News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by ks2048 on Friday December 13, 2024 @09:02PM (#42414050)
When I wonder about the business behind Meta doing this, I see they have $70B in cash, so giving a bunch of AI experts hundreds of millions is pocket change.
Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by wrsh07 on Friday December 13, 2024 @10:40PM (#42414501)
Imagine that something fundamental shifts in the world of AI research. It could be anything: AI suddenly makes programmers much more productive, AI becomes very good at identifying vulnerabilities, AI chat becomes a new major source of entertainment, AI images become an item popularly shared on Instagram (etc)

Suppose any one of these things happened and suddenly Facebook wished that it had access to state of the art models so that it could customize them for its uses (internal developers or tools, embedding in their app).

Imagine how they would feel if the only way they could access these models were by signing 7-9 figure deals with a model dealer like OpenAI. Even worse, imagine if one of their main competitors in advertising started providing robust AI tools to help advertisers adapt their creatives to various form factors. Facebook is now way behind and possibly has to shell out millions to a company like OpenAI all while also losing ad market share worth billions per quarter (ads on Google start performing much better, so Google gets more ad spend)

If this worst case scenario came to pass, Facebook would look foolish. If even one of these things were likely their investments make sense. The rest (open source, make meta a cool place to work) are a strategy credit.

Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by aoanevdus on Friday December 13, 2024 @09:10PM (#42414086)
“Commoditize you complement” may be a good way of framing it. Consider that if OpenAI succeeds dramatically and is the only game in town, they could extract huge rents for anyone using their service. So it’s in other companies interests (or anyone who wants to use AI) that the AI ecosystem have lots of competition to keep prices low.
Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by cma on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:07AM (#42415446)
You can't have enough top researchers without letting them publish.
Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by almostgotcaught on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:43AM (#42415599)
everyone that has responded so far has it wrong (naively so).

FB sells ad space on several apps. those apps needs people on them in order for the ad space to be worth anything. people, in turn, need content to attract them to the apps. so it's simple: enable people/companies/whomever to generate tons of content for cheap and consequently share it on the apps. that's it.

Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by SideQuark on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:47AM (#42417106)
Except giving out the tools makes easier for competitors like TikTok to do the same, drawing revenue away from meta.

So that’s not it. Naively so.

Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by tzs on Saturday December 14, 2024 @11:16AM (#42417927)
Couldn't the same argument be made for all kinds of things companies have made open? Some examples:

• Tesla gave away its EV patents.

• Pixar and DreamWorks have both open-sourced some of their tools, including tools used to make some of their best works. For example DreamWorks' MoonRay renderer has been used on everything they have done since "How to Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World", including "Puss in Boots: The Last Wish" and "The Wild Robot", and will be used on their upcoming films.

• Facebook open-sourced React.

• Google open-sourced Chromium.

Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by bee_rider on Saturday December 14, 2024 @12:06PM (#42418192)
In the case of Tesla, if you want to sell cars, you benefit from open up your charging tech, right?
Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by SideQuark on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:45PM (#42421108)
Yes, it can. But my reply is to the person I directly responded to that claimed these tools are for meta product benefit, but ignored that same argument applies to competitors.

A better answer is meta releases them for some combination of they see it benefitting the business and/or a desire to provide broad benefits to everyone. They certainly expend tremendous resources to create these models. No other company has provided this much value to such a large base of users in this space.

Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by mttddd on Saturday December 14, 2024 @12:49PM (#42418412)
the tools but not necessarily the data, presumably they have internally trained versions
Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by almostgotcaught on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:51PM (#42419347)
this is like saying that AMD making chips that intel/nvidia employees can buy and use to do their jobs is a bad strategy for AMD. lol. ok not every single strategic choice needs to both grow the top line and be anti-competitive. some can just grow the top line.
Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by mttddd on Saturday December 14, 2024 @12:50PM (#42418419)
content but also better ad targetting by better understanding all of the content that users post
Re:New Meta FAIR Research and Models by sangnoir on Saturday December 14, 2024 @03:50AM (#42415619)
Those AI experts are a played a critical role in Meta getting that $70B in the first place