News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pri... by fooker on Monday January 13, 2025 @10:58PM (#42693430)
Tokyo barely makes it into the top hundred by population density.

Also yes, for most large cities you can find news articles about people dying in fires or because of an ambulance getting delayed.

Re:43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pri... by wat10000 on Monday January 13, 2025 @11:08PM (#42693505)
Funny how you don’t see articles about people dying in fires because they live on a suburb that’s 10% as dense as it should be and so the fire station is 3x farther away than it should be.

No real surprise, though. People love stories where you can point to a few people and say, they’re the ones who did this. It’s much less fun when it’s systemic and no one person or group can be blamed.

Re:43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pri... by pclmulqdq on Monday January 13, 2025 @11:40PM (#42693720)
Police response times in my "10% as dense as it should be" suburb (a place that would be the poster child for everything urbanists hate) are 3x faster than they are in NYC. That is largely due to having high mobility through the town. In pure distance terms, I live about 20x further from the police station, though.

The average door-to-door time between my house and the nearest level 1 trauma center is 10 minutes shorter than it would be when I lived in Manhattan. It turns out that having the paramedics wait for an elevator really cuts into their response time. A level 3 trauma center is 25 minutes closer (there are no level 3 trauma centers in Manhattan).

https://patch.com/new-york/new-york-city/nypds-slow-response...

Cities are built for average-case living, and that is fine until you need it not to be.

Re:43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pri... by fooker on Monday January 13, 2025 @11:13PM (#42693528)
As a rule of thumb, you can't design anything trying to account for black swan events.

Optimizing for the regular, daily use case is hard enough.

It would help to think of this as a smart but random person reading about a security issue like spectre and offering you software design advice. Common sense arguments are only useful to an extent, the devil is in the details.

Re:43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pri... by wat10000 on Monday January 13, 2025 @11:21PM (#42693584)
I’m not sure how to apply this here. What does optimizing for regular daily use and not black swan events look like when it comes to fire and ambulance services? It seems to me that black swans are a major purpose for them. That’s why the local fire station tends to have a lot of time where the firefighters are sitting around, and why simple calls often get 3x more response than they need. The services are greatly overprovisioned for daily needs because they also exist for the times when an entire apartment building burns down, or some maniac bombs the subway.
Re:43K fewer drivers on Manhattan roads after congestion pri... by dymk on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @12:23AM (#42693980)
Who cares about news articles? If you're worried that dense cities are dangerous, then back it up with some statistics about deaths per capita due to EMS delays.