News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by gowld on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:02PM (#42639478)
He wasn't disciplined for building an app or fetching data.

He was disciplined for blatantly trying to "hack" (in the YC sense, in UW's view) the registration process:

https://registrar.washington.edu/winter-2025-registration-ch...

"Know that trading, selling, or buying open spots is a breach of the Registration Tampering Abuse Policy. Consequences include referral to the Student Code of Conduct process, a Registrar’s Hold on your record, and potential diploma withholding for graduating students until the conduct process is complete."

https://registrar.washington.edu/registration/policies-proce...

"Registration Abuse The registration system is provided for the sole express purpose for students to register themselves into sections. Any use of the registration system other than for this purpose is considered abuse of the system. Such abuse includes, but is not limited to, buying or selling one’s seat in a class, holding seats for another student, or otherwise registering for a section that one has no intention of taking."

Disclaimer: I am making no claim about the ethical validity of this policy, and I don't know how well the policy is communicated to students. I am not commenting on the allegation that the University demanded free labor in exchange for not-expelling OP.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by pdpi on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:20PM (#42639619)
> Such abuse includes, but is not limited to, buying or selling one’s seat in a class, holding seats for another student, or otherwise registering for a section that one has no intention of taking."

This bit is important.

At a glance, stubhub/ticketmaster/etc are pretty benign services that fulfil a pretty natural need for event tickets, but we've all seen the damage they can cause. There's a very real risk that OP's service could become a ticketmaster for UW classes, with all the perverse incentives that entails. Their reaction was probably excessive, but, from this perspective, understandable.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by MostlyStable on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:32PM (#42639726)
It sounds like the actual demo site didn't actually interact with the registration system at all. He mentions "fake" classes. That's what he wanted the API token for; that would have allowed him to actually make the site function, and he (falsely) assumed that the documentation meant the university was open to the idea.

So while it sounds like his site would almost certainly wound up violating policy had it gone live _it never did so_. That's a pretty good reason for them to deny the API request (which seems like may have not been intended for the public anyway?) But it does not in any way seem to merit the threat of expulsion, or, even worse, the fact that (according to the student in an update), even though he immediately complied they still put a hold on his account anyways.

There is some nuance here for sure, but I do not see in any way that the universities response is proportional to what actually happened.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by hirvi74 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:01PM (#42640806)
Not to mention the fact that if it were so egregious, then why does the university want the creator's work or some modification of it?
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by Xelynega on Thursday January 09, 2025 @01:27AM (#42642199)
The only source we have for this is the person saying it.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by hirvi74 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:07AM (#42646966)
Good point.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by w0m on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:16PM (#42648916)
I'm guessing he had been running the 'demo' site for a fair minute using scrapped data; but didn't get noticed/caught until he requested the token.

Still shit to lock him out after he pulled the site down.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by uwthrowaway on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:29PM (#42639696)
I'm a uw cs student, it is made pretty clear that you're not supposed to trade spots or otherwise automate any part of the registration. Students typically know not to talk about this stuff.

While well-intentioned, if this was commonly used it would mess registration up even more by making the "constrained" classes valuable and would be filled up quickly by people who wouldn't take them.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by buildbot on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:53PM (#42639943)
I was an EE student and worked for UW CSE back in the day, someone tried to do this back then as well and got very in trouble.

There may have been some browser automation scripts about… I wouldn’t know.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by loeg on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:00PM (#42640002)
I benefited from a UW CSE spot trade in like 2010 and didn't get in trouble for it at the time.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by uwthrowaway on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:08PM (#42640054)
Yeah, a small amount of "organic" mischief isn't bad IMO, but it's problematic on a larger scale.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by buildbot on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @08:43PM (#42640694)
Yeah I agree, not ideal given how limited capacity is in some classes.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by hirvi74 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:04PM (#42640826)
How were said student(s) even caught? I am assuming someone spoke too loudly or shared too much, but I'd be lying if I said I was not hoping for some kind of technical solution.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by buildbot on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @11:32PM (#42641658)
Not sure, but UW IT isn’t incapable of noticing repeated requests from the same IP or something, I assume most students are not setting up systems that go over residential proxies.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by thorncorona on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:08AM (#42642490)
You typically need to be signed in in order to get all the course info.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by buildbot on Thursday January 09, 2025 @11:36AM (#42647317)
UW does have that info publicly available: https://www.washington.edu/students/timeschd/WIN2025/

You do have to be signed typically to actually make changes of course, I imagine this tool would have to have your netid login… (yikes)

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by lupire on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:07AM (#42646343)
Can you explain when this horrific behavior (seat trading) is explicitly supported by UW, when they could simply NOT accept requests for trading seats?

I sign up for a class. I am on the roster. How is it possible for me to put your name on the class roster, for credit, transcript, and diploma, without the university going out of their way to help?

These aren't anonymous concert tickets or XBoxes. They are personally identifiable registrations.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by badgersnake on Thursday January 09, 2025 @10:59AM (#42646886)
It seems odd that they would want the author to provided them with a system to automate it then.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by jjmarr on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:25PM (#42639666)
If you look at the GitHub commit history, the repo was created before the blog post from UW, and also never contained actual courses.

This is important, because it's the only explicit reference to "trading open spots" they've made.

The Registration Abuse policy covers access to the registration system for:

* buying or selling one’s seat in a class,

* holding seats for another student,

* or otherwise registering for a section that one has no intention of taking.

It's unclear if HuskySwap actually violated this policy, given that it never actually accessed the registration system and no students used it in conjunction with the registration system of the school.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by uwthrowaway on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:33PM (#42639734)
UW student - see the "Tampering and Abuse" section of (https://registrar.washington.edu/registration/policies-proce...) which has been around for much longer and is well communicated with students.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by jjmarr on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:33PM (#42640240)
Yes, I saw that linked in the top comment.

What isn't clear is how this site actually violated that policy, if there was no course slot trading actually occurring. You could describe it as an attempt, but in this situation, the student asked for permission from the school before doing something that would violate their policies.

To use an analogy, if I sneak notes into an exam, that is likely academic misconduct. However, creating a formula sheet and asking the professor if I can use it is not academic misconduct. I wouldn't consider that to be attempted cheating.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by croemer on Thursday January 09, 2025 @12:09AM (#42641823)
He might have violated the following by testing alone:

> The use of robots and other automated tools to submit registration requests is expressly forbidden.

Some sort of testing will likely have happened, in which case an automated tool has been used. Even if only by TFA himself.

Also note:

> Because use of scripts, robots, or other automated queries can adversely impact University network and computing resources and interferes with equal access to registration, such automated querying of registration-related resources is expressly forbidden. Violators may have their access to University network and computing resources terminated and may be subject to action by the University under applicable law, regulation, or policy, including but not limited to, discipline under any applicable University conduct code.

The whole purpose of the project is to violate this clause. I agree that if no testing had happened, no sanctions should apply because the clause above doesn't say anything about attempts of use being sanctioned.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by uwthrowaway on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:56AM (#42643261)
I'd personally describe it as an attempt for two reasons, although reasonable minds can differ:

1. They made substantial progress towards a working tool with available code, before requesting permission from the school. That request was to enable parts of the site, not requesting permission to develop/release it publicly.

2. It is pretty clear to students that you aren't allowed to mess with any of the registration systems/process (e.g. trading/holding classes). Your analogy has a very reasonable question (are notesheets allowed) vs a policy which is made very clear.

A different analogy is creating a hidden device to cheat on exams, then asking the professor for the exam room's wifi password as to enable it it in the future. While the situation is not as clear-cut as the analogy, I hope it helps show my perspective.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by PennRobotics on Thursday January 09, 2025 @06:39AM (#42644276)
Yet another analogy is designing and presenting a radar detector/jammer but never using it on public roads.

Until the author has used the tool on the UW server during registration, he is not violating their policies and procedures: He hasn't attempted to tamper with records. He admittedly hasn't used their registration system with this tool. Those are the two key phrases in their policy. The text goes on to specifically describe abuse as "use" of a script or robot. There isn't anything forbidding a student from authoring a script.

One problem here is that by releasing the source, it makes it easier for another student to exploit the system. In the case where another student uses this tool during registration, the other student is fully responsible.

Besides all that, it's a great project idea because everyone in his program would instantly relate to the problem.

It's easy to understand the University's overreaction---and it is an overreaction. The better solution from UW would have been to sternly inform the student(s), "The website can never go live. It dies as a proof of concept. Please use your own dummy data; no API access. A disclaimer must be added to any class demos (presentations, code, etc.) with the Tampering and Abuse policy, and that this only uses generated data. Our efforts to improve the registration system in the future will be X, Y, Z."

This student has done nothing wrong (yet) (based on what he revealed) and is getting punished for being near the border.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by ChrisClark on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:21PM (#42640154)
How does a fake site, with fake classes, that had nothing to do with actual registration, violate that?
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by charlieyu1 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:27PM (#42639677)
Why is trading considered bad? It is solving some problems for both students and administrators.

In my old days we did the same, only by finding someone who want to swap manually

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by cibyr on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:52PM (#42639940)
The ability to trade creates an incentive to register for courses you don't actually plan to take, which leads to further scarcity.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by foota on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:48PM (#42639907)
Trading when it happens organically "oops I thought I wanted to take this class, but can't make the time slot work" is beneficial, but making it easy to register for a bunch of classes in high demand and then swap them with others messes with things.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by LPisGood on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @06:51PM (#42639931)
It opens up for abuse by offering to sell a spot.
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by charlieyu1 on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:21PM (#42640155)
The downside is that you may be unable to sell it and actually have to take a course that you don’t want
Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by isotypic on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @07:39PM (#42640282)
You can just drop the course - pretty much every university (in the United States, at least) allows students to drop courses one or two weeks into the semester without any record (on say, a transcript). Otherwise students cannot possibly plan their semesters, since courses may not make material available until after the semester actually starts.

So if you are planning to sell the slots and it does not work out, you just drop the course, no harm to you.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by charlieyu1 on Thursday January 09, 2025 @08:13AM (#42645024)
And the slot will be reallocated.

I won’t say no harm but you have to be pretty desperate to try to pull this off

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by mrguyorama on Thursday January 09, 2025 @03:05PM (#42649355)
"No harm" except for the several slots that were taken up by people hoping to make a quick buck (selling the trade) who drop a day or two into classes and cause the students who actually NEED the class to be very stressed and annoyed and possibly have to adjust their plans because they don't think they will be able to take a class even though it will actually be free by the third time the class meets.

It also just fucks with the University's ability to gauge class interest. In my university, if a class filled up early in the registration window, the University would try to increase capacity or add another copy of the class, but that's not always an option.

A reminder that this is not done for technical reasons. Plenty of colleges all across the US, big and small, custom-built registration software or purchased on the open market, have fully functional waitlist features. "first come first serve" is a policy choice.

Re:I had to take down my course-swapping site or be expelled by toyg on Thursday January 09, 2025 @02:57AM (#42642865)
If a resource is so scarce that its real value is higher than the official one, the producer will have to either increase production, or accept that black markets will appear.

Why can't UW increase the number of classes?