News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by frereubu on Monday December 30, 2024 @09:48AM (#42549723)
TOTP suffers from a similar issue - I use 1Password to store my TOTP codes, but both Google and the UK's HMRC tax website talk about using their own apps for codes rather than anything agreed like "one-time passwords". The digital world is rife with this kind of jockeying for position through language. It took me far too long to understand that "podcasts" are just mp3 files from an RSS feed.

Likewise, in the heyday of interactive TV in the early 2000s, when it was going to conquer the world because everyone had a TV but not a computer, an agency I worked for were invited for a demonstration of a choose-your-own-adventure game they were developing. They kept referencing a "carousel system" where all pages were sent in a looping system and when someone made a choice it waited until that page came round in the "carousel". I kept asking whether that was like Teletext - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teletext - but they absolutely refused to say that and kept saying "well, it's a carousel system".

This refusal to deal in everyday language, alongside trying to get people to use their own apps / sytems, really hinders the adoption of useful technologies.

Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by ffsm8 on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:41AM (#42550252)
That's not what podcasts are at all?

Most of the popular ones are primarily viewed with video even...

A more realistic description would be "a mostly unedited dialogue between people, usually published in a series"

Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by hoherd on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:09AM (#42550560)
https://providersupport.spotify.com/article/podcast-delivery... shows literally every data element as "RSS/something"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Podcast says "Podcasting is the preparation and distribution of audio or video files using RSS feeds to the devices of subscribed users."

Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by ffsm8 on Monday December 30, 2024 @11:39AM (#42550862)
TIL that the average HN reader believes that podcast is a Spotify trademark and their technological implementation is it's definition.

Guess what the biggest or at least most notorious podcast is?

The joe Rogan experience.

Guess what it's primary distribution was, way before Spotify paid him millions to come to their platform?

Yes, Video.

And literally the first paragraph of your Wikipedia link proves my point. Your reading comprehension really seems to be horrendous.

I hope y'all already drunk, as the alternative is really disheartening

Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by bananagoat on Monday December 30, 2024 @12:07PM (#42551175)
Spotify does not have a trademark on rss podcast delivery. RSS feeds have historically been the primary delivery method for podcasts and it long predates Spotify and the JRE. Many of the most popular or historically significant primarily used RSS: Serial, This American Life, Stuff You Should Know—the list goes on and on. Some podcasts are distributed via video, but even many of those also have a corresponding rss feed for the audio version.

Here’s the rss feed for Joe Rogan https://feeds.megaphone.fm/GLT1412515089

If you use a podcast app today, it is guaranteed to be primarily fetching from RSS feeds.

I’m pretty sure the kind of insulting rhetoric you’re using is against the rules here. You may prefer Reddit for starting those kinds of arguments.

Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by ffsm8 on Monday December 30, 2024 @04:23PM (#42553705)
I didn't claim it had a trademark, but if you literally skipped entirely over the comment I was responding to: he quoted the Spotify docs for their podcast APIs as an argument why podcasts are RSS/MP3

And his second link literally confirmed how entirely wrong his own claim was, within literally the first paragraph. Which you seem to have skipped over too....

So where does that leave us? With now two very confused commentors that seem to be unable to read, hence my previous quip about reading comprehension

Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by eudidjhdjf on Monday December 30, 2024 @01:13PM (#42551915)
>That is definitively what they were when the term "podcast" was new and I was trying to figure it out

Reading comprehension. Or are we just starting the clock from when the Joe Rogan podcast began?

>And literally the first paragraph of your Wikipedia link proves my point. Your reading comprehension really seems to be horrendous<

Are you ESL or something? Because the Wikipedia link is referring to the modern context in that paragraph.

Here, we can overcome the way society failed you together.

>The first edition was published on August 13, 2004, as a live show that software developers could use as a test for their download software. Podcasting technically already existed at that time, but Adam was the first to bring together RSS, scripting, and actual audio content<

You're disabled so maybe you were confused when you read

>In October 2000, the concept of attaching sound and video files in RSS feeds was proposed in a draft by Tristan Louis.[18] The idea was implemented by Dave Winer, a software developer and an author of the RSS format.[19]<

But the key word in this sentence is "proposed", as in speaking to what was possible but not what had been done yet. I'd add a flashcard of that one to my vocab deck since it seems like one of the harder ones for you.

So yes, early podcasts were audio and RSS and Joe Rogan wasn't around yet.

Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by ffsm8 on Monday December 30, 2024 @04:13PM (#42553601)
In case your genius mind wasn't able to comprehend this amazing concept: the technical implementation of podcasts in 2000 does not define the concept of a podcast.

Yes, once upon a time, that was the most common way podcasts were distributed. It however wasn't the definition of the word "podcast".

Did you get that, or was that once again too complicated for you?

Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by 384874833 on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @12:15AM (#42556594)
Shifting the goalposts after a flurry of adhominem. Stay classy.
Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by xethos on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:54AM (#42550403)
I'm not going to dictate MP3, but yes: podcasts absolutely are an audio file pulled from an RSS feed. Your description covers some podcasts, but not every podcast has video (which should be entirely optional if it's there at all, and frankly makes it less of a podcast in my opinion), and many go through some pretty heavy editing, even if just to balance audio levels, prune dead conversational branches, and remove filler words or dead air.
Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by Izkata on Monday December 30, 2024 @04:25PM (#42553732)
Part of it is right there in the name: "pod" came from iPod. The device that was audio-only.
Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by frereubu on Monday December 30, 2024 @12:40PM (#42551514)
That is definitively what they were when the term "podcast" was new and I was trying to figure it out - and in any case this seems like rather pointless hairsplitting.
Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by jazzyjackson on Monday December 30, 2024 @02:03PM (#42552387)
- distributed as mp3 files via RSS protocol
Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by frereubu on Monday December 30, 2024 @07:02PM (#42554992)
You seem to be relatively new here, so you may not have read the guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

You're being pretty abusive in this thread, which in turn has provoked others to be abusive, which is why the guidelines specifically on comments say things like this

- When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

- Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith.

- Please don't fulminate. Please don't sneer, including at the rest of the community.

You'll see one of your most abusive comments has been flagged. You'll find that happening more and more to you if you continue to comment like this.

Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by nashashmi on Monday December 30, 2024 @02:46PM (#42552716)
Not sure what you are talking about TOTP suffering from a similar issue.

TOTP works via a secret key provided by the service. The TOTP(secret key + time) function generates a 6 digit code. This is a standard. The secret key can be stored on Authenticators and those authenticators sync to cloud services.

When adding the secret key for the first time to your authenticator, you have to also copy that to a notepad. This way if you want to transfer the keys, you have them available. Authenticator apps don't always allow you to export the keys. TOTP.app is a good auth app that does allow but there is no sync to cloud capability.

Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by frereubu on Monday December 30, 2024 @06:50PM (#42554920)
What I mean is that they don't say "Scan this QR code with your time-based one-time password (TOTP) app." They say "scan this QR code with your Google Authenticator app" or "scan this code with the HMRC app", obfuscating the fact that you can scan that code with any app that supports TOTP authentication like 1Password, Bitwarden, Authy etc. All of those prompts should have a link saying "Click here if you're not sure what TOTP apps are" that goes to a page with links to a whole bunch of recognised authenticator apps, where they can show their own if they want to but also show others that people may already use.
Re:Passkey technology is elegant, but it's most definitely n... by nashashmi on Tuesday December 31, 2024 @11:12AM (#42559574)
Ah yes! TOTP education takes much time. There are very few people who have invested time in teaching the uninformed about TOTP. OTOH, many more have invested time in developing TOTP apps and hacks.