Changes to lifestyle, stress, recreation patterns, and access can all be factors in it spiraling out, and once you're there it's hard to gently wind it back. It's difficult to compare directly because a lot of the places with intentionally high taxes on alcohol also have strong public healthcare systems.
But even simple measures like municipal ordinances against selling sub-500ml containers of hard liquor show small but clear results in reducing addiction rates. In any case the consensus among addiction medicine professionals right now seems to be in favor of this sort of "soft restriction" public health policy.
Do we prevent some from having a bad experience, at the expense of others having a good experience? Or do we allow some to have a good experience, at the experience of others having a bad experience?
I’m a bit of a hedonist so i very strongly favour the latter.
Like: we used to ban alcohol, betting and drugs. But we unbanned alcohol and betting and are moving towards decriminalization of drugs.
Not saying one way is right or wrong (I can see arguments on both sides, and I personally prefer having freedom). But it does seem the general trend in (US) society these days.