News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Triptych Proposals. Parent comment

Re:Triptych Proposals by cryptonector on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @01:10AM (#42631500)
> Two documents (requests) vs one request has nothing to do with anything: typical HTML documents make multiple requests to fully resolve w/images etc. What does bear on if a system is RESTful is if an API end point requires an API-specific schema to interact with.

It's an API-specific schema, yes, but the browser doesn't have to know it because the API-to-HTML conversion is encoded in the second document (which rarely changes). I.e., notionally the browser only deals in the hydrated HTML and not in the API-specific schema. How does that make this not RESTful?

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Triptych Proposals by recursivedoubts on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @09:32AM (#42634638)
Well, again I'm not 100% saying it isn't RESTful, I would need to see an example of the whole system to determine if the uniform interface (and the other constraints of REST) are satisfied. That's why i asked for an example showing where the hypermedia controls are located, etc. so we can make an objective analysis of the situation. REST is a network architecture and thus we need to look at the entire system to determine if it is being satisfied (see https://hypermedia.systems/components-of-a-hypermedia-system...)
[ Parent | on HN ]