News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by weego on Friday July 20, 2012 @01:52PM (#4271998)
I'm not sure I absorbed the message as it was supposed to be put across. The video showed a (seemingly) quite advanced prototype, and they expect to be able to ship before the end of the year. So what is the $200k for? Seemingly to "make it happen" but it appears to be happening already, so it's kickstarting a hefty salary?

If I did somehow miss the point and this seems like a cynical response then obviously I apologise in advance, but that's how it came across.

Edit, cancel the nicety... I just saw that it's retailing for $299. It all feels rather cynical. Perhaps I have too much of a rose-tinted view of the attraction of Kickstarter?

Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by Animus7 on Friday July 20, 2012 @02:43PM (#4272283)
I'm getting the same vibe. And I'm beginning to think that allowing this kind of thing will be the downfall of Kickstarter. Yes, I will explain.

Don't get me wrong, I absolutely love the Kickstarter concept. But in practice, their scaling seems to quickly be turning hem into a sales platform that has no controls or accountability.

And I have nothing bad to say about this project in particular, but they are a YC company, and the state of the prototype shows that they already have all they need to make it happen. This project doesn't need money. The campaign seems to me to be nothing more than a simple "I'm making something cool, so give me cash". And I'm not saying there's anything wrong with that -- by all means, people should be free to do what they wish with their money, and the Kickstarter campaign will probably work out beautifully for them. That's great.

But this whole perception of Kickstarter being a place for bootstrapping interesting projects is turning into a dangerous myth. Like many things before it, Kickstarter is becoming a place for people with money (and/or obvious ability to make money), to make even more money, though marketing under a vague guise of "bootstrapping", with no checks or balances to keep people honest.

This isn't an accusation leveled at Pixate -- I don't believe they're doing anything wrong and I have huge faith in YC's filtering. But once enough clever people figure out that you can earn a killing or huge bonus on top of anything, just by tacking on a nice Kickstarter campaign, it will become impossible to separate the wheat from the chaff. And then people will move on to the next thing, and the cycle will repeat.

</bubble-y doomsaying>

Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by rotw on Friday July 20, 2012 @04:43PM (#4272810)
> And I have nothing bad to say about this project in particular, but they are a YC company, and the state of the prototype shows that they already have all they need to make it happen. This project doesn't need money. The campaign seems to me to be nothing more than a simple "I'm making something cool, so give me cash".

I fully agree. Honestly, I hope both that this campaign fails and that the guys at Pixate are able to develop and launch their product successfully. The point of Kickstarter is to enable creative endeavours that would have trouble succeeding in a market environment -- a talented friend of mine financed his first short film via a similar site, which will hopefully get him a foot in the door of filmmaking. In his case, the Kickstarter idea is a great thing: It guarantees artistic independence and audience involvement.

This app, however, already has backing and will easily make plenty of money on the market. It's not a catastrophe in the long haul, but I sincerely hope this doesn't catch on: That's not audience involvement, that's a commercial transaction. You give me money, I give you product. On a larger scale, it's abusing opportunities for people who have few, which is particularly nefarious if it comes from people who have no need to beg.

Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by majormajor on Friday July 20, 2012 @09:10PM (#4273587)
In just a month or so I've already found myself developing an almost habitual response to Kickstarter software things posted here. Like you say, there seems to be a pattern of trying to cash in.

I see an interesting title on HN. I visit it and start reading. I start reading the copy and see some interesting screenshots/mockups, keep scrolling, and then realize a bit later that there isn't actually anything ready for me to try out, but they want me to give them some money.

Then I close the tab.

Very few of the software projects I've seen linked there have seemed interesting or novel enough for me to care to put up some cash up front. There are tools that cost hundreds of dollars out there that will let me try them, fully-featured, for free. These guys want $50 for beta access or $100 for a full license for something that doesn't exist yet?

It's probably somewhat irrational, but I'm even more annoyed by the ones with real slick demo videos and such. Why not put the time spent making that towards making a product I can actually try?

Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by ericdykstra on Friday July 20, 2012 @02:05PM (#4272083)
Kickstarter is being used, more and more, as a way to build interest and create revenue before the official "launch" of a product; even a product that would be produced anyway. It seems to be a rather effective way to get press coverage for a percentage of projects, and presents a clean interface on a trusted system for interested potential purchasers.

The risk, of course, is that a huge goal is less likely to be reached than a smaller goal. The ideal situation is that you have a reasonable goal that will actually help maybe some outsourcing or consulting costs or distribution set-up or what have you, blow away the goal early, and keep interest to drive revenue.

Personally, I don't find this kind of Kickstarter project very interesting, and I believe it's a suboptimal way to launch a product that could instead just be released as a MVP and iterated on based on user feedback.

Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by jack-r-abbit on Friday July 20, 2012 @02:14PM (#4272129)
It feels like a lot of kickstarters are barely more than a "pre-order" mechanism. I'm not sure what happens if a project gets funded but then fails to deliver. It seems like when you give to a kickstarter, you should go into it fully prepared to never get your money back and never get the finished product.
Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by objclxt on Friday July 20, 2012 @02:43PM (#4272287)
It's a cynical way to pre-order, because you're not really pre-ordering at all: you're giving some money and the rewards are a side-effect. You don't get any of the usual consumer protection at all.
Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by EwanG on Saturday July 21, 2012 @11:42AM (#4274978)
You mean like the Astronaut MMO that got all the press earlier this year, and now even the forums are gone?

Yes, that is the risk with Kickstarter and any other investment. It's just there seems to be less visibility into the viability of the company or person behind the project than most investments. Since I rarely go beyond the $20 range, I only feel mildly burned on the ones that don't go anywhere. For folks who hit the maximum (I've seen some with $10K options), I suspect the hurt is a little more real.

Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by pippin on Friday July 20, 2012 @03:04PM (#4272392)
Running a Kickstarter project early on in a product's life allows anyone to see what kind/size of audience they'll be dealing with.

I don't believe all products should do this, but they'll receive valuable feedback, and if they don't meet their goal, they'll be better off with decent feedback from potential customers.

Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by webwright on Friday July 20, 2012 @04:01PM (#4272633)
"I just saw that it's retailing for $299. It all feels rather cynical."

Huh? For a $99 pledge, you get the $299 license when it launches, it looks like.

This looks like every other product kickstarter, which essentially are saying, "We've invested considerable time and money. We're committed. We'd love to have you pitch in to help accelerate us and get us over the finish line. In exchange, your pledges entitle you to discounts and other favors."

Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by PufferBuffer on Friday July 20, 2012 @06:32PM (#4273176)
Why don't they just create the product and have me pay for it? The company is already funded, why should I go ahead and pre-order something now, knowing it might not work as advertised when it's ready. I'd much rather pay $300 when the product is on the shelf, when I can evaluate the pro's and con's. Sure, if this was a project that hasn't been started and looked very promising, I would give it some money, for a chance to get something great. In this case, it seems I don't have to risk, but rather just have to wait.
Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by loceng on Friday July 20, 2012 @09:47PM (#4273680)
It's an investment round that that don't have to give equity up for.
Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by DanielRibeiro on Friday July 20, 2012 @02:18PM (#4272156)
Note that they also have YC funding:

Q. What's your background?

Paul and Kevin were accepted into Y-Combinator this summer to launch Pixate into it's current prototype phase

Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by andyfleming on Friday July 20, 2012 @02:27PM (#4272193)
Does everyone in the YC program have funding? Obviously, they have access to funding, but does everyone without exception take on funding?
Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by simonw on Saturday July 21, 2012 @05:16AM (#4274387)
To participate in YC you need to accept a very small equity deal from YC - this is usually around $17,000 for 7%, but I believe it can vary depending on the stage of the company.

You later get the option to take a $150,000 convertible note at extremely good terms. This isn't mandatory, but the terms are designed to make it almost a no-brainier to say yes.

Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by jchung on Friday July 20, 2012 @02:30PM (#4272210)
Yes
Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by andyfleming on Friday July 20, 2012 @02:30PM (#4272207)
It looks like these guys have plenty of money. They show a nice house, nice cars, etc. Sounds like they could fund themselves pretty easily, right?
Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by montecarl on Friday July 20, 2012 @11:59PM (#4273905)
I'd love to see complete or nearly complete software on kickstarter. One could finish a software project, then recoup all of the development costs plus profit and then offer the final product for free since you have already made all your money. This model allows the people that are most interested to fund the entire development cycle of the software and pay for everyone else to have it too. It also avoids all of the immoral intellectual property laws.
Re:Pixate - beautiful native mobile apps with CSS by daleharvey on Friday July 20, 2012 @03:34PM (#4272521)
It is very very easy to create a nice demo, the difference beteween that and a nice product is lots and lots of time, effort and money.

There is a balance to be made between 'we have this idea and need money to build it' and 'we are serious about this, we have done X much already, we need money to go over the finish line'