Re:Advice for Marissa Mayer from an ex-Yahoo
by Schwolop on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @09:55PM
(#4258957)
That's an incredibly reductionist view
Now that is a pithy retort I must commit to memory! Ouch.
Re:Advice for Marissa Mayer from an ex-Yahoo
by waterlesscloud on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @10:10PM
(#4259007)
It's also simply not true at a company like Google where the strong-visioned founders are still in charge.
Maybe with 2nd or 3rd generation leaders Google et al will be maximizing shareholder value for the sake of maximizing shareholder value. But not yet. They're still doing what their founders want them to do.
Re:Advice for Marissa Mayer from an ex-Yahoo
by mikeash on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @10:55PM
(#4259146)
Technically, Google is maximizing shareholder value, but their major shareholders value stuff beyond mere money. Not intending to detract from your point in any way, I just thought it's an interesting way to approach it.
Re:Advice for Marissa Mayer from an ex-Yahoo
by MatthewPhillips on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @10:01PM
(#4258973)
Of course every company has a "vision statement" on the wall. That doesn't mean it's a real thing that's worth discussing on HN. Even if a tiny percentage of companies truly believe and adhere to it. Google+ certainly isn't anything about "organizing the world's information".
In what way are the social connections between people and the things they share with one another not information? In some sense, that's the most valuable information out there, which is why not having it scared the shit out of Google.
"Maximize shareholder value" is not a company. A company needs vision, it needs to do something or build something. A company needs profit, and preferably lots of it, yes, but it also needs a guiding philosophy that informs the markets it enters and the ways it enters them. You can call it "marketing fluff", but it's what makes the company what it is. For the best companies, profit is part of the vision, but it does not subsume the vision.
Google and Apple are both very successful companies, but they're both very different. You can deride the difference between them as marketing fluff, but I call it "successfully executing on vision."