Re:Ask HN: Why do you care so much that you're being down vo...
by nkurz on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @02:18AM
(#4254382)
Encouraging a comment per down vote would have a strong negative impact on the readability of the site. I don't know what the daily number of down votes is, but I wouldn't be surprised if it's greater than the current number of comments. The on-topic comments would be overwhelmed by the meta-conversation.
But there definitely is value in providing this feedback. I think the solution is to offer a quieter way of doing so than via a globally visible comment. This feedback should be public to maintain civility and concision, but should be outside of the main stream of the conversation.
But there definitely is value in providing this feedback. I think the solution is to offer a quieter way of doing so than via a globally visible comment. This feedback should be public to maintain civility and concision, but should be outside of the main stream of the conversation.
My proposal is here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4209304