They never actually lied about it as such. They just used terms around security a lot in their marketing, and people assumed.
But yeah, similar experience around telegram, I guess somehow it's bucketed as a competitor to Signal and people just expect feature parity ?
Marketing. Specifically, very aggressive marketing that used a combination of "you can't trust them, we're the only ones keeping you safe" messaging re: WhatsApp and exaggerating+exploiting complaints about Signal and Moxie Marlinspike, to get support from earnest-but-uninformed tech types who went on to evangelize it to others, thinking they were doing a good thing for the world (like the early days of Firefox). It was a very cynical campaign and depressing how well it worked, even after their hand-rolled crypto was broken like a day after the initial fanfare-filled release.
To me, that doesn't sound like technical "enough". And that's not more dangerous than non-technical people trusting a website saying "we secure your data with military-grade encryption".
I tried to explain this fact to a lot of my friends but I always received of pushback, "it can't be true", "of course it's encrypted, it says on the web page it's secure!", etc. I cannot think of any other occasion where the reality of a situation is the exact opposite of what people think.
How did Telegram achieve perpetuating this lie? And more importantly, how do we stop it? What is a good resource to provide to people who think this is true? I usually send them an article written by Matthew Green[1], but it has always been dismissed as just "some dude's blog".
A lot of people are technical just enough to become dangerous. When I explained the problem to a lot of my friends they ran wireshark on the network connection and they saw gibberish. From this they have erroneously concluded they are safe...
[1] https://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2024/08/25/telegram...