News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by treetalker on Friday December 13, 2024 @02:33PM (#42411585)
I'm skeptical of claims like this. How do the claimants define reading? If we mean extracting a subset of information from a particular, arbitrarily defined block of text, well then I can read tens or hundreds of thousands of words per minute: I know how to pick up a typical business paperback, flip to the last chapter (or even just the conclusion), and skim for the 1–3 big ideas.

But try to read a text like a complex SCOTUS majority opinion, or one of the Great Books, at anything close to that speed — good luck! Even trained and very experienced appellate attorneys can study such texts for hours, days, weeks, and still find important intricacies that require not just perception, but ingestion and digestion.

As an exercise, one might grab any text and have one's computer read it aloud at 900 WPM. If one were to glean a single sentence, let alone the important bits, let alone all of it, I'd be shocked.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by kouru225 on Friday December 13, 2024 @04:11PM (#42412383)
Agreed. Like I can probably read these comments at 900 wpm if I wanted but if you put Kant in front of me I’m reading at like 10 wpm.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by jdougan on Friday December 13, 2024 @05:24PM (#42412898)
Kant at 10 wpm?! Look at the speed reader!
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by btilly on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:33PM (#42413888)
No, that's the speed I'd read Kant.

Mind you, I don't agree with a lot of Kant. But that's another story.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by minihat on Friday December 13, 2024 @03:16PM (#42411962)
Reading speed might follow a normal distribution near the middle ranges, but I'd expect non-trivial deviations in the tails due to dyslexia, ADHD on the one side and trained speed readers on the other. Perhaps this individual just falls on the far tail of that distribution?

During my graduate coursework I sometimes read 100-200 pages of technical material in a day while cramming for an exam, and was able to retain it for a day or two. I'd believe it if some people exist who could comprehend and retain all of that long-term. Alas, 'tis not I.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by PaulHoule on Friday December 13, 2024 @03:51PM (#42412224)
I think Dyslexia has a lot of politics attached.

If 25% of people have it then, practically, Dyslexia means you are in the bottom 25% of readers, as much as the Dyslexia industrial complex wants to see it as taxonic and not dimensional. (Sure they say it has two subtypes and sure, maybe there are two reasons that make most bad readers bad readers, there are probably more reasons that are more obscure and too hard to pin down)

Personally I think there are a lot of white collar people who are devastated to have a child who is a poor reader who won't follow in their footsteps (college professors, journalists, people in ethic groups where people will think you're a loser if you're a cop or pro football player, etc.) Labeling it as a disease makes it easier for people in that situation to live with it.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by tshaddox on Friday December 13, 2024 @05:18PM (#42412859)
> Personally I think there are a lot of white collar people who are devastated to have a child who is a poor reader who won't follow in their footsteps (college professors, journalists, people in ethic groups where people will think you're a loser if you're a cop or pro football player, etc.) Labeling it as a disease makes it easier for people in that situation to live with it.

Isn't this just how all diseases and indeed all things work? We're the ones who come up with these simple categorizations and labels to describe reality which is vastly more complex. The terms are necessarily underspecified and the boundaries between categories are necessarily fuzzy. This is true even within some medical community that attempts to have more precise definitions of "disease"/"disorder"/"disability"/etc. and it's all the more true for colloquial usage of these terms. But yes, these terms do end up just meaning "any condition that is not normal that causes problems for the person experiencing it."

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by PaulHoule on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:20PM (#42413830)
I think "flu", "cancer" and "aortic aneurysm" are well defined concepts.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by btilly on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:36PM (#42413908)
Trained speed readers trade off speed and comprehension. I've never heard of any of them doing what I do.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by TrainedMonkey on Friday December 13, 2024 @03:06PM (#42411856)
Anecdatally, I have two reading modes - full comprehension and skimming. In full comprehension I read and subvocalize each word, often slowing down, pausing, or even re-reading to make sure the meaning sinks in. In skim mode I look at phrases, sometimes whole sentences or even simple paragraphs, and move to the next chunk before consciously comprehending the previous one. Skimming effectiveness highly depends on my alertness level and works best with fiction or other media with low information density. For fiction books I can generally recount the plot and events pretty well.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by RajT88 on Friday December 13, 2024 @10:55PM (#42414557)
I have skim mode as well. I could not put a number to it, but I pick up the gist and leave behind some detail.

It is how I got through those middle Wheel of Time books.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by noman-land on Friday December 13, 2024 @11:19PM (#42414656)
What benefits do you gain from skimming a fiction book?
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by TrainedMonkey on Sunday December 15, 2024 @02:21PM (#42425349)
Mostly find out what happens next faster. But on some level something about it is meditative. A constant progress across the book understanding what you can and letting everything else go. From pragmatic angle it is acquiring new information at a comfortable rate without stressful backtracking.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by nottorp on Friday December 13, 2024 @03:13PM (#42411921)
I'd say you only read to assimilate info and not for entertainment then.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by btilly on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:37PM (#42413913)
I did a lot of reading for entertainment. Particularly light sci-fi and fantasy.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by lproven on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:37AM (#42417050)
Me too. Most of it in fact.

But not only.

Back in January, Dave Mills died. I told my boss I'd not heard of him so I didn't think an obit was called for.

The mourning on HN over the weekend persuaded me otherwise.

So, on Monday morning, I read everything I could find about him -- I estimate at least 2000 pages worth and maybe twice that -- and then I wrote this:

https://www.theregister.com/2024/01/23/david_mills_obit/

It gave me a bit of a headache but I can still tear through large amounts of text, retain the info, summarise it, and then if I don't want or need it let it go.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by bitwize on Friday December 13, 2024 @04:00PM (#42412310)
I've been doing some anti-ADHD training on my own by reading a difficult book -- The Left Hand of Darkness by Ursula K. LeGuin -- slowly.

Sure I could bro down those words in a straight beginning-to-end readthrough and get a sense of what's going on. But I find that going back over the past few paragraphs is rewarding, as subtle turns of phrase reveal details I hadn't noticed.

You could probably be trained to comprehend text electronically read to you at 900 wpm. Blind people using screenreaders, for instance, train themselves to understand text read aloud very fast.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by pdfernhout on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:44PM (#42413379)
You might find amusing the RA Lafferty short-story "The Primary Education of the Camiroi" (1966).

Summary: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9AXNLUFeplI "A PTA delegation from Earth visit another planet to investigate their educational methods in order to figure out how to improve the school system back home on Earth. But the lessons learned, and the conclusions drawn, are rather… odd and disturbing."

From the story: https://uncabob.blogspot.com/2015/05/the-primary-education-o...

“How rapidly do you read?” Miss Hanks asked a young girl.

“One hundred and twenty words a minute,” the girl said.

“On Earth some of the girl students your age have learned to read at the rate of five hundred words a minute,” Miss Hanks said proudly.

“When I began disciplined reading, I was reading at the rate of four thousands words a minute,” the girl said. “They had quite a time correcting me of it. I had to take remedial reading, and my parents were ashamed of me. Now I’ve learned to read almost slow enough.”

“I don’t understand,” said Miss Hanks.

...

“What is this business about slow reading?” Miss Hanks asked. “I don’t understand it at all.”

“Only the other day there was a child in the third grade who persisted in rapid reading.” Philoxenus said. “He was given an object lesson. He was given a book of medium difficulty, and he read it rapidly. Then he had to put the book away and repeat what he had read. Do you know that in the first thirty pages he missed four words? Midway in the book there was a whole statement which he had understood wrongly, and there were hundreds of pages that he got word-perfect only with difficulty. If he was so unsure on material that he had just read, think how imperfectly he would have recalled it forty years later.”

“You mean that the Camiroi children learn to recall everything that they read?”

“The Camiroi children and adults will recall for life every detail they have ever seen, read or heard. We on Camiroi are only a little more intelligent than you on Earth. We cannot afford to waste time in forgetting or reviewing, or in pursuing anything of a shallowness that lends itself to scanning.”

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by dxbydt on Saturday December 14, 2024 @12:05PM (#42418188)
Amazing story. I enjoyed reading this so much. The sad fact that this was written in 1966 - like the gentleman advocated for gutting the public school system 6 decades ago, and only now we are getting around to the business of defunding the dept of education. The story has foretold everything - the culture wars, the sacred cow/buffalo, utterly divergent visions of the left and right when it comes to what education means…Rafferty seems to be a futuristic mind reader. Amazing.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by btilly on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:39PM (#42413924)
You aren't finding it annoying?

She goes to great lengths to show how non-sexist the society is according to then feminist theory. Then, just accidentally, slips in gender divides that should not exist in her society.

Given that I had just read some of that feminist literature, I found it quite jarring.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by bitwize on Friday December 13, 2024 @09:05PM (#42414060)
Guess I'm not far along to have reached the bit with the gender divides, yet. What I have read seemed to reflect a rather 2020s-feminist view of gender, in a time when feminism was still in its bra-burning arc. So that was interesting.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by btilly on Friday December 13, 2024 @11:01PM (#42414577)
If you think of it as a bra burning arc, you won't get the historical context.

The most jarring for me was some of the childhood scenes.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by lproven on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:39AM (#42417058)
> a difficult book -- The Left Hand of Darkness

Difficult?! That's a favourite novel of mine. I've read it 3 or 4 times. What is difficult about it? It's short, as well as beautiful. Only 250 pages.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by ACow_Adonis on Friday December 13, 2024 @03:32PM (#42412091)
I'm another "speed reader" skeptic. After significant repeated investigations I came to a stunning conclusion: I'm among some of the fastest actual human readers. My general reading speed 300 to 600 wpm depending on context and medium. For context I was your usual bookworm growing up: reading ahead of level, constantly reading everywhere, always reading while walking, always getting in trouble for reading with other people present like at the breakfast/dinner table, just churning through books non stop. And yes I now read random scientific articles and things for fun.

Anything above that reading speed I've started just allocating to bullshitters, or generally techniques which come back to "not reading" rather than "reading".

That is to say people who choose techniques to try to speed themselves up through strategies like "skimming" (that is to say, not reading parts of the text to try to game metrics) or "extracting key points" (that is to say not reading parts of the text to try to game metrics) or their comprehension drops beyond 100% (that is to say not reading to try to game metrics).

And that's assuming you're not just dealing with the actual frauds trying to talk themselves up in a penis-measuring contest or sell something.

So yeah, I'm in the anything above 400-600 wpm is in the bullshitters club. And technical or difficult text is of course lower and can't be sped up.

No inherent offence intended to "speed readers"... Ok, maybe a little...

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by maximus_01 on Friday December 13, 2024 @03:44PM (#42412185)
So you have decided anyone who can read faster than you is a fraud? Meaning you think you are in possession of the fastest non-fraudulent human reading abilities possible?

Do you have any evidence of this beyond the fact that if you sped up your own reading you would lose comprehension? The person reading at 150wpm could make the same case against you.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by PaulHoule on Friday December 13, 2024 @03:51PM (#42412230)
There are people who sell "speed reading" courses which is not the same as being a fast reader.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by Nadya on Friday December 13, 2024 @05:14PM (#42412838)
After wasting the better part of a decade on speed reading as a teen and using speed reading tools I can only find myself to agree with them. Remove multiple-choice questions and ask questions about the material and speed readers comprehension crumbles apart to such a degree it is difficult to call what they do to be "reading".

There are quite a number of studies on this, but I'll reference a blog that does all the referencing for me [0] since their experience and thirst for knowledge that led them to later be an advocate against - rather than an advocate for - speed reading is basically a 1:1 match of my own.

500-600 WPM is the upper limits, 99.99% of people claiming otherwise are bullshitting, I always leave that 0.01% because some people are literally just built different and are truly one-of-a-kind (or one-of-maybe-a-dozen people on Earth). Anyone claiming such speeds is going to be under a lot of scrutiny the same way I'd be skeptical of anyone else claiming to be in the top 0.01% of anything. If someone tells me they're a Top 10 Challenger ranked League of Legends player I'm not just going to take their word for it without some solid evidence.

[0] https://www.scotthyoung.com/blog/2015/01/19/speed-reading-re...

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by btilly on Friday December 13, 2024 @09:03PM (#42414053)
That's a healthy attitude.

All that I have to say about it, is that in a place like Hacker News, you do encounter the top 0.01% on a fairly regular basis. Particularly among those who were here early on. Being too skeptical of it when you see it doesn't sound like that good an idea.

I mean seriously. Why would I lie? And why would I risk the fake reputation on this account on a lie about something stupid, when I have friends who know me here?

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by ACow_Adonis on Friday December 13, 2024 @05:26PM (#42412907)
It's not that I've decided based on no evidence, it's that I've never met someone in the flesh able to do it where observations are consistent with claims.

Ignoring five minute Reddit or hacker News messages where people say "oh I'm so fast at reading" once you actually have to put them to the test: i.e. oh cool you're a fast reader: so here's a thing we've both not seen but are required to read and we'll discuss and analyse them in the morning. And you can judge how fast they are based on their understanding of the text and how far they've gotten compared to you.

Eventually you start to realise that there's a mysterious absence of observations to the right of what appears imo to be an almost biological barrier.

Then you start to look into their history: well I presume you've read a lot? And you try to talk to them about things... And they're generally not that well-read.

Then you correlate it with other high-performers: PhDs, professors, learned people, people who read all the time and have a history of reading. And you see that these best readers who read a lot also tend to read at a maximum speed of about 300-600 wpm with any comprehension.

So you come to balance these two hypothesese: there's speed readers out there, but they're generally not well read people and don't have a history of reading and they can't discuss much and they don't tend to turn up to discuss things when there's actual reading involved... But they can read really fast I swear!

And you compare them to the people who professionally read, read all the time, are verifiable strong readers... And you clock them between 300-600 wpm.

Beyond the whole "proving a negative" what's a rational person supposed to conclude?

/This is making some minor possible exceptions for people like Kim peek, but aside from having never met him, of such people exist, my understanding is there's also genuine philosophical questions as to whether what those people are doing can neurologically be considered the same act of reading as what the average human being is doing in terms of whether they can then discuss the themes, contents and implications of what they read.

Edit: and this is in context of people like me LOVE reading, so of course we've looked into methods and communities that propose they can increase reading speed, make people read faster, and are filled with fast readers

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by devilbunny on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:29PM (#42413304)
I don’t have a good cross-reference for wpm on this, but I can read uncomplicated stuff at about 100-120 pages per hour. Most people don’t believe me until they see it.

My wife reads at roughly double that speed. She’s the only person I have ever met who reads significantly faster than I do. Met a few who are 10% or maybe 20% faster than I am. But she’s in an entirely separate category, and yes, that is with 100% comprehension, not skimming.

When we were dating, and I first saw her do it, I just said oh, you read really fast. She said, so you don’t think I’m faking it? No, I said, you’re just the first person I’ve ever met who is noticeably faster than I am, but it’s obviously real.

Then I asked the question: what color is the number 5? She stared at me for a second before giving her reply (I don’t remember). “How did you know?” Because I’d read about synesthesia and a qualitatively different form of pattern recognition seemed the most obvious conclusion. Someone might be a little faster than me with basic reading skills, but I’ve been around enough fast readers to know that I’m pretty damned fast, and that those who are faster are usually just a bit faster. Not double.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by btilly on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:43PM (#42413941)
I have no particular interest in subjecting myself to whatever testing you think is needed. Reading it something that I do for pleasure.

The other person I met with the same speed I discovered by sending her an article, rereading it because I was bored while waiting for her to read, then finding that I was done around when she began commenting on it - having finished at about the same time.

You don't have to believe me. As far as I'm concerned, it's a party trick. But a trick that means that I prefer the written word over other forms of entertainment.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by maximus_01 on Friday December 13, 2024 @10:04PM (#42414335)
I don't entirely agree, but thank you for elaborating. I see at least where you are coming from.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by rramadass on Saturday December 14, 2024 @10:29AM (#42417683)
Good write-up. And i completely agree with you.

I had long since come to the conclusion that "speed reading" is a hoax and just another name for "skimming". They are not fooling anybody but their own ego.

The technique of Reading varies widely based on content and our own interest in it.

For example, i have spent hours upon hours reading/re-reading the Sherlock Holmes canon dozens of times because i find the language phrasing/stories/deductions highly appealing and hence want to savour/understand every word of it. On the other hand even though i love Charles Dickens' novels i don't spend as much time on it and skim through large parts which are not appealing to me. The result is that i can literally write essays in my sleep on Sherlock Holmes but can't do it for Oliver Twist/Great Expectations/etc. Thus the meaning of the word "read" is not the same for both.

I have a huge personal library consisting of a large number of "hard copies" and an even larger one in "soft copies" and love skimming/reading them. Skimming to note the larger main points and coming back to Read them if and when i feel like it.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by lproven on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:42AM (#42417076)
> I'm in the anything above 400-600 wpm is in the bullshitters club.

Hi there. I am the walking talking proof you're wrong.

But I don't know how I can prove it to you.

I read this: https://www.amazon.com/Victory-Island-Tale-Penguin-Classics/...

In 2-2.5 hours.

I read this:

https://www.amazon.com/Mission-Gravity-Mesklinite-Book-Maste...

In half an hour, and that was for pleasure.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by autoexec on Friday December 13, 2024 @06:29PM (#42413305)
To me it isn't just about comprehension either. When I read I think about what I'm reading. I'll often stop mid-page or even mid-sentence to think about related subjects or past experiences that have some connection to what I've just read. It takes me longer than other people I know to read something, but I'm far from the slowest at it, and to me, reading is (or at least can be) a deeper experience than just an info dump into my brain.

I'm sure some of it is ADHD or something but to me, reading is about ideas and I can't wait until the end of a book or even the end of a long article without playing around with them. Especially if it's a topic I'm interested in.

Even if speed readers can fully comprehend and retain what they've sped over, I can't help but feel that they're probably missing something.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by btilly on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:36PM (#42413902)
Here's what's weird. I can read a book faster than I can "digest" it.

I first learned my reading speed by accident after I read Clan of the Cave Bear in a single sitting. Immediately afterwards I could not summarize it, though I could recognize any passage in the book. The next day, I could summarize it.

I describe it as feeling like I have a pipeline. I'm able to fill my brain. Digestion is indeed slower.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by lproven on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:33AM (#42417027)
Exactly so.

As a kid, at once 2 month period, I only had access to a library for a few hours on Sunday afternoons and no other time. I could not remove books.

So I read as much as I could in that time window.

5, 6, 7 books in 2 or 3 hours.

Then I'd spend the next 6 days going through them in my head and enjoying them.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by veidr on Saturday December 14, 2024 @10:49AM (#42417801)
Man! I didn't remember it until reading your comment, but I had the same experience in elementary school — obligatory time in the school, with access to books, but only while I was there, after finishing whatever trivial tasks were assigned.

Alas, the selection was quite lacking. So although I voraciously consumed dozens of "Hardy Boys" novels, the subsequent days were filled with irritating thoughts about how stupid they were.... perhaps the inverse of your experience.

Nevertheless, while I was trapped there, it seemed much better than nothing!

I still read books, and to me it seems obvious that most of the "experience" of reading plays out in the background in the days and weeks that follow (unfortunately, even if the book has little to offer — although as an adult I'm free to recogize that and move on to another book).

P.S. Halfway through https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ministry_for_the_Future and it's a good one! Much better than reading about Chet Morton's old jalopy breaking down again just as the villains are escaping on bicycles... ;-P

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by ruthmarx on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:11AM (#42417253)
Digesting is part of reading. So you're not reading that fast at all.

Imagine if someone said they could eat super fast because they could shove food in their mouth fast, but still took a long time to chew and swallow.

Same thing.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by veidr on Saturday December 14, 2024 @10:30AM (#42417687)
Well I think your analogy would be better if they could also chew and swallow rapidly, but then their digestive tract took inordinate time to process the meal... (^_^);
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by ruthmarx on Saturday December 14, 2024 @10:48AM (#42417798)
That wouldn't be a better analog at all since it wouldn't be making the point I wanted to make, it would just be rephrasing what they stated using the same metaphor.
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by btilly on Friday December 13, 2024 @08:32PM (#42413884)
What answer do you wants?

I can answer comprehension questions and get a good score. For example I got a perfect score on the verbal section of the GRE when I took it in the early 1990s, and this is the speed that I did the reading comprehension tests. I can read whole books, and come away able to find any passage after reading just a few paragraphs. For all intents and purposes, it's read.

I can't debug code at this speed though. Doesn't matter how fast I can read, I can't think for myself at the same speed.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by lupire on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:10AM (#42417243)
How long does that memory of the text last?
Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by lproven on Saturday December 14, 2024 @08:31AM (#42417008)
> I'm skeptical of claims like this. How do the claimants define reading?

There are many. I just did this one, the first hit on Google:

https://swiftread.com/reading-speed-test

It said:

« Reading speed: 861 Words per Minute (WPM)

Comprehension: 100% of questions answered correctly

How your reading speed compares

Slow 150 WPM Average 250 WPM Fast 400 WPM Speed reader 600 WPM

You can read pretty fast! Remember that reading fast is only valuable if you're able to maintain good enough comprehension for your goals. »

I took my time and paid attention in order to be able to give dates and things.

I can go considerably faster. I read about 1000wpm or so for work, a bit slower if I am taking time for pleasure, and when I was a teenager, about 2-3 times faster than that when under pressure.

For instance, I read Joseph Conrad's _Victory_ -- 432 dense pages -- in 2 hours for homework, then wrote an essay on it and went to bed. I got a B+. :-)

Shorter lighter SF novels I read in half an hour, back then.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by lupire on Saturday December 14, 2024 @09:08AM (#42417225)
Are you trolling this thread?

I took that test:

Current Test Results

Reading speed: 1560 Words per Minute (WPM)

Comprehension: 100% of questions answered correctly

Most of my few seconds spent "reading" was actually spent deciding if I even had to read it at all. I correctly concluded that the test was garbage, and then skipped to the questions, and answered the 4(!) questions using only basic common sense.

Re:People who are good at reading have different brains: study by lproven on Monday December 16, 2024 @12:27PM (#42433145)
Good for you.

No, I am not trolling. If you have a better test, I can try it, no problem.