexus 7 Comments By Linus Torvalds
by generalk on Saturday July 21, 2012 @12:34PM
(#4275111)
I agree, fewer buttons does not necessarily make a device simpler. There's a happy medium that I think Android hit with the four-button menu/home/back/search keys. Whenever I use an iPhone anymore I always cache-miss and try to find the hardware back button.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Quick Nexus 7 Comments By Linus Torvalds
by primatology on Saturday July 21, 2012 @01:25PM
(#4275257)
Not every screen needs a back button. You can't hide a hardware back button.
I'm with Apple on this one. The back-arrow button in the toolbar reminds me I'm in a hierarchal app, and the label reminds me what the prior screen was. It's just the opposite for me: every time I use an Android I hunt around the screen for the software back button.
As the hardware buttons are generally lit, you could de-emphasise it by removing the light. I had a Motorola java phone which did just this.
The failure of the Apple hierarchical model is it's app-centric, unlike Android which is activity-centric. In a perfect world we could have software back buttons which worked like Android, but I wouldn't trust developers to implement that consistently.
Re:Quick Nexus 7 Comments By Linus Torvalds
by yummyfajitas on Saturday July 21, 2012 @04:03PM
(#4275620)
If there is no place to go back to (i.e., you just opened the app), back takes you to the home screen.
Besides, just as you can't hide a hardware back button, you can't hide the wasted space sitting to the left and right the iPhone's "go home or randomly open Siri" button.