News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by boshalfoshal on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @08:30PM (#42383743)
Supercruise might be comparable to Tesla's "Autosteer" product but its incomparable to Tesla's paid "FSD Supervised" product. The latter is closer to a Waymo or Cruise than it is to a Mercedes or GM driver assist.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by jefftk on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @08:45PM (#42383824)
> The latter is closer to a Waymo or Cruise than it is to a Mercedes or GM driver assist.

It depends how you look at it, but in the (super limited) cases where you can use Mercedes Drive Pilot you can legally and safely read a book, watch a movie, or work while in the driver's seat. [1] That's not the case with any Tesla product.

[1] https://www.mbusa.com/en/owners/manuals/drive-pilot

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by boshalfoshal on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:47PM (#42384199)
Yes there are actual "legal" notions of driver assistance "levels," but out of those 3 companies Tesla seems to be taking it the most seriously. Elon has a high conviction in the product and has continued to pour billions of dollars in GPUs, talent, supply chains, etc to make it happen. Other manufacturers don't take it nearly as seriously, unfortunately.

Sure you might not be able to legally claim that a Tesla is totally "autonomous," but the fact of the matter (to me, at least) is that they are putting in way more effort to solve the problem than legacy auto manufacturers are.

I can step into a Tesla today, press a destination, and go there without touching the wheel or pedals. Sure it won't be flawless but the fact is, I can. I can't do the same in any other consumer car, and the closest thing is a Waymo. The effort is there, I think its just a matter of time before we start seeing the legal stuff play out.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by jefftk on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:58PM (#42384263)
I think there's some chance that Tesla's approach will work out for them, but I'm not optimistic. Getting self-driving software to "impressively good" happened pretty quickly, and even systems from 2016 would usually pass your "go there without touching the wheel or pedals" test. But from there to "as safe as a human" let alone "as safe as we require human-replacing machines to be" turns out to be quite a hard gap to cross.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by fiddlerwoaroof on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @12:50AM (#42385164)
There’s no comparison between what was available when I bought my Tesla in 2020 and what I have today.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by jefftk on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @08:15AM (#42387384)
When you say "what was available" do you mean what a Tesla was capable of? Because I was trying to talk about things like Cruise driving for 90min at night in a city with no intervention: https://youtu.be/KSRPmng1cmA
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by fiddlerwoaroof on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @11:25PM (#42396201)
If you let me pick the roads, I could easily drive 90 minutes at night with no intervention in the LA area: driving from Ventura, down the 126 to the 5 to LAX can be done basically with no interventions no problem today. It could be done with EAP two years ago too. But, FSD works well on essentially arbitrary roads and it didn't four years ago.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by jefftk on Thursday December 12, 2024 @11:00AM (#42400270)
> driving from Ventura, down the 126 to the 5 to LAX

That's a lot simpler than what Cruise showed in their video. Dealing well with pedestrians, stopped cars, cross streets, etc are a significant challenge.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by fiddlerwoaroof on Friday December 13, 2024 @01:10AM (#42406302)
That basically works today, my point is that there was a step change in ability over the last year or two compared to when I got my car.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by grmarcil on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @02:17AM (#42385596)
> systems from 2016 would usually pass your "go there without touching the wheel or pedals" test

Can you give an example? I'm not aware of anything in 2016 that would consistently pass this test.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by michaelt on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @03:39AM (#42385952)
Well, there's consistently and there's consistently.

In 2016 Waymo reported their safety drivers intervening once for every 5,100 miles driven [1] - which implies to me that 99% of journeys nobody touched the wheel or pedals.

The problem is 99% isn't enough, as there are tremendous numbers of cars out there, and a busy bit of freeway would get a disengagement per minute.

[1] https://driverless.wonderhowto.com/news/2016-disengagement-r...

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by norlygfyd on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @07:28AM (#42387066)
They Waymo trick is entirely different to FSD. They are travelling pre-mapped streets.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by misiti3780 on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @01:20PM (#42390904)
with remote controller drivers on an as needed basis
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by michaelt on Thursday December 12, 2024 @04:53AM (#42397799)
You've used Google Street View, right?

It might be missing a few logging roads, private driveways and carpark lanes - but it shows Google is entirely capable of mapping streets in detail all over the world.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by kortilla on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:50AM (#42386316)
> and even systems from 2016 would usually pass your "go there without touching the wheel or pedals" test

This is complete bullshit. The systems in 2016 were restricted to pre-mapped areas with lots of training. (i.e. the waymo/cruise approach today) So if you weren’t in a tiny slice of San Francisco or a few other training areas, this didn’t work.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by jefftk on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @09:15AM (#42387878)
Even if an area is pre-mapped, if you're operating on public streets you need to handle all sorts of unusual things. Here's a Cruise video recorded in 2016 on SF streets, showing a tricky interactions with buses, stopped delivery vehicles, pedestrians, etc: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Tp6Ubf6mE4
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by kortilla on Saturday December 14, 2024 @01:34AM (#42415114)
Yeah, I’m not saying they weren’t doing impressive things. I’m saying they were still severely limited and would not be capable of a “go around without touching the wheel/brakes test” like a Tesla can in the entire US now.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by sangnoir on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @12:45AM (#42385144)
> Yes there are actual "legal" notions of driver assistance "levels," but out of those 3 companies Tesla seems to be taking it the most seriously.

..and yet Tesla is quick to blame the drivers when accidents happen - and has disclaimers for supervision in its TOS. Mercedes on the other hand, takes all responsibility for eventualities that happen while self-driving is engaged (DrivePilot - not ADAS)

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by iknowstuff on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @03:34AM (#42385937)
You fell for Mercedes’ marketing. Its useless.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by pelorat on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @02:27AM (#42385643)
From what I've seen, Tesla FSD would fail a driving test here in the EU within the 1st minute. Even the latest and greatest version behaves like a drunk teenager.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by frankacter on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @03:44AM (#42385972)
I'm not in EU so I can't comment if they have a special circumstance that makes there driving test different than elsewhere in the world, but "behaving like a drunk teenager" is not a descriptor I would use. I make use of Tesla FSD every day, 2 -3 times a day. Over the last few months I've had to engage (of my own choosing) twice, otherwise it is completely hands and foot off experience.

I travel hundred miles a day on average on a mix of local and highway, but all major roads in city and suburb.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by zeusk on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:16AM (#42386115)
I would pay to be away from such drivers
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by 7thpower on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:44AM (#42386285)
Why? And I’m curious if you would you pay more or less to avoid people who are texting/reading while driving?

What about people who make snarky comments to posters who are sharing their experiences in good faith?

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by zeusk on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @05:00AM (#42386369)
Would definitely pay more to avoid FSD pilots, because the texters sense their surroundings more often than the drivers lulled by false advertisement and (at-best) beta grade software.

The snarky posters can stay, doesn't hurt my life or property.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by ninalanyon on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:35AM (#42386234)
Driving tests in Europe, certainly in northern Europe and Scandinavia, are considerably stricter than in the US and many other places in the world. In Norway the test is also not enough, there is also obligatory practice with a qualified instructor including driving on motorways and on a skid pan to simulate driving on ice.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by yreg on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:30AM (#42386200)
I'm EU citizen and I've recently tried out FSD during a vacation in US. It drove perfectly. Same with Waymo.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by fooker on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @05:09AM (#42386418)
Or course it would fail a driving test designed for humans.

Humans would fail a driving test designed for autonomous driving too. We don't have the reaction time comparable to computers to ..say.. avoid oncoming traffic or an object/animal on the road within a few milliseconds. Or identify dark objects easier to see in infrared. Or maintain an exact speed, to a few significant digits. Or manually do a good job with traction control.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by FabHK on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @02:40AM (#42385705)
> of those 3 companies Tesla seems to be taking it the most seriously.

You call lying about it endlessly, misleading marketing, beta-testing on public roads, and not even having L3 properly in production "taking it the most seriously"?

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by ForHackernews on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @06:19AM (#42386741)
Yes: Only Tesla is willing to sacrifice human lives today for the dream of robo-driving in the future.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by edm0nd on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @09:36AM (#42388114)
Sometimes ya gotta break a few eggs to make an omelette
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by boshalfoshal on Friday December 13, 2024 @04:27AM (#42407186)
No, I'm mostly referring to buying talent and GPUs.

I can't point to a single Andrej Karpathy or Chris Lattner or Jim Keller working at Mercedes, BMW, GM, etc (not to mention the not so big named people who are still very very good). And I also don't see many people crossing over from legacy auto autonomous orgs to openai, anthropic, deepmind, etc.

Other manufacturers don't have custom in car inference chips either, or spend billions in R&D for custom training silicon. This is clearly not a side project for Tesla, whereas with other manufacturers, its an obvious afterthought.

My guess is other manufacturers will just license some AV product from whoever is most successful and try to sell products like they always have - through design language and brand feel, not through breakthrough technological innovation.

So yes, I don't think any other consumer car manufacturer is taking it seriously.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by threeseed on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @04:22AM (#42386146)
> Elon has a high conviction in the product and has continued to pour billions of dollars in GPUs, talent, supply chains, etc to make it happen

But that has been invested in X.ai not Tesla.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by porphyra on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @08:56PM (#42383884)
The MB Drive Pilot only works at ridiculously low speeds (under 40 mph), on select highways, no sharp turns, no weather, no construction zones, lanes clearly visible, etc. It's laughable to compare it against FSD which works everywhere. FSD has been flawless when driving on such easy conditions for years.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by adrr on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:14PM (#42383995)
FSD isn't driving though, you're driving. Mercedes is driving itself and you have 10 seconds to takeover. Huge difference between level 3 and level 2. One is self driving and one is just a drivers aid.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by mensetmanusman on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:28PM (#42384073)
FSD is hybrid driving.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by ivewonyoung on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:34PM (#42384114)
> Mercedes is driving itself and you have 10 seconds to takeover. Huge difference between level 3 and level 2. One is self driving and one is just a drivers aid.

None of that is true, it just follows the car in front in slow moving traffic during daytime in good weather on premapped roads and cannot even change lanes. No car in front anymore? It completely fails to "self"-drive.

These limitations are taboo to talk about because the Mercedes system is used as an anti-Tesla talking point, you can get permanently banned from Reddit and BlueSky for bringing it up. Thats why so many people think its a great system.

Edit: Downvotes for bringing up inconvenient facts.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by jefftk on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:54PM (#42384241)
I'm very much aware of how Drive Pilot doesn't handle most cases: in my comment I described it as "super limited" and linked to where Mercedes describes the details.

But within the range of cases where the Mercedes system is applicable (which recently went up to 59mph in Germany [1]) it's solidly better than the Tesla system because Mercedes did the engineering to make it reliable enough that you don't have to supervise the car's driving. If I had a highway commute in stop-and go traffic I'd be comfortable reading in a Mercedes, but not in a Tesla.

[1] https://media.mercedes-benz.com/article/4c04b46a-05e3-4a20-9...

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by porphyra on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @11:18PM (#42384752)
If Tesla were to artificially set up limitations like highway only, daytime, clearly visible lanes, good weather, car in front, no construction zones, no lane changes, etc, then they would easily have been able to offer full L3 and take full liability for it. Tesla FSD is practically perfected, with no accidents whatsoever, under such conditions already. But Elon wouldn't want to release this kind of gimped system as he is aiming for full self driving everywhere.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by root_axis on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @12:29AM (#42385073)
> Tesla FSD is practically perfected

Absolutely untrue. It's not even close to perfect. I use it a few times a week and while it's seen some significant improvements over the last year, it still makes pretty dangerous mistakes, especially on left turns, right-turn slip lanes, intersections with flashing yellow lights, streets with very worn road lines or where the positioning of the road lines shift from one side of the intersection to the other. I can think of a dozen other similar situations so I'm very sure there are many others I've never even encountered.

It remains to be seen how much juice Tesla can squeeze out of a transformer approach to autonomous driving, but it's by no means a sure thing.

edit: I misunderstood the comment. I see now that "practically perfected" is a reference to the ideal conditions mentioned in your first sentence.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by sib on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @12:52AM (#42385176)
You seem to have (accidentally?) left off the rest of the comment:

"Tesla FSD is practically perfected, with no accidents whatsoever, under such conditions"

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by root_axis on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @01:39AM (#42385403)
You're right. Thanks. I edited my comment to acknowledge that.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by throwaway2037 on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @08:20AM (#42387415)
Thank you to post your personal experience. One pattern that I have noticed about Tesla FSD stories on HN: it is black and white, with little grey area. Either people live an area where the roads are easy for FSD to navigate, and they come here to say "It is perfect!". And vice versa: People live in a place with a bunch of complex roads and intersections where FSD does not perform well... And they come to HN to share their experience. (Privately, I cannot wait to see self-driving models try driving on Jakarta or Napoli. It will so much fun to watch those on YouTube!) I do think that Elon/Tesla is taking a crazy gamble to release FSD early to gain billions of hours of training data! I can understand where this would make some people uncomfortable, due to the safety concerns. Except Waymo, who else has the training data that Tesla has at this point? Wiki tells me that FSD has been driving on public roads since 2016. That must an astonishing amount of training data accumulated in the last 8 years! I assume he will be tasking X.ai with improving the FSD model using this enormous training data.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by porphyra on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @09:32AM (#42388060)
The streets of Jakarta and Napoli wouldn't work with the Mercedes Benz system either.

> Who has the training data at this point?

Woven by Toyota has roof pods on rideshare (Lyft) cars collecting data: https://woven.toyota/en/our-latest/20220407/

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by Hamuko on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @01:41AM (#42385414)
How can you claim that they could do it when they clearly are not doing it?
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by Certhas on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @03:05AM (#42385801)
This is so absurd. If they could accurately predict when their system is so reliable, they could get it certified for Level 3 use in these conditions. That's not a gimped version, that's strictly better than the product they offer.

They can't though. Mercedes-Benz can. To pretend that Tesla doesn't offer a better product because they don't want to is...

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by 4ndrewl on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @07:26AM (#42387052)
Tesla aren't allowed to because of woke /s
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by sangnoir on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @03:09AM (#42385825)
> Tesla FSD is practically perfected, with no accidents whatsoever, under such conditions already

Disengaging 2 seconds before an accident leads to a perfect driving record

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by ivewonyoung on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @10:11PM (#42384336)
> If I had a highway commute in stop-and go traffic I'd be comfortable reading in a Mercedes

It gets dark at 4:45PM in a good chunk of the western world in winter so it won't be useful then.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by adrr on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @10:23PM (#42384415)
Compare it to FSD which can't self drive on any road in any condition. Thats the real facts.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by ripjaygn on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @10:37PM (#42384505)
There are plenty of FSD videos on YouTube where the driver didn't have to intervene at all on long trips, where the car isn't just following the car in front.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by adrr on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @10:50PM (#42384578)
You hit it on the nail, the driver didn't have to intervene but they had to be ready to take over at any time. If FSD could safely operate where you had 10 seconds to take over for level 3, why doesn't Tesla go get it certified for L3 driving. FSD isn't even approved for being a drivers aid(hands off, eyes on) in EU and China because Tesla has not demonstrated that it is safe. Even Blue cruise is approved in EU for comparison. And it isn't because Tesla isn't trying to get ADAS certification in these markets.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by delabay on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @11:56PM (#42384931)
Imo Mercedes scored a point with their narrow application of L3 driving, Tesla is playing to win the game.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by jajko on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @07:18AM (#42387008)
For past decade, with meh results consistently so far. They were/are? selling FSD as premium package and never delivered on promises, that's outright fraud in plain sight.

Technologically Tesla is far behind since one man's ego wants to trump physics and computing limitations and its failing. Still no Lidar.

I don't care about 90 youtube videos of long drives with no intervention. I care about a million out of a million (and maybe 10 on top). Either there is something I can trust with mine and my kids life with, or I am not interested with anything on top adaptive cruise control (since I don't spend my life in stop&go traffic).

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by adrr on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @12:53PM (#42390590)
Are they? they haven't start certification for self driving any market? It seems FSD is more of way to pump the stock. Mercedes is testing their same cars for L4(point to point) in china.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by llamaimperative on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:00PM (#42383911)
Are you assuming MB Drive Pilot couldn’t also work pretty well outside of its design domain?

This argument is always so silly because it’s just an argument about the correct way to build a safe control system (i.e. with guaranteed performance characteristics in a defined operational domain) versus the incorrect way to do it (just kinda work over an ambiguously defined set of conditions and hope you don’t kill too many innocent people to cripple your business).

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by ivewonyoung on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:37PM (#42384141)
> Are you assuming MB Drive Pilot couldn’t also work pretty well outside of its design domain?

Yes,that's a suppressed fact, not an assumption. It just follows the car in front. Check my other comment.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42384114

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by llamaimperative on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @10:15PM (#42384356)
Umm, yeah. Maybe I wasn't clear.

MB Drive Pilot is designed not to attempt to operate outside of a well-defined domain.

It will, by design, not operate in a way that is unsafe or in a context in which it's unsafe.

You are arguing the system would perform worse in contexts in which you have not seen it perform (because its designers decided to prevent it from such attempts).

What evidence do you have for your argument?

Restated: You are assuming that if Mercedes engineers had a similar appetite for putting millions of innocent people at risk by operating in unreliable contexts, that their system would perform far worse than FSD does. On what basis do you make that assumption?

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by ivewonyoung on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @10:26PM (#42384439)
> What evidence do you have for your argument?

The fact that their software is written only to just follow the car in front, and completely and immediately give up if there's no car in front or one cannot be seen due to it being dark or bad weather, on premapped roads.

Meanwhile FSD has repeatedly shown that's it's capable of driving without a car in front.

You can watch YouTube videos of FSD driving without a car in front for thousands of miles on non-premapped roads.

What makes you think Mercedes would be better at doing that?

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by gmueckl on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @01:21AM (#42385300)
What makes you think that MB doesn't have the same capability, but they aren't willing to ship a half-arsed highly dangerous, people killing feature like some other companies do? Unlike any of their competitors, they assume full legal liability for their car's behavior while Drive Pilot is enabled.

MB also has a luxury brand reputation to maintain. When they ship a major feature like that, it absolutely has to work 100% as advertised.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by ivewonyoung on Friday December 13, 2024 @01:31PM (#42411044)
> Unlike any of their competitors, they assume full legal liability for their car's behavior while Drive Pilot is enabled.

Source? If someone gets killed when the system is driving, there is no legal framework for you as a driver to escape criminal penalties. Who at MB are they going to jail for it?

Can UPS indemnify their drivers from involuntary manslaughter charges?

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by typewithrhythm on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @02:28AM (#42385654)
I've worked on competitors to the mb system from legacy auto; generally the way we work is make the best possible system for the long term, then limit the odd to meet safety, regulatory, and brand risk requirements.

So there will be a system happily running producing target driving paths, but some monitoring system disables in the case with no car in front.

I would guess that the mb system is in fact ok without a car in front, but didn't hit their appetite for risk yet.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by llamaimperative on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @09:44AM (#42388195)
> What makes you think Mercedes would be better at doing that?

I didn't say they are. You're the only one making assumptions here :)

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by ripjaygn on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @10:40PM (#42384521)
> You are arguing the system would perform worse in contexts in which you have not seen it perform (because its designers decided to prevent it from such attempts).

Should we also assume that Mercedes cars can fly better than a plane, because we have not yet seen them fly?

What kind of logic is that?

In other news, OpenAI has solved AGI last year, but is keeping it a secret because it's too dangerous.

I have solved self driving, how can you say I didn't if you haven't seen it perform?

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by gmueckl on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @01:27AM (#42385346)
What kind of messed-up logic is that? How many products do you think you own that contain hidden features that you're not supposed to know about? Just about everything with at least a microcontroller inside has extra software modules that you never learn about as the end user (e.g. service modes and factory calibration routines).
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by llamaimperative on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @09:43AM (#42388177)
No, but generally you should assume a system with near-100% performance within a well-defined ODD doesn't fall off to near-0% performance immediately adjacent to that ODD.

Here's a better example: let's say by law Mercedes has to restrict their cars from exceeding 80mph. They have a car that can reach 80mph in 2 seconds. Is it therefore credible to claim that the car is actually incapable of driving at 81mph?

Or is it more credible to say, "we don't know much about its performance beyond 80mph, but it can probably achieve something outside of that."

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by ivewonyoung on Friday December 13, 2024 @01:28PM (#42411011)
A car not being in front means more data for cameras because they can see more of the road ahead if the system can actually do proper road navigation.

The fact that it shuts off immediately shows that they're just copying what the car ahead does.

The system is unable to function on a pre-mapped highway on a clear day with lane markings if there is no other traffic on the road. What does that tell you?

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by judge2020 on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @12:41AM (#42385127)
How do I file a claim for an accident it causes?
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by kccqzy on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @12:42AM (#42385130)
I'm sure legally yes, but tell that to a cop who stopped you.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by norlygfyd on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @07:27AM (#42387061)
And in those same cases, you could probably safely do the same with FSD (s), but because FSD isn't as limited and the Mercedes product is not a serious competitor, there's no compelling reason for allowing it.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by PaulWaldman on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @08:58PM (#42383902)
Eh, Tesls's FSD and Autopilot as well as GM's Supercruise are all classified as SAEJ3016 Automation Level 2.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by red75prime on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:10PM (#42383966)
Which tells approximately nothing about their relative capabilities. The fallback system is the driver (who needs to be ready to take over immediately) and the range of conditions for autonomous operation is better than Level 1.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by danans on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @10:55PM (#42384616)
> the range of conditions for autonomous operation is better than Level 1.

It better be, because Level 1 is satisfied with just cruise control with automatic braking.

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by jaimex2 on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @08:45PM (#42383829)
It's not even close between Tesla and Waymo.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hv9HtWUf27s

Arguably this is Waymo in its "home turf"

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by adrr on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:22PM (#42384034)
Tesla can't self drive in any condition on any street. Hard to compare that to a level 4 company where the car can go hundreds of thousands of miles without disengagement. Being a owner FSD, its no where near being able to drive itself without supervision, it tries to run reds, misses people in cross walks and can't understand signs like "Do Not Enter".
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by minhazm on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @10:03PM (#42384291)
> Hard to compare that to a level 4 company where the car can go hundreds of thousands of miles without disengagement

This is nowhere close to being true. The latest numbers I could find for 2022 are 17,060 miles per disengagement[1] for Waymo. And even then the definition is not quite clear, because these are safety disengagements from what I can tell, and not disengagements for things like getting stuck because the road is closed or something else.

[1] https://www.eetimes.com/waymo-cruise-dominate-av-testing/

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by danans on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @10:51PM (#42384582)
> This is nowhere close to being true. The latest numbers I could find for 2022 are 17,060 miles per disengagement[1] for Waymo

Tesla doesn't reveal it's miles/disengagement stats, but according to crowdsourced data it's 690-828 miles between critical disengagement [1], which is 2 orders of magnitude worse than the Waymo number you posted, and far below their goal of besting human drivers' abilities.

1. https://electrek.co/2024/10/24/elon-musk-just-said-some-wild...

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by bushbaba on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @12:05AM (#42384972)
Regardless we are probably about 10-50x the disengagement rate needed. It’s about 1 accidents every 500k miles for a human driver.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by danans on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @01:07AM (#42385239)
Your 1 accident per 500k miles stat is an average across urban and rural areas. But accident rates in urban areas are likely significantly higher than in non-urban areas, due to higher vehicle density/congestion, despite the fact that vehicle accident fatality rates are higher in rural areas[1]. Urban areas tend to have a lot more low-speed no-injury or mild-injury collisions. When you account for all of those, AVs are in shooting distance of human driver accident rates in urban areas. Also, the accident rates are much higher for drunk, sleepy, or distracted drivers, so to the extent AVs reduce those types of driving, they bring the overall accident rates down much further.

1. https://crashstats.nhtsa.dot.gov/Api/Public/Publication/8135....

Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by mbreese on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @09:05PM (#42383932)
Arguably, it would be a better comparison if the Tesla was restricted from highway driving. I understand the letting the car figure out its own route, but I’m more interested in seeing the Tesla navigate city streets.
Re:GM exits robotaxi market, will bring Cruise operations in... by m463 on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @01:34AM (#42385375)
I thought supercruise only worked on "qualified roads".

Tesla autopilot 1.0 has been around on tesla since 2015. It's actually pretty good on the freeway as traffic aware cruise control + autosteer. I think it's a pretty good balance of driver + assist.