News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by madeofpalk on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:42AM (#42609761)
> it was always a metric closely aligned with what customers want
Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by makeitdouble on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:52AM (#42609812)
Parent's point is that customers want more than single metrics, and the metrics you leave on the side to priorize the OKRs can be as critical.

Put another way, if your client has 20 inherent metrics, you can't have 20 OKRs so you're always at risk to mess it when focusing on a smaller set.

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by liontwist on Monday January 06, 2025 @07:03AM (#42609866)
Exactly. So a productive employee is one who identifies a problem and knows which of the following to do:

- fix it themselves without anyone asking - bring it up to higher management - deprioritize it based on severity and leadership initiatives

This is the pattern taught by Jethro to Moses in the Old Testament:

every great matter they shall bring unto thee, but every small matter they shall judge: so shall it be easier for thyself, and they shall bear the burden with thee.

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by devsda on Monday January 06, 2025 @08:41AM (#42610473)
> fix it themselves without anyone asking - bring it up to higher management

No matter what your intentions are, doing this frequent enough will give you reputation of being a lonely wolf and trouble maker.

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by liontwist on Monday January 06, 2025 @10:57AM (#42611626)
I’m sorry that’s your experience.

But it can’t function any other way. You are a filter of small problems for everyone in the org higher than you. If you bring up everything up the chain your level may as well not exist.

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by marcosdumay on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:08PM (#42613258)
There are many places out there where individual contributors are agency-less executors.

I don't think it ever worked. (Remember when Japan destroyed the world's car industry just by changing that single thing? And that's industry work, highly repetitive and formalized.) But that never stopped managers from doing something.

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by liontwist on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:51AM (#42609807)
All OKRs help customers, but not all customer help meets an OKR.

Finding and fixing product problems requires decentralized decision making and trust.

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by DrScientist on Monday January 06, 2025 @07:34AM (#42610050)
Indeed.

What I find odd, is often the biggest proponents of the free market - with it's decentralised decision making process ( and redundancy of effort ), decide that total centralized, top down control is the best way to run their own company - as they think top down decisions and minimising waste through duplication is the way to go.

As with all things - it's a balance of course.

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by zeroonetwothree on Monday January 06, 2025 @10:01AM (#42611103)
You might want to read "The Nature of the Firm", which discusses this.
Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by DrScientist on Monday January 06, 2025 @12:13PM (#42612536)
That's a slightly different angle - if I understand correctly it's about why firms exist at all - and if I were to summarise it's because lack of trust costs - a firms boundaries are created to balance transactional costs ( within the firm it's low, between firms or individuals it can dominate ) versus the costs of perhaps not being market efficient.

My argument above is about not what shapes a firm's boundary but how it operates internally - too much top down control potentially risks exacerbating the risks associated with being a company and also potentially increases internal transactional costs as well - worse of both worlds! - all that ceremony around decision making, time spent justifying existences, inability to just act.

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by liontwist on Monday January 06, 2025 @11:02AM (#42611661)
That’s an easy one to answer.

Corporations don’t have police or taxation power and so have more limited impact on your individual freedom.

In a “free market” you can choose what firms you work for and with, except the government.

The government would be more efficient in an autocratic leadership. But government efficiency is not the societies efficiency and well being

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by DrScientist on Monday January 06, 2025 @12:04PM (#42612406)
> In a “free market” you can choose what firms you work for and with, except the government.

Eh? Nobody ever leaves one country for another?

> The government would be more efficient in an autocratic leadership. But government efficiency is not the societies efficiency and well being

I think the free market proponents would say otherwise - one key problem is the myth of perfect information - you are imagining it's possible to concentrate all the required information to make any correct decision into a very small group of people at the top ( and assuming these people are competent and not corrupt). One of the ideas behind why distributed markets work is the information about what is needed is communicated by the mechanisms of the market itself.

And to bring it back to the original post - does the CEO have all the information required to direct others to meet the customers need across all areas - or is it better to use the collective intelligence of the entire organisation?

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by aurareturn on Monday January 06, 2025 @07:51AM (#42610146)
>Finding and fixing product problems requires decentralized decision making and trust.

Which is exponentially harder in a large company - hence why OKRs are invented.

Re:Hitting OKRs vs. Doing Your Job by jcgl on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @03:47PM (#42638274)
> All OKRs help customers

And in the real world, not even this is true, due to the cost of satisfying OKRs--opportunity cost is one kind of cost, but optimizing an OKR can of course negatively impact other valuable things that aren't represented by OKRs.