News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by yuvalr1 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @02:45AM (#42538382)
> Just to clarify on the facts, as gathered from reddit threads

Sadly this sentence does not compile. Facts cannot be gathered from Reddit threads, as we cannot know who is behind the messages. Facts can only be gathered from reliable sources. Therefor those are not facts, but hypotheses.

Other people in this thread are contradicting the Reddit hypotheses[1], who should we believe?

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42534182

Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by littlestymaar on Sunday December 29, 2024 @02:50AM (#42538399)
Idk about here in particular, but many reddit threads do in fact source their infos from reliable sources (unlike the HN post you're quoting)
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by RansomStark on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:01AM (#42538967)
> Facts can only be gathered from reliable sources.

Source?

How do you define reliable?

Why is the authors identity important?

Facts don't change because you know the authors name, or trust the source, or like the person telling lies.

The idea that anonymous sources, or "untrusted" sources (for someones definition of trusted) cannot be the source of facts is gaining ground right now, and it needs to be pushed back on wherever it is seen.

It's a lazy Ad hominem, and it's down right dangerous.

I don't care if it's elected officials claiming Russian malinformation or a random chess thread, this is the hill I choose to die on.

Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by sambeau on Sunday December 29, 2024 @06:23AM (#42539279)
The tradition of journalists using anonymous sources doesn’t mean they use anonymous sources, it means that they know who the source is, considers them reliable, but agrees not to name them. Usually they require multiple independent sources.

Unknown sources on the internet are usually not reliable. Anonymous sources should not be trusted, even when there are more than one saying the same thing. Bots and deliberate misinformation abound.

This is not a hill you should die on as it’s a hill that can greatly harm democratic society.

Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by verisimi on Sunday December 29, 2024 @06:49AM (#42539384)
Is democratic society the hill to die on? Sources?
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by braincat31415 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @01:42PM (#42541911)
That's one possibility. The other possibility is that the journalist mentions anonymous sources because he/she does not have any and is simply making stuff up.
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by andreasmetsala on Sunday December 29, 2024 @07:11PM (#42544900)
That’s why you verify the information from other sources.
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by braincat31415 on Sunday December 29, 2024 @09:45PM (#42545927)
Thank you Sherlock for this invaluable suggestion.

Quite often this is simply not possible.

Next time I read "according to our anonymous sources in the FBI", I'll make sure I reach out to them for verification.

Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by andreasmetsala on Friday January 03, 2025 @03:38AM (#42583781)
If you can’t verify it then that’s a rumor. The world doesn’t owe you an explanation and you can’t be informed of everything.
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by sambeau on Monday December 30, 2024 @10:32AM (#42550154)
That’s not journalism, that’s something else. There used to be fact checkers and editors used to have to verify the sources. I realise that the press barons no longer have any integrity, but it certainly used to be the rule.
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by bryanrasmussen on Sunday December 29, 2024 @07:25AM (#42539504)
Facts are things that actually happened, (knowledge of) facts can be gathered from Reddit threads but so can (knowledge of) bullshit that is erroneously thought to be facts.

on edit: note I do not say anything about verification, as that is a different thing as to whether or not a thing is a fact. Verification is about how sure the knowledge we have is a fact, but whether a fact is verified or not it remains a fact even if we do not know it is a fact.

Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by ekianjo on Sunday December 29, 2024 @08:28AM (#42539811)
> Facts can only be gathered from reliable sources.

Which mythical reliable sources? Humans are known to make errors regardless where they work.

Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by veidr on Sunday December 29, 2024 @09:09AM (#42540042)
Facts are facts, in the same way rocks are rocks.

You can gather them from anywhere they exist. There might be places where it is easier to gather facts than Reddit.

But wherever you get purported facts, it's hard to know whether they are merely claims, or actual facts. Most of us do indeed short-circuit our evaluation of claims when we trust the source, and although this sometimes causes us to wrongly believe false claims are facts, I think it's probably a good optimization on balance.

Nevertheless, "who should we believe?" remains one of the most fundamental questions of human existence. The tremendous energy required to confirm the factuality of even a trivial claim makes me agree with what I think is your premise — the quoted poster was making a highly dubious assertion of "facts".

But I think s/facts/claims/ would suffice to fix it.

Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by underlogic on Sunday December 29, 2024 @03:09PM (#42542615)
Common sense says that wearing jeans has exactly nothing to do with playing chess. No speculation necessary
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing... by ttyprintk on Monday December 30, 2024 @09:23AM (#42549496)
I need to know what brand Magnus was wearing. Jeans so cool they were banned from chess.