News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Vintage digicams aren't just a fad. They're an artistic s... by crazygringo on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @07:46AM (#42305553)
What did he mean by CD distortion?

I'm also not super clear on how digital video would have jitter in a way that analog video wouldn't?

I totally agree with his overall sentiment, I'm just a bit confused on the specific examples.

Re:Vintage digicams aren't just a fad. They're an artistic s... by jcarrano on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @08:35AM (#42305875)
I read that, at least early on, many CDs were mastered with inadequate dithering, resulting in audible quantization noise.
Re:Vintage digicams aren't just a fad. They're an artistic s... by nayuki on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @07:28PM (#42313297)
Good questions. CD distortion include hard clipping from amplifying too much, whereas vacuum tubes and magnetic tape have soft saturation (still a distortion, just a different kind). Another distortion is that dynamic range compression is used, bringing up the volume of quiet parts of a song.

As for digital video jitter, I can think of MPEG compression artifacts, both spatial (e.g. DCT mosquito noise) and temporal (e.g. motion compensation errors, periodic keyframe refreshes).

Re:Vintage digicams aren't just a fad. They're an artistic s... by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @07:55PM (#42313463)
That is bad mastering, not an inherent property of CDs.
Re:Vintage digicams aren't just a fad. They're an artistic s... by shiroiushi on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @08:33PM (#42313669)
It's not, but it's very, very common, basically the rule in fact, starting I think in the early 2000s.
Re:Vintage digicams aren't just a fad. They're an artistic s... by numpad0 on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @03:45AM (#42315651)
There is something in CD that is noticeable by listening to vinyl, CD, and optionally mp3. I'd say CD makes everything sound like a harpsichord, but just ever so slightly. Maybe it's encoding or maybe it's decoding. Or something else. It's a first generation digital format, after all.

Analog videos never stutter but digital formats tend to have non-constant processing cost and do stutter occasionally. Maybe he's referring to that?

Re:Vintage digicams aren't just a fad. They're an artistic s... by crazygringo on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @07:37AM (#42316839)
> I'd say CD makes everything sound like a harpsichord

Ha, that's a great description. Yes -- you're hearing more high frequencies.

Which is by design, because they're there in real life. Vinyl cuts off the highest frequencies, as do MP3's.

Nothing to do with first generation though -- if you listen to a FLAC on your computer with wired headphones the highest frequencies are still there.

It's a feature not a bug. :)