News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why OpenAI's Structure Must Evolve to Advance Our Mission by franga2000 on Friday December 27, 2024 @10:35AM (#42522951)
Is it illegal? If it is, not amount of explaining will make it legal.
Re:Why OpenAI's Structure Must Evolve to Advance Our Mission by mikeyouse on Friday December 27, 2024 @11:04AM (#42523271)
That's not really true and is at the heart of much of the 'confusion' about e.g. tax evasion vs. tax avoidance. You can do illegal things if you don't get prosecuted for them and a lot of this type of legal wrangling is to give your lawyers and political allies enough grey area to grab onto to shout about selective prosecution when you're called out for it.
Re:Why OpenAI's Structure Must Evolve to Advance Our Mission by Drew_ on Friday December 27, 2024 @12:46PM (#42524265)
I don't see how that's relevant. In what case is the difference between tax evasion and avoidance just the motive/explanation? I'm pretty sure the difference is purely technical.

Moreover, I don't think a lack of prosecution/enforcement makes something legal. At least, I don't think that defense would hold up very well in court.

Re:Why OpenAI's Structure Must Evolve to Advance Our Mission by mikeyouse on Friday December 27, 2024 @03:20PM (#42525668)
> I'm pretty sure the difference is purely technical.

It's really not - there is a ton of tax law that relies on e.g. the fair market value of hard-to-price assets or if all else fails and a penalty is due, there's an entire section of the CFR on how circumstances surrounding the underpayment can reduce or eliminate the liability.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.6664-4

If you've only ever filed a personal tax return, you're dramatically under-appreciating how complicated business taxes are and how much grey area there really is. Did you know you can pay your 10-year old to work for you as a means to avoid taxes? Try looking up the dollar amount where avoid turns to evade... there isn't one. The amount paid just has to be "reasonable and justifiable" and the work they perform has to be "work necessary to the business".

Re:Why OpenAI's Structure Must Evolve to Advance Our Mission by Drew_ on Saturday December 28, 2024 @08:27PM (#42536559)
Waiving penalties depending on the circumstance is interesting but not directly relevant to the question on hand. You would have already been found to have evaded taxes before the penalty could be assessed. So the circumstance/motivation/explanation is still not the differentiator between avoidance and evasion in this case - just the penalty.
Re:Why OpenAI's Structure Must Evolve to Advance Our Mission by mikeyouse on Wednesday January 01, 2025 @09:32PM (#42571097)
If tax law were black and white / “purely technical” they wouldn’t make accommodation to reduce your penalties if you made good faith errors when filing was my only point.
Re:Why OpenAI's Structure Must Evolve to Advance Our Mission by moron4hire on Friday December 27, 2024 @10:40AM (#42523028)
When the consequence is paying a fine/settlement, it means the law is only for poor people.
Re:Why OpenAI's Structure Must Evolve to Advance Our Mission by jefftk on Friday December 27, 2024 @01:37PM (#42524714)
There are solidly legal and solidly illegal ways to do this, and a range of options in between. My reading of what they are doing is that it is pretty far toward the legal end of this spectrum, and the key question will be whether whether the non-profit is appropriately compensated for its stake in the for-profit.

Explaining reduces the chance that they're challenged by the IRS or attorney general, since that is a political process.