Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016)
by npoc on Monday January 06, 2025 @07:37AM
(#42610070)
> whey itself does not necessitate killing anything.
This is assuming that people would eat calves if they weren't killed so that we can take their milk.
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016)
by jvanderbot on Monday January 06, 2025 @08:39AM
(#42610463)
You're right, but I think about it the other direction. We currently _do_ eat the calves that _are_ killed so we can take their milk.
We _could_ (probably) figure out a way to not require killing them, I just don't know what that would be.
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016)
by GrantMoyer on Monday January 06, 2025 @09:47AM
(#42610977)
Back of the envelope math: cows live for about 20 years, but dairy cows are killed after about 4 years when their milk production slows. Assuming they are impregnated 4 times, that's (5 cows * 20 years per cow) / (4 years) = 25 times as costly. And this 25 times as costly milk has to compete with the 1 times as costly milk in a market that's already so competative that milk is sold below cost with government subsidies. It's impossible for practical purposes.
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016)
by jvanderbot on Monday January 06, 2025 @10:13AM
(#42611210)
If you're comparing today's market, practices, and subsidies (which are all just measurements of the same signal) to a fictional world where we didn't want to kill any calfs, but using today's subsidies and prices, then I think that's not a fair comparison.
If god appeared and said that the Hindus were right all along and cows are sacred and milk is their gift to us - we'd do it just fine.
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016)
by bluGill on Monday January 06, 2025 @10:30AM
(#42611366)
Milk cows are not generally used for meat. That is a different breed of cows. Milk cows almost never have male offspring - with AI we can control to ensure only female calf's are born (IIRC this is about 97% accurate so a few males are born). A few great milk producing mothers will be given sperm that is male only thus ensuring enough bulls to provide fathers and improving genetics for the next generations.
Re:Engineer eats efficiently for $2.50 a day (2016)
by jvanderbot on Monday January 06, 2025 @12:24PM
(#42612667)
If AI means "Artificial Insemination" I believe you.
If AI means "Artificial Intelligence" I do not believe you.
This is objectionable if you find any of the meat farming practices objectionable, but whey itself does not necessitate killing anything.
A replacement rate breeding program for cows that rotates dairy production is probably possible. It's just not what we seem to want.