News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by lloeki on Thursday July 12, 2012 @05:04PM (#4236814)
> I think this is all related to the iOS X direction Apple is going with their desktops. they would rather force a broken implementation of full-screen

Indeed the current implementation is severely lacking. It's jarring when you plug a MacBook to a TV, pop in a DVD video, which starts the official DVD Player, and put it in full screen. Possible scenarios include:

- you are in mirror mode: this means the TV and the internal display will be at their common denominator, suboptimal in both resolution and aspect ratio.

- you are not in mirror mode: the primary display is irrevocably the built-in one. DVD Player goes fullscreen on that 13", while you can enjoy 42" of glorious Lion linen. Of course you don't want to close the screen, unless you have both fed the laptop with AC and have an external peripheral at hand to control Apple Remote, an external keyboard or a Magic Trackpad, which is a ludicrous situation.

The current solution is of course to use VLC, which goes around Lion's fullscreen API.

Yet I see a solution ahead.

In Lion an app "going fullscreen" really means "the app gets its own space" (I thus prefer the term "fullspace" instead). What's more, since Spaces have been introduced, a multihead setup lies in a single, giant Space all across. It follows that since the two screens are one unique Space, an app going fullspace will (under the current implementation) take over the two screens.

That's the problem, and so there's the solution: in a dual-head setup, the two screens should be two independent spaces, not one across.

This solves a good deal of issues:

- fullspace immediately occupies only one screen, with the other ones available to desktops or other fullspace apps

- windows can be moved from one monitor to an other monitor from Mission Control. This is not possible currently: you have to exit Mission Control and drag the window to the other screen.

- windows can be moved from one monitor to another space on another monitor from Mission Control. This is not possible currently: you have to exit MC, drag the window as the previous case, enter MC again and drag the window to the other space.

- and why not, Spaces could be rearranged not only inside each monitor, but across monitors. Take Desktop2 on Screen1, drag it on Screen2 after Desktop3, take fullspaced QuickTime on Screen3, put in on Screen1. There are problems to be solved, like when resolutions differ, but that's really not the end of the world.

MC literally begs for those four features.

I don't know if Apple thought of it yet (probably) and if they want to go that way (who knows, really). For all I know it would mean a heavy deal of refactoring of the current Spaces implementation (e.g see how currently Desktop1 is never reorderable, how fishy...).

Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by phamilton on Thursday July 12, 2012 @11:09PM (#4238029)
I've learned to treat spaces as complete context switches. I think I like it better this way (though I know I'm in the minority here).

Space 1: Left Monitor - Chrome (Work profile), Middle Monitor - IDE, Right Monitor - Terminal Space 2: Left Monitor - Chrome (Personal profile), Middle Monitor - Itunes and Spotify, Right Monitor - Misc. non work stuff.

If I'm working on two projects, each gets its own space and browser window.

This way I can more effectively tune out Personal distractions.

Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by adrianhoward on Friday July 13, 2012 @03:57AM (#4238723)
I've learned to treat spaces as complete context switches. I think I like it better this way (though I know I'm in the minority here).

I think you're in the minority of the hn community. I'm not entirely sure that you're in the minority in the general population.

Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by geoffw8 on Friday July 13, 2012 @04:28AM (#4238834)
I don't use spaces, I find actually enforcing a multi-space policy to be pretty hard work.
Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by FuzzyDunlop on Thursday July 12, 2012 @07:01PM (#4237314)
Agreed on all counts, however you can change the primary display in System Preferences.

You have to drag the menu bar on the diagram onto the display you want to be the primary.

Of course, that fixes one thing, but then your laptop screen is rendered useless instead.

Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by lloeki on Friday July 13, 2012 @02:11AM (#4238460)
Thanks for that. Talk about non-obvious. I could swear there's a checkbox for that on my dual head Hackintosh that is not present on my MacBook when I plug an external screen. Or it could be me (that time we used the MacBook as a fallback of the fallback — dedicated DVD player died + suddenly no 5.1 sound on XBox360, so I was quite enraged).

Edit: ah, after checking, the drag-the-menubar thing is actually written in the prefpane, and there's no checkbox. Silly me.

Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by Volpe on Friday July 13, 2012 @12:55AM (#4238280)
> - you are not in mirror mode: the primary display is irrevocably the built-in one. DVD Player goes fullscreen on that 13", while you can enjoy 42" of glorious Lion linen. Of course you don't want to close the screen, unless you have both fed the laptop with AC and have an external peripheral at hand to control Apple Remote, an external keyboard or a Magic Trackpad, which is a ludicrous situation.

You can change which screen is the 'primary display'.

Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by barumrho on Thursday July 12, 2012 @05:22PM (#4236907)
This is exactly how xmonad handles multiple screens. I am not very hopeful that Apple will implement this, since it can be pretty confusing to users.
Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by lloeki on Friday July 13, 2012 @02:08AM (#4238457)
Ah I could not remember which of xmonad or awesome was doing that. Mission Control bird's eye view makes workspace management admittedly much less confusing than either one.

It could be hidden behind the existing — and checked by default — option "Automatically rearrange Spaces".

Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by Produce on Friday July 13, 2012 @04:08AM (#4238755)
God forbid someone get confused at the expense of a better and more efficient implementation. Little children get confused by long English words. We should take them out of the dictionary.
Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by mrich on Friday July 13, 2012 @05:59AM (#4239091)
This has always been the Apple mode of operation. With quite some success, I might add.
Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by Produce on Friday July 13, 2012 @07:39AM (#4239325)
I know. It's a tragedy.
Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by btilly on Thursday July 12, 2012 @05:20PM (#4236896)
I would love to have multiple monitors, and have multiple desktops per monitor that I change independently.

For instance on one monitor I could flip between email, the specs for what I'm working on, etc in different desktops. The other monitor can have a browser that I'm testing in, my code, etc in different desktops.

Re:Fullscreen in Mountain Lion still renders second display ... by mitjak on Thursday July 12, 2012 @05:34PM (#4236990)
Brilliant. A space that's 2x the width is both elegant and consistent with the existing UI paradigm.