News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @05:28PM (#42446095)
It somehow works almost anywhere outside of NA? It's really not a crazy concept - estimate it based on geolocation and say "more exact will be available once you enter your address". The problem is, that genuinely negatively affect the sales because people see the true price of things.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by HelloMcFly on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @05:43PM (#42446253)
> estimate it based on geolocation and say "more exact will be available once you enter your address".

I appreciate this can be done and countries in Europe do it, I just don't see how this is any better at all than status quo:

* Current State: we all know the quoted price doesn't include sales tax, which will be added to make the final price in checkout after we enter our address.

* Final State: we all know the quoted price will likely change during checkout, when we see the final price after we enter our address.

So we make things more complicated for vendors, and we make it not just acceptable but required that vendors use our IP addresses for geolocation, only to give us a maybe-right-maybe-wrong final price. Does anyone feel scammed by not having tax included on the price in the listings of Macy's online store?

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @06:27PM (#42446560)
The only reason why status quo is there because people are less likely to remove items from their online shopping carts once they've added it. There are techniques and shopping check out flows that have been perfected over the years to drive up the online sales. Realistically, it won't move the needle for the people who are on this forum because of the average salary (a few dollars are usually not a big deal for us), but it can be a make it or break it choice for a good chunk of customers.

I'm not sure why one wouldn't want to know the real price before the checkout. It's a bit baffling to me. It could be a cultural thing as well, then I guess, there isn't really a right or wrong way of looking at it.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @07:54PM (#42447124)
> The only reason why status quo is there because people are less likely to remove items from their online shopping carts once they've added it.

Sure, in a world where the actual sticker price is displayed. Do you believe this will remain true when customers have to add items to the cart to get the “real” price?

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @09:16PM (#42447539)
That's literally how it works everywhere else...? For example, when I go to amazon.jp, even without logging in, it will show you tax included prices once you enter your postal code.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @04:37AM (#42449183)
Ok I see what you mean now. On an ecommerce site this works but I don't see how it can be done in advertising.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by crazygringo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @09:00PM (#42447457)
> I'm not sure why one wouldn't want to know the real price before the checkout. It's a bit baffling to me.

It's just that, in the list of things I'd like fixed about the world, that's about dead last.

When you're used to sales tax being added at the register, it's not an inconvenience. Who cares.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @09:20PM (#42447549)
Fair, I guess it's a cultural thing then. I absolutely have no idea what other municipality's taxes are the second I get out of mine. I wouldn't want to randomly predict whether it's 10, 12, or 15%.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by HelloMcFly on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @05:58PM (#42456448)
> I'm not sure why one wouldn't want to know the real price before the checkout.

Because you'd never actually know if it's the final real price or not until you entered your address! That's the entire premise of my objection, was that not clear?

If we want to talk about displaying final price for my confirmed shipping address then yeah, I'm all in for that.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by websap on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @05:36PM (#42446182)
I've been working at FAANG for the past 10 years, so this made me absolutely chuckle!

I can totally image a PM somewhere calculate the negative bps for this and call the experiment a failure!

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @06:04PM (#42446402)
Yeah, I totally get you! I've done exactly this work for semi-B2B company where it clearly showed the sticker price effect and we ended up removing the taxes from it. Unless it's legislated, it's obvious the way the companies will go.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by blitzar on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @06:11PM (#42446453)
Apparently they can track you to the nearest 5m 24 hours a day, figure out that your teenage daughter is pregnant and replicate your likeness and voice perfectly - but when it comes to sales tax its an intractable problem.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @07:18PM (#42446892)
I believe you are referencing the famous Target case. As I understand the dad was angry that Target was sending baby-related coupons to his teenage daughter.

Finding out your teenage daughter is pregnant based on her shopping is easy. It’s actually harder not to notice. “Customers like you also bought” is an effective algorithm because people are mostly the same. Pregnancy has some very specific and unique needs which create a strong signal.

Nobody is in a shady back room poring over chat logs and GPS coordinates looking for pregnant teenagers. It just falls out of the sysem.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by ewoodrich on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @06:43PM (#42446679)
That's a non-sequitur unless the question being considered is specifically whether a data hoarder like Google should build in estimated sales tax in their store vs "a random shopping cart from a retailer I've never interacted with before".
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @05:32PM (#42446147)
> It somehow works almost anywhere outside of NA?

Is North America unique in allowing local municipalities to set their own taxes?

> It's really not a crazy concept - estimate it based on geolocation and say "more exact will be available once you enter your address".

That’s exactly what happens now, except the advertised price is actually correct instead of an “estimate”. I have an intuitive sense for local tax. How can I know what method was used to compute this estimated price?

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @06:02PM (#42446388)
Out of my head, if I recall correctly, Australia, Japan, Denmark do local municipal taxes as well (some are more flat than others).

Anyways, all I was saying that it's a solved UX problem, and the reason why you're not getting full price is because A/B testing has shown that when customers see the complete price, they get a shock and less likely to buy the item. This doesn't have much to do with websites caring about some edge cases that they'll somehow won't be able to give out exact price to you. In the worst case, the shopping websites could ask you to enter your postal code and show all prices with the tax included price.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @06:04PM (#42446405)
So are estimated prices being advertised in Australia, Japan, or Denmark? Why is North America uniquely susceptible to A/B testing?

Municipal taxes are not an edgecase in the United States at least. They’re very much the norm, especially in telecommunications.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @06:31PM (#42446587)
Because according to Japanese law, in most of the scenarios, the full price, to your best ability, has to be presented to the potential customer. Same goes for Australia, if I recall correctly. No clue about Denmark, I'm sorry. But assuming it's similar over there as well.

It's not that NA is the only one susceptible to A/B testing. It's more of a - it's-grey-area-to-illegal to not show full prices outside of NA.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @06:34PM (#42446612)
Huh, I find that very surprising. Are the estimates gamed at all? Is there any rule around how accurate they have to be?
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @07:02PM (#42446805)
You just put your postal code and it shows all prices according to your municipality, it will be as exact as you can get. Just go to amazon.jp, it should have a text input somewhere for your postal code to calculate the tax.

In terms of gaming, hmm… I guess, you could add wrong municipality’s taxes when you show the original price, and switch over at the checkout. But my assumption is that would be deemed illegal, as you are knowingly misleading the customer. Some in person stores still try a bit to mislead you by putting the full price in smaller font (like including the consumption tax), and exclude it over it in the bigger font. But I can still accept that, as I am informed about the full price somehow.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @07:42PM (#42447049)
Ok well obviously if you have the address the correct calculation can be made. That’s consistent with the behavior in the US.

What is displayed for price before you put in postal code? What price do generic banner or TV ads display?

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @09:32PM (#42447613)
My guess is approximate (average?) tax. I'm currently outside of Japan, by default Amazon shows me the price in Yen and says it can't deliver to me. When I put down the postal code in Tokyo, shows the same amount. Probably takes the biggest city's tax rate when it can't determine it through geolocation.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @09:55PM (#42447720)
What about billboards or banner ads? When an ISP in Japan wants to advertise their service do they include a price on the billboard?

What you describe sounds like the same thing that happens in the US. So what's special about Australia, Japan, and Denmark as you stated earlier?

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @01:31AM (#42448523)
Why wouldn’t they? Major ones are electronic, and you know the areas you are putting up your ads in, so you include the tax in it. You go to the store, sales tax either included in the price, or written in smaller font with the tax included price.

It actually happens in NA for specific industries as well! If you buy a flight from Google flights without making any additional purchases, you will get the sticker price because airfare display is regulated to a certain degree. Except in Japan and other countries, almost all display prices have to include local taxes. It’s a solved problem, but there’s no political appetite for it in US/Canada because it will hurt the sales.

Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by mulmen on Wednesday December 18, 2024 @04:31AM (#42449165)
Not sure how telco taxes work in Japan but it would be impossible to advertise an accurate tax-included price in my city because not all the residents of the metro area have the same tax structure. Zip code isn't enough. The full address is required. So TV and print advertisements are pre-tax. I don't see how it could work any other way.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by throwaway2037 on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @08:24PM (#42447281)

    > Because according to Japanese law, in most of the scenarios, the full price, to your best ability, has to be presented to the potential customer.
Are you sure? When I shop in Japan, it seems like about 50/50 where they have sales tax included, or not. However, the price tag will be clear if the price includes sales tax or not.
Re:FTC bans hidden junk fees in hotel, event ticket prices by tokioyoyo on Tuesday December 17, 2024 @09:29PM (#42447592)
Yes. Source: https://www.nta.go.jp/taxes/shiraberu/taxanswer/shohi/6902.h...

I agree, there are a lot of cases where they don't show the full prices. Especially in the recent years when they've been changing the consumption tax rapidly, and allowing shops to have some leeway. But online prices, almost everywhere, include tax. Even Shopify forces JP merchants to display them while selling in the area.