News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why it's hard to trust software, but you mostly have to a... by gjsman-1000 on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @11:39AM (#42559799)
How many structural parts does a school have that need to be considered? How many iron beams? How many floors? Several thousand at most? Everything else on the BOM doesn’t matter - wallpaper isn’t a structural priority.

In computer code, every last line is possibly structural. It also only takes a single missing = in the 1.2 million line codebase to kill.

Comparing it to school engineering is an oversimplification. You should be comparing it to verifying the structural integrity of every skyscraper ever built; for each project.

Re:Why it's hard to trust software, but you mostly have to a... by aeonik on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @12:47PM (#42560358)
Chemical and elemental properties of the walls and wall paper can matter though.

Leaded paint, Aresenic, flammability, weight (steel walls vs sheet rock).

The complexity is still less than software though, and there are much better established standards of things that work together.

Even if a screw is slightly wrong, it can still work.

In software it's more like, every screw must have monocrystalline design, any grain boundary must be properly accounted for, and if not, that screw can take out an entire section of the building, possibly the whole thing, possibly the entire city.

Re:Why it's hard to trust software, but you mostly have to a... by whatever1 on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @01:25PM (#42560654)
The claim was not that it will be easy, but since the stakes are high the buck has to stop somewhere. You cannot have Devin AI shipping crap and nobody picking up the phone when it hits the fan.