News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by cogman10 on Friday December 06, 2024 @02:00PM (#42342964)
> What is your theory of responsibility?

Ethical:

He was the CEO of the company and ultimately the buck stops with him on company policies. The company he lead has the highest number of insurance denials (double most other insurance agencies). That has almost certainly lead to death as people not being able to afford treatment is a great way to die. Consider, for example, if someone has cancer and insurance denies coverage of chemo medications that they are supposed to cover. Well, now the covered person is in a battle with the insurance company to pay for the medications (which they say they cover) that works as a ticking timebomb against them. They could pony up the bill while they wait for coverage, but that's not going to be within the means of many people.

> what framework and criteria is it evaluated under?

One of responsibility. Surely the CEO of a company must know that the policy the company he runs and owns has lead to industry leading denial rates. That's exactly the sort of statistic CEOs track and have influence over.

And when dealing with health, the outcome is simply obvious. By increasing the amount of denials you know you are harming legitimate claimants.

This is not a soldier or a serial killer. It's worse than both. It's an uncaring individual optimizing profit over people. Unlike a soldier who likely can't avoid killing or a surgeon who makes mistakes, this is more akin to a general positioning wounded soldiers on the frontlines so the army doesn't have to pay their salaries or feed them. Not for pleasure or psychosis in the case of a serial killer, just for simple banal resource optimization.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by slibhb on Friday December 06, 2024 @02:09PM (#42343094)
> This is not a soldier or a serial killer. It's worse than both.

How can you be so morally clueless?

When an insurance company denies coverage, it isn't killing someone. It didn't make anyone sick. Rather, it didn't pick up the bill for their treatment. That may have been wrong, it may have been an evasion of responsibility, but it is not comparable to someone who goes around killing people.

I have to understand comments like this (there are a lot of them) as some kind of morbid performance art. Either that or severe mental illness.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by cogman10 on Friday December 06, 2024 @02:19PM (#42343207)
> it isn't killing someone.

It is absolutely killing multiple people yearly.

If I withhold water from someone dying of thirst, who I promised to give water to, who paid me for that water, I've killed them when they die. I may not have plunged a knife into their heart but they'll be dead all the same directly from my actions.

If an insurance company does not pay for the medicine and treatments they say they cover, that they payed to cover, and people die from that, they are responsible for those deaths.

A serial killer kills less than the medical health industry does. That doesn't make them moral, it highlights how immoral the current healthcare system is in the US.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by nickff on Friday December 06, 2024 @03:18PM (#42343915)
Every healthcare system (even single-payer) denies some care to some people; they do this because of limited resources, fraud risk, etc.

Do government healthcare ministers and other administrators responsible for single-payer systems deserve to die too? What about legislators who limit healthcare budgets to below 100% of GDP (which is to say all of them); should they be summarily executed?

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by cogman10 on Friday December 06, 2024 @03:32PM (#42344073)
> Do government healthcare ministers and other administrators responsible for single-payer systems deserve to die too?

No, because as you point out there are legitimate reasons to deny coverage.

However, when your competitors are denying at a rate of something like 10->15% and you are denying at 36%, that goes beyond just managing resources or fraud prevention.

Your question is a false dichotomy.

> What about legislators who limit healthcare budgets to below 100% of GDP (which is to say all of them); should they be summarily executed?

Again, false dichotomy. Primarily because it's not even provable that 100% of GDP going to healthcare would actually save more lives than 99% or 50%. Further, unless you have a very expansive definition of what healthcare means (food? housing? etc?) then putting 100% of the budget towards it would ultimately starve out necessary industries for life thus causing death.

The real question to ask is "Can an insurance company be moral if it denies legitimate claims" my answer to that is no. Pragmatically, I can excuse some of it to human error as that'll happen. People will die from accidents and that's just a part of life. However, let's not pretend that there isn't a massive incentive for these large companies to deny as many claims as possible with no market forces and few regulations to impede them.

A government denying a liver transplant to a 90 year old is quiet different from a health insurance agency blanket denying cancer treatment because it costs them too much money.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by nickff on Friday December 06, 2024 @03:34PM (#42344105)
How can you simultaneously contend that United’s denials of coverage are responsible for killing people, and also contend that increasing healthcare spending wouldn’t save people?
Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by cogman10 on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:04PM (#42344419)
You are using binary thinking. It's not a binary.

I can contend that United's denials are responsible for killing people because they are denying at 2x the industry average. To prove me wrong, you'd have to show that actually the rest of the industry isn't denying enough and that United has somehow stumbled upon the real rate of spurious insurance claims.

And for the 100% of money to healthcare that makes the assumption that we have that much healthcare need to spend that much money on. There are limits to needs which is why the argument you make is flawed.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by nickff on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:22PM (#42344603)
Why is the burden of proof on me? You’re the one justifying a murder!

Also, I wouldn’t have to prove than increasing healthcare spending to 100% of GDP would be optimal, just proving that there is some incremental gain by spending a tiny bit more than is currently spent by a single-payer would justify the murder of one or more legislators (by your logic).

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by antasvara on Friday December 06, 2024 @05:09PM (#42345078)
By my cursory Google search, the successful appeal rate for claims denials is somewhere between 30 and 60 percent.

With the caveat that this isn't a representative sample (people appealing likely have the denials most likely to be overturned), 30% at the low end still feels too high.

This rate is even higher for prior authorization denials. Those get overturned on appeal more than half the time.

Probably safe to assume that if your denial rate is 2x competitors, those numbers would be even worse.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by cogman10 on Friday December 06, 2024 @04:39PM (#42344775)
> You’re the one justifying a murder!

I'm not, nor have I ever.

And with that I think this conversation is done. If you won't engage with any point I've made and instead are just here to insult me there's no point in continuing further.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by cdelsolar on Friday December 06, 2024 @02:19PM (#42343200)
Compare this to someone who controls the only available lifeboat while others are drowning. The person in control may not have pushed anyone overboard, but if they refuse to help—especially after taking on the explicit role of “we’re here to help if something goes wrong”—they carry moral responsibility for the resulting harm. Insurance companies are not random bystanders; they are paid entities agreeing to intervene financially on behalf of the patient. Their explicit role makes their refusal to pay not merely passive, but an active withholding of assistance they were entrusted (and compensated) to provide. An insurance company knows full well that refusing to cover a critical treatment will likely result in the patient’s deterioration or death.

Remember Asimov's rules? A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm. They are one and the same.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by nickff on Friday December 06, 2024 @03:26PM (#42344005)
What if the lifeboat skipper picks up many people, but decides that picking up more would endanger the lifeboat itself?

Asimov’s rules don’t work; that’s the whole point.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by cogman10 on Friday December 06, 2024 @03:37PM (#42344140)
If you are to apply it the way health insurance works, the skipper is asking the drowning victims to give them all their money and then is deciding on who they rescue, mostly leaving the people far away to drown because that will have added fuel costs and they'd rather save that to go fishing on tuesday.
Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by nickff on Friday December 06, 2024 @03:46PM (#42344232)
This analogy is already a stretch (I didn’t come up with it, was just responding to someone else), and you’re torturing it beyond reason.
Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by jiggawatts on Saturday December 07, 2024 @02:06AM (#42347844)
Brian Thompson's net worth was $43M.

He definitely has a yacht or two.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by diob on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:48PM (#42347099)
I think you don't understand the games they play. They will cause a surgery to be delayed the day of the surgery by last minute denial tactics, losing patients precious time in things like cancer treatments. In that case, you didn't have the time to even collect the money and get a loan, if that's really your angle.

It's not performance art, just empathy.

I have a friend who they tried to kill this year. His doctor recommended going in and removing an area they thought some skin cancer had spread to. They performed the surgery, biopsy confirmed their suspicions.

After all that, the insurance company (too late thankfully) came in and said they didn't think the cancer had spread, so no need for surgery.

I hope you never have to deal with this, but if you live long enough you or a friend / family member probably will.

There's countless amounts of blood on their hands. It's not about bills coming in and getting uncovered, it's about life saving surgeries being delayed till the patient dies in hopes that they can avoid covering something they're supposed, or avoiding paying for a medication in the hopes that the patient dies before they can litigate.

I don't really care how you want to spin things, that's murder, and thankfully most folks agree with me.

Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by lazystar on Friday December 06, 2024 @10:56PM (#42347137)
the cognitive dissonance of the folks in the insurance industry is what resulted in that execution a few days ago. stop deluding yourself.
Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think by lotsofpulp on Friday December 06, 2024 @11:08PM (#42347191)
> He was the CEO of the company and ultimately the buck stops with him on company policies

No, it didn’t. He had the title of CEO due to title inflation, but UNH’s real CEO is Andrew Witty. The buck stops with Witty (and the board that votes for Witty).