News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Judge Refuses to Allow Sale of Infowars to The Onion by WhatsTheBigIdea on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @03:46PM (#42392771)
Judge Lopez's argument (as communicated by the nytimes) appears invalid.

The standard American auction is the "English Open Cry" auction. The kind of auction we expect to see at cattle auctions, estate auctions, charity auctions, etc. The English Open Cry is what is known as a "second price" auction, which means that the winning bidder will pay 1 increment more than the next highest bidder was willing to pay.

When you have a "sealed" or "secret" bid auction, the fundamental game changes to the "Vickrey Auction" which is a "first price" auction. This means that the highest bidder wins and pays the price they bid... which is expected to be the highest price at which they would be happy with the transaction.

The Sealed-Bid auction should generate a price that is greater than or equal to the English Open Cry in all situations.

The only caveat is that since the Sealed-Bid auction is always less kind to the bidder, it may not attract as many bidders as the English Open Cry.

Re:Judge Refuses to Allow Sale of Infowars to The Onion by archon1410 on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:01PM (#42392929)
You're confused. It's the Vickery auction which is second-price. English auctions are first-price. First-price sealed bid auctions are different from Vickery auctions.
Re:Judge Refuses to Allow Sale of Infowars to The Onion by johnnyanmac on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @03:58PM (#42392893)
Given how the NYT is describing the entire court case (only a level above shit slinging from Twitter), it sounds like this is less about any rationale and more dragging of the feet to get any kind of "win" out of this whole kerfluffle.

The judge basically says as much in the end:

>“You’ve got to scratch and claw and get everything you can for everyone else,” he said.

Which is a truly bizarre statement for a judge to make given the nature of this entire case. Then again, "good faith errors" certainly shows the bias of this judge here.

Re:Judge Refuses to Allow Sale of Infowars to The Onion by stevage on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:44PM (#42393324)
> The Sealed-Bid auction should generate a price that is greater than or equal to the English Open Cry in all situations.

That is a very large claim to make that ignores psychology. If it were true, you would never see open cry auctions used anywhere.

Re:Judge Refuses to Allow Sale of Infowars to The Onion by RobotToaster on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:46PM (#42393332)
> The Sealed-Bid auction should generate a price that is greater than or equal to the English Open Cry in all situations.

Do you have a source for this? I find it hard to believe standard "English" auctions would be so popular if it was true.

Re:Judge Refuses to Allow Sale of Infowars to The Onion by tz18 on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @05:13PM (#42393619)
Parent commenter's description of the difference between an ascending bid auction and a second price auction (or Vickrey auction) is very confused. You can review the first chapter of "Mechanism Design and Approximation" for an introduction to auctions and proofs of the optimality of different auctions for different goals (e.g. the second price auction is proven to maximize social surplus): https://jasonhartline.com/MDnA/
Re:Judge Refuses to Allow Sale of Infowars to The Onion by nocman on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:49PM (#42393365)
> The Sealed-Bid auction should generate a price that is greater than or equal to the English Open Cry in all situations.

Not necessarily. In many sealed-bid auctions, bidders hope to win with a lower bid (often much lower) than they would if they were bidding against others in the same room. This is especially true if you have no idea whether anyone else is bidding on the item at all. I have placed very low bids on items in sealed-bid auctions for things I had no immediate need for, but would happily pay for if the cost was very low (and I have won many such items, sometimes because no one else even bid on them).

Re:Judge Refuses to Allow Sale of Infowars to The Onion by krisoft on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @07:05PM (#42394585)
> I have placed very low bids on items in sealed-bid auctions for things I had no immediate need for, but would happily pay for if the cost was very low

Would you think it would have gone differently in an English Open Cry situation?

Re:Judge Refuses to Allow Sale of Infowars to The Onion by tz18 on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @05:05PM (#42393528)
This is almost entirely wrong in all respects. You can review the first chapter of "Mechanism Design and Approximation" for a good introduction to auction design. https://jasonhartline.com/MDnA/