News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by exabrial on Sunday January 05, 2025 @09:51PM (#42607130)
Every time the US Federal Reserve prints money, it's devaluing anyone that has cash or equivalents. Edit: that was not worded strong enough. It hurts everyone, but is unbelievably regressive against new savers and the impoverished.

An average person is unlikely to win this game. Our real returns are not 10% per year, they're closer to 4%. The 1%ers that hold top tier offices in this country voted themselves out of this game.

Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by laughing_man on Sunday January 05, 2025 @10:37PM (#42607408)
One thousand times this. The government punishes those who save. It's going to get worse, too when Social Security is means tested, which, is pretty much inevitable at this point. When that happens you'd have to be an idiot to save for retirement unless you're wealthy enough to take advantage of loopholes rich people put into the tax code.
Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by BigParm on Monday January 06, 2025 @09:32AM (#42610837)
I don't understand. If you buy an S&P500 ETF you are crushing.
Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by ttt3ts on Monday January 06, 2025 @10:32AM (#42611385)
https://www.statista.com/chart/30224/share-of-americans-who-...

Only 60% of us own any stock at all and often through 401k or other indirect investment.

Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by laughing_man on Monday January 06, 2025 @01:21PM (#42613442)
Last year, sure. Not over the long run. If it's outside your 401(k) the value of your money is going down due to inflation and taxes.
Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by Reubend on Monday January 06, 2025 @09:08PM (#42618404)
I think they're distinguishing between "saving" vs "investing". Investment carries risk.
Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by chowchowchow on Sunday January 05, 2025 @11:18PM (#42607617)
Isn’t it nearly entirely the commercial banks “printing” money by fractional-reserve lending? Low interest rates mean more, bigger loans from banks, ergo more money out there.
Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by ImJamal on Monday January 06, 2025 @07:01AM (#42609850)
The Federal Reserve chooses the amount that the banks are required to have on hand. They could ban the practice tomorrow if they wanted to.
Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by chowchowchow on Monday January 06, 2025 @10:47AM (#42611525)
It’s not really the fed printing money though is it. It’s private banks meeting demand for loans.
Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by ImJamal on Monday January 06, 2025 @11:06AM (#42611716)
If you want to be that pedantic it hasn't been printing money for decades since it is all digital.

The fed, in essence, delegates the printing of money to banks since they are on the ground and should understand if more loans are necessary.

Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by chowchowchow on Monday January 06, 2025 @12:51PM (#42613000)
What do you mean "necessary?" It's a function of demand, they only write the loans for borrowers who want and qualify for them.

It's not pedantry. It's understanding the model of attribution which blames the "fed" for this when it clearly seems like a function of the systemic design of our economy and financial system. Put another way - abolish the fed, and I'm not sure how this would change. And in fact it might get worse as you've removed an oversight and controlling body.

Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by ImJamal on Monday January 06, 2025 @04:20PM (#42616004)
When people talk about ending the fed they don't just mean the actual Federal Reserve. They mean the Federal Reserve along with everything they control such as fractional reserve banking, quantitative easing, etc. Perhaps there is somebody out there who wants to end the fed, but keep fractional reserve banking, but I haven't seen them.

Fixing that will, potentially fix the issue ... Or completely crash everything.

Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by chowchowchow on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:12PM (#42617186)
Ahh, “end the fed” doesn’t mean end the fed, OK. Because if you did end the fed, you’d have unregulated banking and maybe a return to wildcat banking which um, would probably not be better for your long term finances.

A quick perusal of Wikipedia’s article on the history of banking would reveal that banks figured out they could lend out more than the amount they had in deposit well before the concept of a central bank came into being, and the central banks’ role has historically been to keep things at least somewhat under control. So again, to put it simply, blaming the fed seems totally misguided here.

Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by ImJamal on Monday January 06, 2025 @08:29PM (#42618218)
I don't think you understand how catchy phrases work. You don't make your phrase 50 words long to accurately convey your thoughts or it will never catch on. The majority of those advocating for ending the fed are Austrian economics supporters who consider the Fed, and the things they are involved with, to be things that need to end and use the phrase end the fed to encompass all of that.
Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by chowchowchow on Monday January 06, 2025 @10:51PM (#42618989)
Heh. I think it’s more likely most people saying that don’t really know what it’d entail.

For instance without our current banking and financial system you’d have to pay banks to look after your money, if all they were allowed to do with it was hold on to it. This would have a similar drag on your principal as inflation does on buying power.

Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by ericmcer on Monday January 06, 2025 @12:56PM (#42613074)
Just invest in the market or you get your savings chewed up. I think it unlikely that the government, the Fed and huge corps are going to stop printing money because it has been working great (for them). Almost 100% of my money is in VOO and VOOG ETFs. Maybe 5% in cash, no real estate or other assets.
Re:As Gen X Nears Retirement, Many Fear They Can't Afford It by thoughtstheseus on Monday January 06, 2025 @02:27PM (#42614453)
You can see this dynamic in various investment markets. Stocks are priced according to their expected earnings while fart coin is a repository of excess liquidity. If you massively increase liquidity through money/debt creation you pump asset prices. Assets with a well determined return profile are inflated, but those with an unknown distribution (speculation)see an explosion of value. Only people with large stores of wealth can invest in the memes without risking financial ruin from crashes. Terrible policy choice imo