Re:Could the Soviet Union have survived?
by karmakurtisaani on Thursday January 02, 2025 @06:26AM
(#42573556)
I'm inclined to think with modern statistical and computational methods one could get close to a working planned economy. However, taking into account corruption and politics, this model would break within a decade and lead to inefficiencies and shortages.
I think there might be a similarity in our market economy models and their blind spots related to limited resources and environmental considerations.
Re:Could the Soviet Union have survived?
by mike_hearn on Thursday January 02, 2025 @06:44AM
(#42573630)
It would be the most amazing hacking target ever. I don't even know how you'd defend a computer system that critical, especially not during wartime.
https://www.amazon.com/Cows-Discover-These-Farm-Childrens/dp...
No central planner is going to sign off on selling that. More importantly, Amazon doesn't try to set all prices. On its market, sellers are allowed to set their own prices and frequently use complex strategies to do so. The heart of central planning is an attempt to have one institution set all prices.
> It's sort of an article of faith in economics that a centrally planned economy can't work
It is now, sure, because of all the attempts to make it work that failed. Back when the USSR was new it was the other way around, the intellectual class were convinced that the Soviet system was better and the future. That included some economists!
The problem with centrally planned economics wasn't a lack of compute power, it was that the information needed to select the correct prices isn't something you can gather in one place. A lot of it exists only in people's minds and isn't even written down anywhere.