News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by lupusreal on Monday December 02, 2024 @12:22PM (#42298243)
> Silk residues were successfully detected, which confirmed the early use of silk as a material carrier to communicate between Heaven and Earth

That last bit seemed to jump out of nowhere. Maybe I'm missing some implications of the grid-like oval bronze thing? Very mysterious.

Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by hosh on Monday December 02, 2024 @12:50PM (#42298512)
All the authors are Chinese. They might have been confirming a cultural transmission about the origins of using silk that otherwise had no direct archaeological evidence.

They got a bit of the history of the Silk Roads incomplete. The Silk Roads, as it is understood now, isn't just about trading in silk, but the idea that the ancient world was connected and globalized through an extensive trade network. It isn't just overland routes, but also maritime routes for spice trade with India, and connections from North Africa deep into the interior of the African continent. Paper was worth more than silk along the Silk Roads. However, from the lens of Chinese history, silk was something that the Chinese monopolized for a while and was sought after by other cultures and civilizations connected through the Silk Roads.

Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by hinkley on Monday December 02, 2024 @01:04PM (#42298629)
I wonder how different African history would be if there were a major river emptying into the Indian Ocean instead of rather small ones. You have some minor rivers and the Red Sea. Not great for making a trading superpower like Egypt.
Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by shagie on Monday December 02, 2024 @03:34PM (#42300112)
One of the recent videos that I watched was RealLifeLore : How Africa’s Geography Traps it in Endless Poverty https://youtu.be/Y8m95sCDEf0

A chunk of it is about the nature of the lack of good harbors along the coast that would be able to shelter trading ships from the open ocean.

Zanzibar is the noted example of a port https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zanzibar#Before_1498

> From the 9th century, Swahili merchants on Zanzibar operated as brokers for long-distance traders from both the hinterland and Indian Ocean world. Persian, Indian, and Arab traders frequented Zanzibar to acquire East African goods like gold, ivory, and ambergris and then shipped them overseas to Asia. Similarly, caravan traders from the African Great Lakes and Zambezian Region came to the coast to trade for imported goods, especially Indian cloth. Before the Portuguese arrival, the southern towns of Unguja Ukuu and Kizimkazi and the northern town of Tumbatu were the dominant centres of exchange.

Even the large rivers that do empty into the ocean, they have significant portions of rapids that make it impractical to use as a trading route.

Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by olddustytrail on Monday December 02, 2024 @01:14PM (#42298736)
You mean like the Ethiopian Empire?
Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by jhwhite on Monday December 02, 2024 @12:27PM (#42298285)
I'm probably wrong but since it was discovered in a sacrificial pit I assumed the bronze age people burned the silk as a way to "communicate with heaven".
Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by pempem on Monday December 02, 2024 @12:34PM (#42298362)
Still, a very pretty sentence for an abstract.
Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by mikhailfranco on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @05:00AM (#42304578)
Silk does not burn in normal flame.

If you are buying a 'silk' garment it is common to ask the shop-keeper to hold it to a cigarette lighter to prove it does not contain a synthetic petroleum-based fabric, such as polyester.

Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by jihadjihad on Monday December 02, 2024 @12:48PM (#42298492)
They talk about it later on:

> Similarly, silk was also used as a sacrificial object, such as in the form of silk books or paintings on silk, with the silk serving as a carrier to convey the content of the calligraphy and painting upon it to Heaven.

But it does seem that there is some context that would be helpful here, at least for this Western reader.

Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by AlotOfReading on Monday December 02, 2024 @12:46PM (#42298473)
A Western academic would phrase it very differently. If you read the paper, they claim that a document called the "Jiatu Zhijia" describes a very similar object called a jiatu that supposedly resembles a divine turtle that caused legendary emperor Yao to abdicate to Shun, i.e. acting as a material carrier between heaven and earth.

I can't actually find other English uses of that name, and while I can guess that they're referring to one of a small set of documents discussing the (possibly mythological) abdication of Yao, those documents were written thousands of years after the events. I'm not wholly opposed to the argument, but you should explicitly justify it in cases like this instead of accepting the symbolism uncritically.

Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by powerapple on Monday December 02, 2024 @01:22PM (#42298819)
Chinese burn paper items, such as paper money, when paying respects to their ancestors. We believe it will go to the other world.

It is actually common in other cultures as well.

Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by gota on Monday December 02, 2024 @12:37PM (#42298384)
I'm noy bothered by it but I wonder if it betrays some sort of religious belief from the authors? Which ideally should be either avoided or disclaimed explicitly
Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by NateEag on Monday December 02, 2024 @04:07PM (#42300407)
Why does religious belief require a disclaimer?

Do other philosophical positions, like atheism or panpsychism?

Re:Evidence of the use of silk by Bronze Age civilization by OJFord on Tuesday December 03, 2024 @10:24AM (#42307111)
If you want your writing to be taken as establishing facts, you need to base it on a priori established facts; if you base it on hypotheses and beliefs then you're just expanding on the hypothesis, contributing further belief.

I suspect though that it's not the author's beliefs, just an ambiguously written way of saying that it was done by those people with that belief - in the same way that an atheist or follower of some other religion may say that Christians pray in order to communicate their wishes to God. Of course there is the rude and angry for no clear reason brand of atheist who could never bring themselves to say such a thing, but to the rest of us there is no problem in describing someone else's actions by their own reasons for doing them, even if we don't share that motivation. I have colleagues who run for pleasure; though I do not for mine.