News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by acabal on Monday December 30, 2024 @03:18PM (#42553036)
Some time ago I read You Can't Win[1], a 1926 memoir by a hobo-by-choice named Jack Black. He describes his life as a hobo in various cities (including SF!), and the picture he paints of the turn-of-the-century will be eerily familiar to anyone living in a major US city today: huge numbers of homeless hopelessly addicted to wine and opium (called "hop") that was cheap and easily accessible in streets and flophouses; tent cities lining the outskirts of town; entire communities of people living in that fashion and outright refusing to re-enter society.

The big difference between now and the turn of the 20th century is that back then, the law had little to no tolerance for public vagrancy. Jack Black describes dodging sheriffs, being locked up for the crimes of vagrancy and burglary, spending long stretches of time in prison and emerging completely unreformed, immediately returning to his life of encampment and crime. Even though ultimately his behavior didn't change, the law made him spend significant lengths of time removed from society.

I don't know what the lesson is here, if there is one. While a century ago their approach also didn't solve the problem, it did result in more livable cities for everyone else in the meantime. Perhaps one takeaway here is that it the problem isn't truly "solvable" given how we have structured our markets-based society.

[1] https://standardebooks.org/ebooks/jack-black/you-cant-win

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by IncreasePosts on Monday December 30, 2024 @03:24PM (#42553097)
"homeless" is a very broad term, and I think we need to segment it out because not everyone needs the same response.

The single parent who is trying to make life work, who loses her job for some reason, and becomes homeless? Compassion.

The drug addicted thief who has no interest in being a part of society, who basically wants to live that way? I don't think compassion is the right answer. If you show compassion to that type, you will just be taken advantage of.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by kstrauser on Monday December 30, 2024 @03:26PM (#42553125)
We should have compassion for everyone, albeit it's pretty difficult for genuinely horrible people. However, compassion doesn't mean giving them everything they want without conditions. That's enablement, and isn't compassionate at all.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by plagiarist on Monday December 30, 2024 @04:00PM (#42553459)
I agree. Maybe it would be neat if we could criminalize the theft part instead of the homelessness and drug addiction?
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by kstrauser on Monday December 30, 2024 @04:16PM (#42553642)
I am completely on board with that idea.

It shouldn't be a crime to be homeless. It should be a crime to do criminal things.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by piva00 on Monday December 30, 2024 @08:08PM (#42555380)
> The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by plagiarist on Monday December 30, 2024 @08:21PM (#42555445)
Homelessness is illegal for everyone and wage theft is a civil court case for everyone. A truly just and equitable system with prosperity for all.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by piva00 on Monday December 30, 2024 @08:28PM (#42555485)
I invite you to read the quote again juxtaposed with your reply. I don't think you got it.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by kstrauser on Monday December 30, 2024 @08:32PM (#42555498)
I read their words as sarcastic, and agreeing with you.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @05:45PM (#42554395)
I think some things said in this discussion are genuinely horrible - should I hate those people? Should they be locked up?
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by kstrauser on Monday December 30, 2024 @08:18PM (#42555430)
> I think some things said in this discussion are genuinely horrible - should I hate those people?

You do you. I try not to hate anyone, although I grant myself some leniency when considering child molesters, serial killers, and other people I find despicable.

> Should they be locked up?

100% of the people I strongly dislike have done things that should earn them jail time. I don't know what your thresholds are.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @09:54PM (#42555937)
> 100% of the people I strongly dislike have done things that should earn them jail time. I don't know what your thresholds are.

That seems a bit too convenient and perfect. But people were talking about using police on homeless people, who aren't child molesters and serial killers.

> other people I find despicable

That's the problem - your personal feelings aren't relevant.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by kstrauser on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:31PM (#42556173)
I have no idea what you're trying to say, and I suspect you might've completely misunderstood what I wrote.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by jyounker on Friday January 03, 2025 @10:43AM (#42586603)
The most effective policy for fixing homeless is, surprise, giving people places to live.

It's hard for people to address any other problems in their life unless they have a roof over their head, if for no other reason that the homeless are chronically severely under-slept.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @05:44PM (#42554382)
The subtext is, 1) People like me but on hard times get compassion, people unlike me get hate. 2) Hate is an ok response.

I've never regretted compassion.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by cr125rider on Monday December 30, 2024 @07:41PM (#42555235)
It’s not hate it’s just not forcing society on someone who doesn’t want it.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by JohnMakin on Monday December 30, 2024 @03:22PM (#42553085)
Per your own post you claim two things - that a very similar (and possibly worse) problem existed with ruthless enforcement, yet the problem was still bad. Why is then your conclusion/question that we need more of that, or I guess to more accurately paraphrase what you said, less compassion than we have now? Those things don’t really seem to logically follow.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by flustercan on Monday December 30, 2024 @03:55PM (#42553404)
> yet the problem was still bad.

My reading of the comment is that homelessness was not solved but ruthless enforcement made the issues related to homelessness less bad for everyone else who wasn't homeless.

System 1 (permissiveness): Bad for a small percentage of people and sorta bad for everyone else.

System 2 (strict enforcement): Really bad for a small percentage of people, neutral bad for everyone else.

System 3 (theoretical): Everything works pretty well for everyone.

Obviously system 3 is the best option, but it doesn't exist currently in any society anywhere on earth (maybe Japan?) System 2 seems to be the next best option to use while we keep trying to find a workable system 3.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @05:39PM (#42554337)
People have the exact same rights and freedom as you, whether or not they have housing or do things you like. That's what freedom is - doing things you don't like.

People love advertising their embrace of dictatorship and oppression, as if it's clever or smart. It's really a failure of responsibility and duty.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by flustercan on Monday December 30, 2024 @06:02PM (#42554574)
All I want is for the laws on the books to be enforced. If a majority decides those laws are bad, they should be taken off the books.

Its currently against the law to litter, shoplift, vandalize, defecate in public, be visibly intoxicated in public, and store private property in public spaces. I think we should enforce those laws.

Should some of those laws be rewritten or abandoned? Maybe! But simply ignoring active laws is the definition of lawlessness and I don't want to live in a lawless community.

There is quite a lot of space in between "I think having laws is good, actually" and "embrace of dictatorship and oppression" but I guess this wouldn't be an internet board discussion without hyperbolic statements.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:33PM (#42556422)
> All I want is for the laws on the books to be enforced.

That's an old rationalization of oppression. The reality is that we don't want all the laws enforced on themselves or their friends, and the laws are never enforced in toto on anyone, except the politically vulnerable.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by xcrunner529 on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @01:10AM (#42556800)
We can’t camp in parks and monopolize them for ourselves, nor should the homeless.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @08:08AM (#42558471)
The law, in its majestic equality, forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to steal their bread.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @01:39PM (#42560763)
You are free to beg in the halls and offices of Congress, however, if you ask for at least $10 million.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by xcrunner529 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @03:20PM (#42568950)
I guess the poor should be allowed to kill too while we’re at it.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by bryanrasmussen on Sunday January 05, 2025 @02:08AM (#42600258)
the rather famous quote of course has one point to it - that is those laws mentioned are ones only the poor have any interest in doing, although both rich and poor share the capability of it.

Thus the correct response is not to talk about killing, which is something both the rich and poor have an interest in doing as well as sharing capability, and are often caught doing, but rather:

The law in its majestic equality forbids rich and poor alike from insider trading, or dumping hazardous materials into downstream waters from their factories.

This, rhetorically speaking, would seem to counter the original quote nicely, in showing that the law of course prevents Rich and poor alike in doing things that they have interests in doing, but no poor person is insider trading or dumping hazardous materials from their factories, because the definition of poor includes that they cannot be doing these things.

The thing of course is that the poor may have an interest in insider trading but lack the capacity, whereas everybody has the capacity to sleep under bridges but only the poor really seem to have an interest in it, and really they only have that interest because they are poor.

Which leads me to the following conclusion:

The interests of the poor are forbidden. The capacities of the rich are regulated.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by xcrunner529 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @12:20AM (#42619511)
Hmm I guess I get that. I have so much frustration with all the public spaces being piss pits I guess I miss things.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by metalman on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @07:49AM (#42558390)
The constituion is bieng ignored,over written, its basic ideals ridiculed, and is unfortunatly the source of ALL LAW.

Not one of the "new laws" bieng enforced or ignored is therfor valid.

Questions of legitamcy and precident are ridiculous.

Enforcing the first page of the constitution, fixes everything.

The other possibility, is decaring a total government shutdown, martial law, and a mandatory partisipation is drafting a new constitution, with a maximum of 10 pages.

Constitution, then enforcement procedure, but no more "laws", and laws, and laws, and laws, thinking of pi here, infinitly non repeating but with a sense of horror, rather than wonder

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by bryanrasmussen on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @08:00AM (#42558434)
In S.L.C Utah in the late 80s it was against the law for homeless people to ask for spare change.

One time I was walking with a friend, and a homeless guy asked me for some change and I gave it to him (most of the time I wouldn't because I wasn't exactly rich myself, but at just that time I felt like it), then I turned to cross the street before I had gotten 3 feet from giving the guy the spare change two cops swooped out from seemingly nowhere, accosted me and my friend, and started asking "what did he ask you? did you give him money", this was also quite aggressive the tone of voice of these cops.

Now I'm not the quickest guy on the uptake in these kinds of situations but luckily I was firing on all cylinders that day and so I said "no I didn't give me any money, he asked me what time it was leave me alone" loud enough that the homeless guy who was being detained by a third cop could hear me.

So after a bit more harassment they let us and the homeless guy go.

So first off a lot of laws are quite clearly unconstitutional, and it is an abrogation of freedom of speech that a homeless guy isn't allowed to ask me for money, no matter how uncomfortable it might make me.

My interpretation of rights is that any law which would actually itself be against the laws of the land does not need to be followed at all, but I have noticed that some people who hold your views believe that there are processes whereby illegitimate laws get nullified and until those processes are followed the law should be followed. Do you hold to this view?

Furthermore I would ask are there any laws that you would consider illegitimate? If so what are you doing personally to overturn those? I have encountered the viewpoint, generally in Americans, that the laws that are illegitimate should be followed until overturned and the duty of overturning those unjust laws fall only on the people who care about and are affected by those laws - is this also your viewpoint or do you think it falls on every citizen to oppose the unjust laws to their utmost?

Given the necessity to uphold the law that you believe in (meaning you believe in the necessity above other things) was I under an obligation to tell the police that the homeless guy asked me for money, and that I gave it to him?

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by flustercan on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @03:08PM (#42568853)
>I have noticed that some people who hold your views believe that there are processes whereby illegitimate laws get nullified and until those processes are followed the law should be followed. Do you hold to this view?

Yeah sorta, my point was more about enforcement than compliance. I don't necessarily think unjust laws should be followed but it certainly should not be up to each individual police officer to decide which laws gets enforced on which people.

If a law is unjust enough and enough people choose to disobey it and the legal system is forced to get involved constantly then I believe we would see a lot more change in the law than with our current system of writing laws then letting cops selectively enforce them.

>Furthermore I would ask are there any laws that you would consider illegitimate? If so what are you doing personally to overturn those?

Yes, just about any restriction on abortion. What am I doing? Not much other than voting, occasionally donating money, and choosing to never live in a state that writes those laws. Would what I do change if there were, say, a national abortion ban? Probably, but I certainly won't count on the police joining in on whatever form of protest I see fit.

I don't think the laws around shoplifting, public intoxication, vandalism, etc. are bad and I am doing nothing to overturn them.

> Given the necessity to uphold the law that you believe in (meaning you believe in the necessity above other things) was I under an obligation to tell the police that the homeless guy asked me for money, and that I gave it to him?

No, but the cops who saw you do it were obliged to follow whatever procedure was written into the law. Does SLC still have this law? Having been involved in the enforcement of this law, were you more aware that the law existed and you wanted it changed?

The laws are written democratically, then enforced dictatorially by the whim of a few individuals with a gun. I think this is bad.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by NicholasGurr on Monday December 30, 2024 @07:24PM (#42555129)
> That's what freedom is - doing things you don't like.

You don’t like having your family murdered, but according to your definition, freedom must be murdering your family.

Or it could be you just drew up a trite definition for the purpose of argument.

We do all have the same rights and freedoms. Thing is, being part of society, we often have the same expectations and responsibilities (simple ones like not shitting on the street, not leaving used needles in children’s playgrounds, little things like that). A visible segment of the homeless population isn’t holding up their end of the bargain.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by cr125rider on Monday December 30, 2024 @07:39PM (#42555227)
Yes but many of the things that homeless people do is illegal in the eyes of the law, they just look the other way.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:34PM (#42556427)
They look the other way for lots of people doing lots of things. Let's start enforcing laws at the top, where the actions are far more consequential, rather than on the vulnerable people at the bottom.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by flustercan on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @03:31PM (#42569051)
Sounds like we agree, enforce all the laws.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @05:36PM (#42569889)
That would be very oppressive and expensive, and I doubt you really mean it beyond theoretically.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by nobodyandproud on Monday December 30, 2024 @08:12PM (#42555400)
I don’t like how you make System 1 to be somehow the lesser of two evils.

System 1/2 are both extremely awful, but in different ways.

System 3 would be highly affordable and available housing, coupled with out-of-sight permissiveness but strict enforcement once certain indicative lines are crossed.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by xcrunner529 on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @01:11AM (#42556805)
An LA school literally had to put up fencing to hide the homeless next door from being sexual deviants and exposing themselves to children.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by nobodyandproud on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @09:11AM (#42558797)
So then, aren’t you essentially agreeing with me? That permissiveness isn’t better?
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by xcrunner529 on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @03:19PM (#42568945)
Yep
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by throwaway_5633 on Monday December 30, 2024 @09:30PM (#42555798)
I live in the Netherlands and I’d say we mostly have a system 3, there is little problematic homelessness, housing is often available to those not wanting to live on the street, shelters ban anyone intoxicated. Drug rehabilitation is available to the homelessness (including free alternative drug prescriptions). Public intoxication is policed. If I see someone living in a tent it’s exceptional enough to point it out to a friend.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by swexbe on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @04:57AM (#42557678)
Japan absolutely has a homelessness problem. Not anywhere near as bad as California’s. In my experience they mostly keep themselves out of the way as opposed to western homeless. Not sure if this is due to stricter enforcement or cultural practices.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by ozzzy1 on Monday December 30, 2024 @03:37PM (#42553232)
Yea, I'm not seeing this compassionate approach we have been doing for the past decades apparently.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by bradleyjg on Monday December 30, 2024 @03:50PM (#42553358)
We spend an enormous amount of money. Unfortunately most of it goes to well meaning, but ineffectual do-gooders rather than actually solving any problems.

Voters very much want a compassionate and effective solution. They just aren’t being offered one.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @05:54PM (#42554468)
Is there a location you are talking about?

> Unfortunately most of it goes to well meaning, but ineffectual do-gooders rather than actually solving any problems.

It sounds like the generic arguments of certain political parties, using terms like 'do-gooders' and calling them 'ineffectual', etc. Is there evidence behind it, in your locale?

The main issue I've seen is that public services are underfunded.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by bradleyjg on Monday December 30, 2024 @07:04PM (#42555011)
The main issue I've seen is that public services are underfunded.

How do you explain Vancouver or Stockholm’s homeless populations? Those famously underfunded Swedish and Canadian welfare states?

Some people just can’t wait to spend other people’s money and aren’t too picky about whether or not it’ll accomplish anything.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by piva00 on Monday December 30, 2024 @08:05PM (#42555361)
To be honest, homelessness in Stockholm is really, really low. The very few homeless I see here are in a couple of spots in the city (mainly by Östermalmstorgs t-bana) are there by choice and go into shelters most nights.

I don't ever see homeless people in tents or anything similar.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by bradleyjg on Monday December 30, 2024 @09:13PM (#42555698)
I was there a little under a decade and saw plenty of vagrants. Not comparable to sf or anything but they were there.

If you’ve cleared it all up since then, kudos. But I don’t think it’s because public services were underfunded back then.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @09:52PM (#42555926)
Your evidence is some anecodtal experience from a decade ago? How do you know the causes of what you remember seeing?
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by piva00 on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:58PM (#42556290)
What kind of vagrants? There used to be tons of roma people panhandling but they aren't homeless, and since the pandemic they're much less numerous (I'd guess I see less than a 1/5 of what I used to).

I really don't think you saw "plenty" of homeless on the streets here, not now and not a decade ago. Panhandlers, beggars, etc. do exist but they aren't homeless.

I do not trust your anecdotal experience, not saying the issue doesn't exist but it's not even close to a problem and orders of magnitude less than anything I've experienced traveling in the USA, around the Bay Area, Texas (Austin/Dallas), New York, Portland, Chicago, Detroit, Boston, and a few other places had a very acute and visible issue with homelessness that's incomparable with Stockholm.

So yes, public services being properly funded help a lot.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @09:50PM (#42555913)
> Some people just can’t wait to spend other people’s money and aren’t too picky about whether or not it’ll accomplish anything

What value does that have? You must have something valuable to contribute.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by bradleyjg on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:02PM (#42555993)
I suggest you peruse Matthew 7:5. I have nothing further to say to you.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by xcrunner529 on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @01:13AM (#42556812)
Are you literally citing a religious text for policy in a free country? Lmao.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by rndmize on Monday December 30, 2024 @09:20PM (#42555741)
https://calmatters.org/commentary/2023/07/something-clearly-...

This says CA averages spending 42k per year per homeless person, going off the 2022-2021 state budget.

https://abc7news.com/sf-homeless-plan-housing-all-san-franci...

This says SF is looking to spend 70k per homeless person per year in the next few years (in addition to state spending?). I've seen other pieces that mention SF spending anywhere from 250 mil to over a billion per year on homelessness. I have multiple friends that make less than 70k per year, in CA, and somehow make do. Lack of money doesn't seem to be the issue here.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by aksss on Monday December 30, 2024 @03:40PM (#42553260)
I think his conclusion was that enforcement at least makes the city more livable for the people who do choose to be a part of society, air-gapping the problems endemic to vagrancy (assault, abuse, drugs, crime), while having at least a margin deterrence effect.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @05:56PM (#42554490)
> for the people who do choose to be a part of society

That's a pretty crazy qualification: Either be go along with and be accepted by the majority or you are subject to sanctions. That is the opposite of freedom and universal rights.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by devilbunny on Monday December 30, 2024 @07:24PM (#42555128)
> go along with and be accepted by the majority or you are subject to sanctions.

That's pretty much criminal law in a nutshell. There are expectations if you want others to tolerate your oddities, one of which is you don't get to impose on them.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:26PM (#42556392)
> That's pretty much criminal law in a nutshell.

It's the opposite. Others liking you or not is irrelevant.

> There are expectations if you want others to tolerate your oddities, one of which is you don't get to impose on them.

You absolutely do get to 'impose' them. You can't cause harm to others, but their subjective distaste or apprehension or whatever is not harm. That's what freedom is about.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by devilbunny on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @10:36PM (#42563784)
Interesting philosophy, but you do you.

> You can't cause harm to others, but their subjective distaste or apprehension or whatever is not harm.

You know there's a reason that there's never been a successful hyperlibertarian society, right? Some people are assholes.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @02:07AM (#42564466)
This isn't hyperlibertarian or one person's philosophy, it's the foundation of US society, law, and politics.

The Declaration of Independence centers on the inalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. Core to the Constitution is the Bill of Rights. Liberty and justice for all; Marines fight for freedom; land of the free, Statue of Liberty, etc.

If freedom is only doing things other people like, it's meaningless. Causing harm is one thing. People may not like you - maybe I don't like you. Can I pass a law to jail you?

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by devilbunny on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @08:04AM (#42565772)
Are you persisting in the idea that homeless tent cities are not a harm to those who are subject to them? It’s a bit meme-ish, but sidewalk poop is actually a quality of life issue.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @05:35PM (#42569882)
> tent cities are not a harm to those who are subject to them

Nothing inherent about tent cities harms neighbors. They could be badly located but so can lots of things. They suck as housing, but the residents wouldn't be there if they had better options.

> It’s a bit meme-ish

Whatever this means, who cares? We're talking about shelter and human rights, not memes.

> sidewalk poop is actually a quality of life issue

Yes, that could be an actual health risk, but I think people are searching for a justification. I'm dubious it's really a big problem, or one that requires taking away anyone's freedom. How about providing a bathroom?

If it's ok to take away people's freedom, why don't you give up yours? We could force you to walk down a different sidewalk.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by aksss on Monday December 30, 2024 @08:37PM (#42555519)
Crazy? To be fair, the minimum bar in American society these days is pretty dang low. Don’t steal, don’t rape, don’t physically assault, don’t walk nude on the sidewalk, don’t poop on the floor of the grocery store, leave the kids alone. With these simple tricks you can largely be ignored to be the “you” which you want to be.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:28PM (#42556402)
This discussion and what happens in reality shows the opposite: Being unhoused, having a drug addiction, being perceived as having mental health issues, lack of cleanliness, etc. is all treated as deserving of hate and being a target of oppression - people here are openly calling for oppression - and being treated as a criminal.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by aksss on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @02:33AM (#42557150)
I think you're mistaking society targeting the outcomes and behaviors of vagrancy, to which addiction and mental health can lead (theft, pooping in the wrong places). The social glare starts earlier because of a pretty reliable correlation. That's less about intentional cruelty and more about saving the ship.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by mmooss on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @01:28PM (#42560682)
One justification after another to abuse people, is what I read.

> pretty reliable correlation

I have yet to see that correlation. To my eye, there is a correlation between some things and a lack of housing. For example, access to bathrooms.

But the obsession with poop is becoming childish; poop - gross! In all my time in cities, I don't know that I've ever seen it. I don't know that it's a common problem, but just a dramatic example that advocates like to pull out.

> That's less about intentional cruelty and more about saving the ship.

First, people here are openly embracing cruelty. Second, 'unintentional cruely' would be a highly immature, irresponsible concept.

I think 'saving the ship' is greatly exaggerating the risks in order to justify the abuse. It's a very serious thing to take away someone's inherent, inalienable freedom.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by bediger4000 on Monday December 30, 2024 @06:56PM (#42554954)
You're forgetting all the prison related employment. That's got to count for something.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by schaefer on Monday December 30, 2024 @03:56PM (#42553414)
What a great book recommendation. Thank you.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by throw16180339 on Monday December 30, 2024 @05:30PM (#42554265)
You might also like Down and Out in Paris and London by George Orwell.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by morkalork on Monday December 30, 2024 @04:09PM (#42553559)
One thing you mention, floop houses, aka single room occupancy (SRO) units don't really exist anymore though. They were shut down over higher building code standards (because fires) and public health concerns. Although those issues were often overstated and it was supposedly "morality" concerns that played a bigger part. Now since covid, rent has increased dramatically and there's been a corresponding increase in working, non-addict, homeless where I live and that type of housing could help.
Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by Derawk on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @10:30AM (#42559257)
Everyone is different, and homelessness is complicated. Ideally you just build the housing - that should be enough for many. But, there are plenty others who can’t function due to illness — and/or have made certain choices not to participate in society.

I believe that the greater majority fall into the homeless not by choice but I’ve befriended several homeless by choice people. They take advantage of all the services and often have no incentive or intention to participate in society in any meaningful way. They tend to dislike authority and value personal freedom above all else. They are often friendly and very intelligent but they love to piss people off too.

It’s easier to spot these people in times of housing abundance so we should solve the shortage first IMO.

Re:What I Learned Reporting in Cities That Take Belongings f... by tharmas on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @10:51AM (#42559429)
Agreed. The only solution to the housing problem is building public housing. Yes, theres all kinds of problems with that but a nice side effect is it reduces housing costs for all income groups.

But of course for those who bought a house for financial investment purposes (retirement plan, rent seeking, flipping) solving the housing problem is not a benefit.