Re:US Will Ban Cancer-Linked Red Dye No. 3 in Cereal and Oth...
by Aloisius on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @08:10PM
(#42719692)
"Safe" for the FDA means the benefits outweigh the potential risks, not safe in absolute terms.
If the FDA actually required every drug to be proven safe at any dose for everyone, we'd have no modern drugs.
Re:US Will Ban Cancer-Linked Red Dye No. 3 in Cereal and Oth...
by refurb on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @09:34PM
(#42720348)
We require drug companies show their products are safe and efficacious, and there is both a scientific and a legal framework by which we do this.
We don’t do this.
What the FDA requires is acceptable safety in light of the benefit provided.
The FDA approves highly toxic drugs all the time. Including ones with the risk of death. I don’t think anyone would call chemotherapy “safe”.
So, let’s stop pretending it’s not possible. We require drug companies show their products are safe and efficacious, and there is both a scientific and a legal framework by which we do this. Let’s debate whether or not the same framework should be applied to food additives (I would argue it should) rather than claim it is not possible.