What if the lifeboat skipper picks up many people, but decides that picking up more would endanger the lifeboat itself?
Asimov’s rules don’t work; that’s the whole point.
If you are to apply it the way health insurance works, the skipper is asking the drowning victims to give them all their money and then is deciding on who they rescue, mostly leaving the people far away to drown because that will have added fuel costs and they'd rather save that to go fishing on tuesday.
This analogy is already a stretch (I didn’t come up with it, was just responding to someone else), and you’re torturing it beyond reason.
Re:Hit Men Aren't What You Think
by jiggawatts on Saturday December 07, 2024 @02:06AM
(#42347844)
Brian Thompson's net worth was $43M.
He definitely has a yacht or two.
Remember Asimov's rules? A robot may not injure a human being or, through inaction, allow a human being to come to harm. They are one and the same.