Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by josephcsible on Sunday January 12, 2025 @09:01PM
(#42679242)
Isn't it reasonable for applications to assume that, now that virtually all hardware has it, even super-cheap computers like the Raspberry Pi?
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by Narishma on Sunday January 12, 2025 @09:33PM
(#42679443)
The hardware may be there, but not necessarily the drivers.
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by zamadatix on Sunday January 12, 2025 @09:58PM
(#42679610)
The drivers are fine for GPU accelerated rendering of the app surfaces, even on the Pi. Hell, the drivers are even there >98% of the time for accelerated decode of the video format itself to boot.
Qube's unique choice in software only rendering for user applications is one born out of the isolation goals for security, not what the software/drivers/hardware could do.
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by fsflover on Monday January 13, 2025 @01:05PM
(#42686407)
> even on the Pi
Only proprietary ones, so not for everyone...
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by fsflover on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @07:26AM
(#42696409)
> Broadcom never released a public specification for the V3D 3.x or 4.x series.
So the support must be worse if you prefer free drivers?
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by zamadatix on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @10:29AM
(#42698402)
No, as there isn't a non-free driver alternative to compare V3D to. For VC4 (Pi 1-3) there was a proprietary alternative driver... but it was a bit garbage.
It feels you may be conflating the "proprietary firmware blob on the GPU which is used to boot the Pi" story with the GPU driver itself.
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by fsflover on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @11:17AM
(#42699183)
Yes, you are right, "proprietary firmware blob on the GPU which is used to boot the Pi" is what I recall as a big Pi problem. So my original wording is correct that you need proprietary blobs to run Raspberry Pi, isn't it?
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by zamadatix on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @11:38AM
(#42699625)
"Yes" in that the above statement about needing proprietary blobs to boot the Pis is certainly accurate & true (ongoing science experiments notwithstanding). "No" in that we somehow went from talking about "how apps can safely assume to rely on accelerated rasterization instead of software rasterization" to "how the Raspberry Pi family needs proprietary boot firmware to do anything with app output at all" and I've missed the connection between the two points.
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by fsflover on Wednesday January 15, 2025 @11:18AM
(#42712840)
> support must be worse if you prefer free drivers
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by fulafel on Sunday January 12, 2025 @11:33PM
(#42680099)
Yes. Besides Qubes users, a big population of software rendering users is people who have old and/or buggy drivers that are blacklisted by Firefox.
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by usr1106 on Monday January 13, 2025 @02:19AM
(#42680925)
I understand GPUs are a security nightmare. If you want to have some understanding of your security, don't use a GPU.
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by irundebian on Tuesday January 14, 2025 @10:19AM
(#42698255)
Yeah, if you really care about security, only use computer which use line printers as output mechanisms.
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by adastra22 on Monday January 13, 2025 @03:01AM
(#42681151)
The issue for Qubes is security. GPUs can be used to subvert basically all the otherwise hardware-enforced security protections.
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by creole_wither on Monday January 13, 2025 @01:03PM
(#42686395)
In a desktop, couldn't you assign a GPU to one video machine and in that scenario would there still be a security problem when there is only one VM using it?
Re:Qubes OS: A reasonably secure operating system
by adastra22 on Monday January 13, 2025 @08:57PM
(#42692528)
It’s not about virtual machines. GPUs typically have direct memory access to pretty much all system RAM. There exist PCIe mitigations, but the review does not meet up to Qubes security standards.
Around Firefox 92 or 93 the new GPU-based renderer ported from Servo was made default and performance under Qubes became much worse. Unfortunately, it seems applications increasingly assume the presence of video acceleration and don't prioritize software rendering.