News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why do you care so much that you're being down vo... by ColinWright on Monday July 16, 2012 @04:57AM (#4249888)
For me it's not the karma, it's the implication that my well-intentioned comment that was intended to add value has been considered by someone in "the community" to be the opposite, and to be of negative value.

If that happens then there is a mis-match between my understanding and reality, and as a mathematician, engineer, hacker, and general learner for life, I want to know why. When people disagree with me it's an opportunity to learn, and I want to take that opportunity, especially from people who have chosen to self-identify with this "community."

Re:Ask HN: Why do you care so much that you're being down vo... by nkurz on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @02:18AM (#4254382)
Encouraging a comment per down vote would have a strong negative impact on the readability of the site. I don't know what the daily number of down votes is, but I wouldn't be surprised if it's greater than the current number of comments. The on-topic comments would be overwhelmed by the meta-conversation.

But there definitely is value in providing this feedback. I think the solution is to offer a quieter way of doing so than via a globally visible comment. This feedback should be public to maintain civility and concision, but should be outside of the main stream of the conversation.

My proposal is here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4209304

Re:Ask HN: Why do you care so much that you're being down vo... by pippy on Monday July 16, 2012 @11:25PM (#4253928)
The difficult thing is assessing your opinion whether it was downvoted because your opinion was fallacious or someone doesn't agree with it.

It does cause some problems with content, most notably bandwagons and mundane comments out of fear.