I really don't want to buy a Tesla, but from what I can tell, nobody has anything close to what FSD offers.
From what I read about it, you're absolutely right. Down to the point of unwanted veering towards road dividers and other vehicles.
Our 2024 Kia does this every 10-20 miles on average. You don't even have to enable lane assist. It also randomly decides to weaken the regenerative braking, or switch out of single pedal mode.
If you disable enough of the safety features it stops doing these things, but, for instance, that means you can't have blind spot detection that works when you're going over 5mph and a working steering column at the same time.
The Tesla system isn't perfect, but it is far from unique in being imperfect.
FSD is a very hard problem, and the systems deployed are at best alpha level. These things should be "hyped responsibly".
It's super-duper popular to bag on Tesla / Musk now because the mainstream news is shilling for the Left, and he's 'the enemy', even though they're the ones that drove him away. That plus, Musk won't bend the knee to the censorship machine and won't deplatform anyone with contrary narratives to the endless lies the mainstream pumps out these days. I know how difficult to avoid the non-stop lie machine, you have to actively seek out actual journalism such as Glenn Greenwald or Matt Taibbi... and X is quite literally the only truly free and open space, and sure it's got a ton of nutty shit, but that's the canary showing you it's at least non-censored. I'd rather wade through a bunch of crazy stories about hurricane weather control and see actual pictures of these crazy UAP's all over NJ that don't seem to get much press anywhere else... but I digress.
> and X is quite literally the only truly free and open space
> free
My brother, you need to literally pay money or your tweets get buried by those who do.
> open
Since taking control of the company, musk made it a closed platform. You now need an account to view tweets, before you did not.
SuperCruise does what it claims to do, keep it up the middle on listed corridors. Most highways and interstates are eligible. I love both systems.
FSD is truly almost there for unsupervised, point to point driving. People want to virtue signal and complain about Tesla but it is an amazing piece of hardware being mass produced today. My car is 3 years old.
You might "feel" it is almost there because it gets it right 99.9% of the time but that is still way too many accidents and injuries in the long run. And the work to go from 99.9% to 99.9999% is 1000x more complicated.
Also, fault tolerance error rates don’t work that way - difficulty increases exponentially as you increase fault. In other words, it’s much more difficult than three orders of magnitude to go from 3 9s to 6 9s - it’s easily 5-6 orders of magnitude.
When L5 becomes available then this becomes a different calculus. And it’s honestly questionable about how good the characterization actually is since Tesla’s L2 FSD seems to outperform Mercedes’s L3 and it’s more a matter of the liability the manufacturer is willing to take on vs objective measurements of quality.
The average crash rate for human is one every 500k miles.
You'd trust your partner or parent to do that for you ...
That said, based on my experience with FSD, I'd be tempted to take a nap if it let me, reinforcing my initial statement that it's very darn close.
Are you ready to have your tesla drive FSD with you sleeping in it for 500k? You are letting your feeling dictate that FSD is ready. The math is more complicated.
Going from 99.9% to 99.99999% is what makes a system truly driverless and where most of the work is. Waymo is way way ahead of FSD for this.
Your comment/question seems to assume that somehow accurate classification of performance is possible, which is demonstrably false assumption.
First, if somehow system-internal watchdog was able to detect erroneous outputs for training, it would also be able to stop those outputs propagating to control system live, leading to zero errors. Such a watchdog requires self driving to be quantified analytically, leaving implementation entirely testable and therefore control system not passing the testsuite (i.e. exhibiting erroneous behavior, i.e. still having "edge cases") not deployable in public. Many words to say that that in practice with driving being somewhat loosely defined you need humans in the training loop.
Second, vehicle operators are not only unqualified to accurately monitor behavior of these autonomous systems, in part due to not being formally trained on safety systems in general and the system they are monitoring in particular, but on top of that incentivized to underreport erroneous output.
My prediction has been that we are going to see increased number of accidents with ADAS deployments, not less, before the number can start dwindling.
That said, when trying to BUY a supercruise vehicle, the sales guys were clueless, I had to review the stat sheets of each car to see which ones did or did not have it. GM is treating this technology as “surveys say 2% of the market wants a self driving vehicle” (incorrect question) compared to “install on every vehicle as an available subscription, let the sales team earn their way.” I’m sure the tech is expensive, but it can’t be that much more at the OEM level.
I also have a Tesla with FSD. FSD is truly amazing but still struggles with edge cases like, my office has two entrances, one is blocked by barrels, it tries to turn into the barrels every time.