News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by neilv on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @03:56AM (#42304243)
> > Y Combinator was the sort of unforgiving power player that remembered the names of investors who had crossed portfolio companies in the past, or who had disseminated unflattering portraits of YC, and blacklisted them from any YC dealings, or from the minds of YC founders.

Do we have to be careful what we say on HN?

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by jf on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @04:25AM (#42304404)
Not any more than you need to in any public forum
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by adastra22 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @04:56AM (#42304559)
Not the point. One should be allowed to be critical of the institutions of the valley without getting their name written down in a secret blacklist.
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by tomhoward on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @08:29AM (#42305819)
YC will fund anyone who is building a company that looks like it could be highly successful.

There's one case I'm thinking of now where someone was as critical of YC (both the org and individual leaders) as anyone could possibly be, in a highly public and sustained way, and their startup later got funded by YC.

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by adastra22 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @10:01AM (#42306805)
Well that is contrary to what is stated in the article/book.
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by tomhoward on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @04:21PM (#42311616)
What in the article (sentence or paragraph) contradicts what I wrote?

The article is about how YC defended one of its funded companies against a legal attack. It doesn’t say anything about YC refusing to fund someone who criticized it.

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by adastra22 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @04:55PM (#42311981)
> Y Combinator was the sort of unforgiving power player that remembered the names of investors who had crossed portfolio companies in the past, *or who had disseminated unflattering portraits of YC*, and blacklisted them from any YC dealings, or from the minds of YC founders

If you said something unflattering about YC once and got uninvited from demo day, that's on you. But being black listed from ever investing in any YC-backed startup even if you reach out to founders directly is taking things too far. And potentially an antitrust issue. Cabals are illegal, after all.

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by tomhoward on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @10:38PM (#42314302)
The quoted book was being purposefully colorful and inflammatory for literary effect, but it still doesn’t make any claims of investors being “blacklisted” just because they said something unflattering about YC. (“Disseminating unflattering portraits” implies some kind of organised campaign to damage YC, and I have no idea if that really happened or if it’s just part of the colorful/exaggerated writing).

The only cases I know of where an investor was banished from Demo Day/YC’s network was for acting in bad faith towards founders. If YC banished investors who had a track record of being great to founders, they would be doing a disservice to founders, and therefore acting against YC’s own interests.

That aside, my original comment doesn’t contradict anything in the article (I can’t speak for the entire book - honestly when I tried reading it I couldn’t get past the first few pages).

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by adastra22 on Wednesday December 04, 2024 @07:53AM (#42316956)
That's good to know, thanks.
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by JoshTriplett on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @10:45AM (#42307370)
Which case was that?
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by acdha on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @08:46AM (#42305971)
That’s an ideal but how would that work short of stringent government regulation? It’s never been easier to mine text and since YC is giving people large sums of money they have both a valid reason and broad deference to their assessment of applicants. VC isn’t like a car or home loan so I don’t think there’s anyway you could cut out bias less blatant than circulating a list of racial slurs or explicit threats of retaliation for funding people: since they’re basically making a large unsecured loan there’s simply too much justifiable discretion to exclude something like reviewing posting history.
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by adastra22 on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @09:59AM (#42306784)
This is the traditional role of regulation, yes. Note that if what they were filter out for were things like union sympathies, it would be illegal.
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by acdha on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @10:09AM (#42306894)
Yes, but how would you tell? Unless they straight up tell you why you were turned down it’s really hard to know what someone was thinking when they say “I just didn’t think they had the right idea”.
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by ChrisMarshallNY on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @04:48AM (#42304521)
Not because of YC. I think that what people say here, is only a fairly small data point, for them.

But I would encourage folks to consider their approach, in general, whenever we are in a professional context (and, despite the casual nature of HN, this is very much a “professional context”).

I think that some few people here, are able to post in a truly anonymous fashion, but most folks could be doxxed fairly easily, if they piss off the wrong people (not always movers and shakers; we have some truly amazing talent, hereabouts).

In my case, I just make it clear who I am, and post carefully (I know it may not seem so, but look closer). I learned, long ago, that I’m not actually able to maintain true anonymity, so I don’t even try.

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by kmmlng on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:29AM (#42304748)
I think it's important to distinguish between two directions here: 1) can someone figure out who I am based on my profile and 2) can someone find my profile if they know who I am. I care much more about the second, because the odds of someone attempting the second are much higher.
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by ChrisMarshallNY on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @06:23AM (#42305027)
Well, back when I was looking for work, a couple of companies asked for my HN handle (actually, it's one of the reasons that I got an account, here).

It was fairly obvious, that I would not be considered, if I didn't have one.

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by RGamma on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @07:18AM (#42305367)
That explains a lot.
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by ChrisMarshallNY on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @08:03AM (#42305654)
Eh. We all have our origin stories.

Turned out that I didn't really feel like working with companies that require HN handles, and they didn't feel like working with past-their-prime engineers, so it's all good.

I stuck around, and folks generally seem to feel I'm a decent member, here. A few curmudgeons don't like me, but, when you're "on the spectrum," you get pretty used to folks not liking you, for no discernible reason. I've found that being true to myself, means that it doesn't really matter, all that much. I've had really dangerous people not like me, IRL, so this joint is Amateur Hour.

I try to be a decent member here, and not bring darkness (I'm quite capable of it). Some folks think that makes me "stuffy," or "snobby."

Whatever creams your Twinkie. I'm actually a pretty decent person, and it's probably worth it, to get to know me. I won't make you rich, but I'm also no threat to anyone (and have no desire to be).

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by paganel on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @09:35AM (#42306461)
> a couple of companies asked for my HN handle

That's kind of shitty. I'm writing this down as in the last 2-3 years I've started to care less and less about any perceived veil (or hypocrisy, to be more honest) on websites like this one but it's still interesting to see that companies filter out potential employees based on that manifested hypocrisy. That explains a lot of how come SV is in the slump that it is right now (ignoring the AI bubble), but that's matter for a different discussion.

We all have to be well-behaved hackers and painters, or else. That's not how it worked in the past, and it will never work like that.

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by ChrisMarshallNY on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:00PM (#42308373)
Well, behaving well (even "fake nice") isn't necessarily "hypocrisy."

All of us, and I mean ALL OF US have dark fantasy lives. Freud called it our "Id."

It's not meant to be worn outside our heads.

One of the common refrains that you'll hear from fans of "hatemongers," like Alex Jones and Rush Limbaugh, is "They're just saying what everyone is thinking!".

There's a reason that we don't say everything that we think.

That's not hypocrisy. That's being a good member of society.

I have good friends -like, actually really good friends, who hold beliefs that I disagree with -sometimes, quite strongly.

We don't talk about that stuff, when we're together.

That's not hypocrisy, either. That's being friends. We find that there are a lot more values that we hold in common, than in opposition.

Modern social media has made it fashionable to use society as a public toilet for our Ids. I don't think that it has improved things.

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by paganel on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @12:42PM (#42308855)
It is my belief that when it comes to politics, i.e. the life of the polis, it is in the best interest of said polis for its citizens to speak up their mind as closer to (their inner) truth as possible, otherwise it won’t be said citizens conducting the life of their polis.

The Freud/id stuff I can understand (and I agree with), but that’s related to a person’s inner “psychological” life, not to the polis as a whole.

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by ChrisMarshallNY on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @01:25PM (#42309428)
I think when it comes to workplaces, it isn't really the same thing as the political arena (office "politics" aside). Personal restraint is fairly important. I have worked very closely, with people I desperately wanted to strangle, and we did good work.

Also, even in the political arena, there's often a need for personal restraint. My family has been in international diplomacy for decades (I'm the redneck engineer).

My father[0] used to constantly pop my "Simple wrong answer" balloons, on a regular, by explaining that nothing that involves humans, is ever actually simple, and that there are always dozens of competing forces at work; much of it sloppy emotions, pride, poverty, insecurity, tribalism, ignorance, religion, greed, and whatnot.

I have other family that has worked for decades, trying to get different faiths to work together, to address issues like poverty, lack of education, etc.

Talk about "herding cats."

Someone (I think Will Rogers) used to say "Diplomacy is the art of saying 'Nice doggie,' while reaching for a rock."

[0] https://cmarshall.com/miscellaneous/MikeMarshall.htm

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by fallingknife on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:16AM (#42304677)
So they won't do business with people that have crossed them or insulted them in the past? Regardless of whether they were in the right that's kind of just how people act, but phrased in a way to sound dramatic. You are not entitled to invest in whatever company you want.
Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by brudgers on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @07:45AM (#42305541)
If you want to associate with the people at YC, it probably makes some sense to behave like the kind of person that people at YC are likely to want to associate with.

The Adchemy’s investors were funding a lawsuit against a startup. I imagine from YC’s perspective, that kind of thing was considered bad for the ecosystem.

By which I mean nobody involved was going to make money. There’s no blood in a stone. The lawsuit was not in anyone’s business interest. The article states it was even contrary to an unwritten rule of the startup culture.

Re:Y Combinator and Power in Silicon Valley by propoganda on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @09:48AM (#42306620)
Yes. Michael O’Church learned that the hard way. But he warned us afterwards.