News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge Refuses to Allow Sale of Infowars to The Onion by dang on Saturday December 14, 2024 @07:15PM (#42420459)
I feel like we're hitting a point where we'd have to clarify what we mean by some of these phrases or risk talking past each other, and that's too hard to do in this context. (For example I think we probably mean something different by "ideological commitment".) I'd like to add a few things though—and of course you're also welcome to do that if you want.

One thing is, I personally wouldn't put the HN concept of "optimizing for intellectual curiosity" anywhere near the phrase "free marketplace of ideas". The word "marketplace" has many associations, some of which are inimical to what we want here. Ditto for "free". Neither word belongs to, let's call it, the domain language of HN moderation (and I could even say bad things about "ideas").

For me, "optimizing for intellectual curiosity" has to do with (1) learning from each other (which implies community, and a marketplace is not a community); and above all, (2) avoiding tedious repetition. The problem with political and ideological battle (on HN) is that it falls on the undesirable side of both lines: its endless hammering of talking points is as repetitive as discourse can get; and its register of high indignation is as destructive to openness and curiosity as one can get. If this is a 2x2 matrix, that's the bad-bad quadrant.

Another thing is, this community has lots of transgender members, they're as welcome as anyone, and some who I know of make some of the best contributions to the site. We don't tolerate slurs or abuse, and warn and/or ban accounts that post those. The community also does a good job of flagging them. Some stick around for a while, but people are welcome to (and do) email [email protected] when they see them, and we always follow up. The topic, of course, is fraught on HN, just as it is fraught in society at large, and people inevitably have conflicting ideas about what constitutes a slur or an abuse. But I don't believe the site is as bad as you say it is on this front; if it is, then there are a lot of posts going unflagged and unmoderated that I'm unaware of.

Last thing is, what does 'misinformation' mean if not 'falsehood'? But if you're asking mods to decide what's true vs. what's false and impose those decisions on the community—that strikes me as absurd. How on earth would we do that? We don't have a truth meter*. Of course we all have our views about what's true vs. what's false, but I'm not so hubristic as to imagine that mine are the correct ones and wield power accordingly. That is the worst quality I can imagine in a moderator, and the thjing the community would hate the most. (I'm also not so hubristic as to imagine that I don't do that, unintentionally or unconsciously—the most I can say is that I've spent 10 years trying to get better at not doing it, and practice does change one.)

Of course eager ideologues of every flavour would happily say "you don't have a misinformation meter? that's ok - use mine!" But the power to decide and enforce what counts as misinformation is literally the power to decide what's true and control the site. But now I'm repeating what I said at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42418981 and we're in a cycle...

Moderation, at least as I understand it, simply can't work on those principles. It needs principles on a different level that can foster community and the kind of discussion that has a good chance of remaining curious. That doesn't mean I'm reducing this to relativism and I suspect if we were to look at a list of borderline posts together, we'd end up agreeing about most of them. I don't want culture war talking points, for example, or just-asking-questions baiting, any more than it sounds like you do.

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38787789, https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

There are no comments on this comment yet.