News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by columbo on Monday July 16, 2012 @09:08PM (#4253588)
I'm going to show my lack of linux history here... why not Debian? Are they really building something that is native to ubuntu that you wouldn't work in <insert-debian-fork crunchbang or mint>?
Re:Steam'd Penguins by Ralith on Monday July 16, 2012 @09:28PM (#4253659)
They're working with Canonical to make sure that it's well supported, and they chose them because Ubuntu in particular is focusing on making Linux for the mainstream. In this context, "supported" on a particular platform doesn't mean "can run," it means "should work out of the box for absolutely everyone." I have no doubt that, come the release on Ubuntu, unofficial packages will come into being for nearly every distro--and on Debian you probably won't even need that.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by trotsky on Monday July 16, 2012 @09:35PM (#4253675)
Ubuntu's the only major distribution (that I know of) that has an integrated and supported process for installing the closed video drivers you'll need to run their games on ati/nvidia.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by mitchty on Monday July 16, 2012 @09:46PM (#4253694)
Arch linux isn't all that hard, not sure if this counts as "integrated and supported"

But... # pacman -S nvidia nvidia-utils

https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/NVIDIA

Is all I did for the work install, took longer to finish the setup but thats more due to me having 2 monitors than anything else, one is mad simple. Can't speak to the ati stuff. I know SuSe is about as simple as well.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by wickedchicken on Monday July 16, 2012 @10:12PM (#4253755)
> Arch linux isn't all that hard

Yes. Yes it is.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by mediocregopher on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @12:14AM (#4254053)
(I wrote all this then realized I've gotten off the point, this isn't really addressed at your comment. I recognize that the typical computer user couldn't give a damn about customizing their system and certainly wouldn't bother with setting up Arch, which makes it a poor gaming platform. I'm just tired of constantly hearing about how hard Arch is. It isn't hard, it just takes a bit of effort).

I'd say Arch is pretty simple, just not easy [0]. Easy would be inserting the install cd, walking away, coming back and being able to hit the internet. Which is fine, if that's all you want to do. Arch installation isn't easy, it's simple, and more importantly it works. When I install windows from scratch you know what it comes with? Nothing. No drivers, no programs, nothing. Not even an ethernet driver for me to get the other drivers. Arch comes with all of it out of the box, you just need to go through the tutorial so you can choose which things in the box you actually want.

Arch is simple in that if I go to any scary looking file in /etc and open it up I won't be completely baffled by what's in it. I can randomly shut down any service running on my machine and I know my box will keep chugging and I can recover from it. There's no weird services that I don't know what they do, no scripts that run on startup that I can't understand let alone find. There aren't inter-dependencies that I don't know about. When I run ps aux I can account for every single thing running.

And even then, the package management is simple AND easy. I have never had a problem installing something with pacman, not once. There's this oft-repeated line about upgrades breaking systems, but I've never seen it. If an upgrade fails I look at the front page of archlinux.org and see that some manual commands are needed, copy-paste them and voila things work. I've used arch on three computers now, two laptops and a very old desktop, and have never had any problems. I know there's going to be some horror stories, but I can counter any of them with a quick search for the same in windows. Problems upgrading happen, but they're not common, and not something that's inherent to Arch like I've seen people suggest.

[0] http://www.infoq.com/presentations/Simple-Made-Easy

Re:Steam'd Penguins by wickedchicken on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @01:09AM (#4254187)
I'm a systems developer, not a distro maintainer. When I boot off of that iso, I want a menu that asks me this:

[ ] Desktop

[ ] Server

[ ] Embedded

[ ] Custom

This ultimately comes down to a user interface issue, but it's different than the kind of user interface often associated with the HN crowd. It's more like an API user interface, be that a web or programming library API. A crucial feature of good APIs is 'graceful degradation' in terms of easiness/control. Take a look at the libcURL library[1]. cURL has 3 levels of access: "easy," "share," and "multi." If you don't care about a lot of features and just want to download a webpage, the easy interface will get you what you want in a few lines of code. If you have something more complicated, you can go all the way down to the multi interface to access many of the raw functions of the API.

They key takeaway is giving the user control of her complexity level. If I'm a sysadmin compiling an image meant to be deployed on thousands of servers, then something like Arch would be pretty great -- I can fine-tune things how I want. If I'm just a random developer, then I would like to stick to 'sane defaults,' with the option to revisit those defaults later if needed.

I really don't care what cron I have, don't force me to pick one against my will.

[1] http://curl.haxx.se/libcurl/c/

Re:Steam'd Penguins by recursive on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @12:47AM (#4254132)
Every time I've installed Windows, it's come with basic drivers and programs.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by eitland on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @02:28AM (#4254408)
Short history lesson here then: Until recently installing Windows (except OEM) meant running driver CDs at least for stuff like network drivers (so you could connect to internet to download the updated drivers).
Re:Steam'd Penguins by jholman on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @03:07AM (#4254539)
Short history lesson: I have successfully gotten my Windows installs onto the internet without using driver CDs since at least Windows 98SE.

I dunno what I'm doing that's so magical; I just install the dang thing.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by danbee on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:00AM (#4254712)
This totally depends on the network card chipset. A fresh Windows 7 install on my PC requires external NIC drivers before I get on the net.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by fceccon on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:12AM (#4254744)
Same here, I installed Windows 7 on a PC with a fairly recent Asus MB and I had to install the drivers from the CD.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by datalus on Monday July 16, 2012 @10:31PM (#4253798)
Running Arch Linux on a Raspberry Pi, it's pretty awesome as a next step distro beyond Ubuntu, but yeah... as an accessible platform for gamers of all kinds, ah no :)
Re:Steam'd Penguins by mitchty on Monday July 16, 2012 @10:28PM (#4253792)
I'll admit, i'm biased. >.<

But having installed Linux back in 1997 and dealing with X11Rwhatever it was back then and minicom and all that jazz, kinda makes my view of hard a bit off of what most people view as hard.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by wickedchicken on Monday July 16, 2012 @10:50PM (#4253844)
The problem I ran into with Arch was that it forced you to make many decisions about your system up-front, before you had a system to begin with. I even found Gentoo easier to set up, and Gentoo forced me to pick which version of cron I wanted to install.

One nice thing about Arch though is the ArchWiki: it has copious amounts of documentation on software that is usually applicable to other distros. A good example is https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Awesome

Re:Steam'd Penguins by trotsky on Monday July 16, 2012 @09:55PM (#4253712)
looks like it was a good thing i hedged ;)
Re:Steam'd Penguins by biomechanica on Monday July 16, 2012 @09:17PM (#4253622)
I think it has to do with their familiarity with Ubuntu server and the popularity of the distro.

They wrote on that post that they do indeed want to support other distro's in the future. I suspect they just want to get some stability before committing to a wide range of distro's. Ubuntu is very popular, so it makes sense.

Distro's can take the .deb files and extract them through their package managers to fit their systems, probably without much hassle.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by ekianjo on Monday July 16, 2012 @11:20PM (#4253916)
If it works for Ubuntu it will work for Mint. Mint is 100% compatible with Ubuntu, you can even install the Ubuntu software center in Mint.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by mtgx on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @03:04AM (#4254530)
I hope so, because I like Mint a lot more than regular Ubuntu.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by grakic on Monday July 16, 2012 @09:18PM (#4253625)
I expect it will eventually work on any recent distribution, and there would be community docs everywhere on how to install dependencies, configure and run their software on distribution X.

Saying that, Ubuntu is popular, there may be some commercial connections with Canonical, and picking one distribution to do the testing should streamline their efforts.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by fl3tch on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @12:25AM (#4254088)
Debian has the Debian Free Software Guidelines and the community as whole is less supportive of proprietary software, not to mention that it's all volunteers. I think Valve would rather work with a company-supported distro like Ubuntu, which focuses on just working.

In any case, the client may very well run on Debian, it just won't be officially tested or certified by Valve (for now).

Re:Steam'd Penguins by mbell on Monday July 16, 2012 @09:23PM (#4253636)
Simple answer is that most of the differentiation between Ubunu and Debian is in the areas of audio and video. Specifically regarding drivers, which is a critically important component of game development.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by Longlius on Monday July 16, 2012 @11:14PM (#4253897)
The Linux Standard Base keeps most of the system structure and ABI consistent across distributions, which means that binaries are trivial to move among them.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by sandGorgon on Monday July 16, 2012 @10:34PM (#4253805)
This is why I think they just miscalculated. They still dont know the religious wars of Fedora vs Ubuntu, or rpm vs deb.

I was seriously hoping for a Valve distro, which would be perfectly tuned for all things media (they hired the SDL guy). Maybe have Steam as the package manager for everything.

Instead, they just joined a camp - this is not good.

The other way they could have approached it was to support Android - not as a playing system, but rather as a console device connected to peripherals - and sponsored some project to run Android apk on Linux with access to the sound and graphics layer (SDL?? )

Re:Steam'd Penguins by cageface on Monday July 16, 2012 @11:24PM (#4253924)
Instead, they just joined a camp - this is not good.

This is exactly what they should be doing, not further fragmenting an already gratuitously fragmented market.

Every time some commercial vendor makes a move into Linux and people start bickering about distros I just /facepalm.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by sandGorgon on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @01:59AM (#4254320)
actually I am indeed talking about the "bickering" that is going to start. I use Ubuntu myself and am most definitely not bickering about Fedora.

However, the Linux market is already fragmented. And even worse, it is deeply religious. Just google for the bickering that ensued when Meego chose rpm over deb. People have already started talking about why not Arch, etc.

The point that you are missing is that, if anyone could unify the Linux fragmentation it is Valve. Steam is a killer app, and I can totally see people migrating towards a distro built around it (and laptops certified for it).

I want Valve to succeed - how will it succeed in a severely fragmented market ? Can it justify the cost of its Linux team then ? Android is having a similar problems in version fragmentation. People have posted articles here on how they are unable to justify multiple version (distro?) development. Multiply that problem by a thousand - different audio toolkits, poor driver compatibilities. I am not able to see how they are going to succeed, unless they unify atleast the multimedia toolkits (something like CoreAudio)

Re:Steam'd Penguins by cageface on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @03:22AM (#4254587)
Steam is a killer app, and I can totally see people migrating towards a distro built around it (and laptops certified for it).

http://xkcd.com/927/

Anybody willing to switch distros just to run a game might as well just install a Windows partition.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by jlgreco on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @03:42AM (#4254657)
Eh, switching from Fedora to Ubuntu would not be a big deal at all. The differences really are quite minimal and the actual install would take what, half an hour tops? The effort to install a windows partition would be much higher.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by jiggy2011 on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:00AM (#4254713)
I think they are responding to the suggestion that Valve releases their own distro.

Would certainly take me significantly more than half an hour to switch to Fedora though since I would need to re-learn the package manager, move all my settings across and figure out the subtle differences in configuration etc.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by fingerprinter on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @05:48AM (#4254964)
Valve releasing their own distro would be just craaaaaazy. That would be like Amazon or Google doing it. Why bother? There is an awesome one out there for free (Ubuntu).

If Valve wants to make their own console, which is the more likely case, they can license Ubuntu support for cheaper than they could make a terrible distro and it would be win-win-win (which is, of course, better than a win-win scenario).

Re:Steam'd Penguins by sandGorgon on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @07:05AM (#4255169)
Amazon or Google is doing it - ChromeOS, Android, Amazon's fork of Android....
Re:Steam'd Penguins by jlgreco on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:14AM (#4254753)
If you keep a seperate /home the process is greatly streamlined. I've had the same one through countless ubuntu , gentoo, and fedora installs. Just have to swap out your / and recreate your user.

The only real differences in package management for I'd say 95% of use cases is if you type 'yum' or 'apt-get' before typing 'install whatever'.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by hef19898 on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @04:23AM (#4254776)
From a gamers perspective, Win/ is great but if Win( comes with all that mobile UI stuff Linux (I don't care about which version exactly) will have quite a chance. Given decent drivers for the hardware and being open but not having to much over head will exactly be what a lot of gamers want, it will be running games.

If someone comes up with a upgradeable open pc-based console of sort running steam, well THIS could be the final nail in the traditional PCs coffin. Actually loving playing games on a desktop I hope that doesn't happen any time soon!

Re:Steam'd Penguins by jiggy2011 on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @03:40AM (#4254646)
Very true, this reminds me of the failed Corel Linux years back.

If the attitude towards fragmentation is to fork a new distro for every application, am I supposed to restart my computer every time I want to task switch or run hundreds of virtual machines?

There are some specialised situations where a custom distro makes sense, like appliance type applications (smoothwall, backtrack etc)

Re:Steam'd Penguins by ElliotH on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @02:19AM (#4254386)
I'm not sure this is the issue you think it is.

Games in the Humble Indie Bundle releases have Linux builds. (.tar.gz or .bin) I haven't had major issues beyond installing the libraries that I get prompted are missing. That could get automated, especially now PackageKit abstracts away from the details of different package management utilities.

Also, you could cover a huge portion of the linux market by just supporting Ubuntu and Fedora. Other distros (e.g Arch) have a community that has some experience in repackaging these for their distro.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by jiggy2011 on Tuesday July 17, 2012 @03:27AM (#4254618)
I don't think they'd really reduce fragmentation by creating yet anther distro.

They could probably solve a lot of issues with fragmentation by establishing steam in a chrooted environment on the system so that it could maintain it's own versions of certain libraries etc. This could then be targeted by developers as opposed to targeting a specific distro. In essence, a "distro within a distro".

Re:Steam'd Penguins by drivebyacct2 on Monday July 16, 2012 @11:33PM (#4253951)
No kidding. How ungrateful is this reaction (and I'm not normally one to grate-guilt)? If it works in Ubuntu, it will probably work just fine on other Linux variants, but Ubuntu is the primary support scenario.

And why would a new distro make sense? Now you can have gaming if you just install ~~Windows~~ ValveLinux.

Re:Steam'd Penguins by ekianjo on Monday July 16, 2012 @11:23PM (#4253921)
They clearly mentioned in their post they would support other distributions if STeam on Ubuntu is successful. They are not choosing sides, simply starting with the largest distribution. Which makes sense.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by gcr on Monday July 16, 2012 @10:42PM (#4253824)
Porting between Ubuntu and Fedora, or even Ubuntu and Android once you have a native Ubuntu build is far easier than porting from Windows to Ubuntu.
Re:Steam'd Penguins by jiggy2011 on Monday July 16, 2012 @11:54PM (#4254003)
I'm glad they are not making their own distro. If I wanted to run a "gaming OS" I'd use Windows or buy an Xbox.

Where they could provide value though is to create a stable platform cross distro that is well supported for game/app developers. Anything that allows porting to Linux without worrying about distro fragmentation is a good thing.

Besides when it comes to more esoteric distros I'm sure they will be able to tap into the community to help bring it there.