I’d rather avoid these sort of meaningless labels and just focus on doing what I think is important.
Like it I wanted to reduce climate impact and I was a bank, I would set up a page that lists all the ways I impact climate.
If you believe corporations tend to fall short of their external appearances, then what reason do you have to believe this isn’t still the case, but from a lower basis?
I.e. you assume:
Before: 8 goodness points (apparent) = 6 goodness points (actual)
Now: 6 goodness points (apparent) = 6 goodness points (actual)
Wouldn’t your logic actually indicate their new goodness points (actual) should be 4?
ESG actively allocated investment dollars that were specifically designated for socially and environmentally responsible businesses into oil & gas companies, so in that case keeping up appearances is actively making things worse than doing nothing.
This sort of thing has sucked the air from anyone actually doing useful meaningful things - since anyone paying attention just rolls their eyes when someone talks about being green or whatever. Sure, some companies and orgs actually are legitimately doing useful and interesting stuff - but it takes so much personal research into each one now that anyone blathering about how they are green is met with instant suspicion to anyone remotely paying attention to the space.
The less administrative and marketing driven grift the better, even if it's a tiny little baby step. This sort of thing has done more to harm the environmental movement than helped it from where I'm standing.
Do you really expect real movement on climate change now?
We should all stop being naive. A corporation only mandate is profits, always increasing ones. All else is secondary.
It's the role of elected governments to regulate that their incessant chase for profits don't harm society.
If society puts in place a government that doesn't care to regulate corporations in their harmful ways, well, in a sense society has spoken.