Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing...
by viraptor on Saturday December 28, 2024 @07:57AM
(#42530749)
Rules don't get changed due to people quietly saying "I don't like this rule" while staying at home. Public rebellion is what gets the job done. Protests that don't inconvenience anyone are irrelevant.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing...
by Aachen on Saturday December 28, 2024 @08:19AM
(#42530846)
Would it have been quiet if the defending champion decides to stay at home and when someone asks him he says it's because of a disagreement about the event's rules? Wouldn't that have gone around and raised the issue/discussion?
I'm still undecided who's right here or who should have done what: I'm not for stupid dress codes, but it also seems silly to get hung up over if you can easily comply at no detriment to your performance or anything, so idk, just saying that it does seem like an option to stay home if you disagree when you're someone whose absence would be very conspicuous
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing...
by cwillu on Saturday December 28, 2024 @08:37AM
(#42530963)
We wouldn't be talking about it here, and I suggest that the same is true across many other forums that aren't specifically focused on chess.
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing...
by vouaobrasil on Saturday December 28, 2024 @12:27PM
(#42532601)
That is true, I won't argue there.
Re:Chess: Magnus Carlsen disqualified in N.Y. after refusing...
by simplicio on Saturday December 28, 2024 @07:23PM
(#42536194)
I mean...I feel like lots of rules are changed by people just saying they don't like the rule? Modern society would be pretty unworkable if the only way to change any rule was public rebellion.
(Plus, its not really clear to me that Carlson actually cares about the dress code rule? By his own admission, he broke it by accident, not like a concious act of rebellion, and his issue seems to have been with the way it was then enforced rather then the rule itself.)